• On MovieTome: See the villain of IRON MAN 2!
November 5, 2009 2:08 PM PST

Why crutches may soon be relics of the past

by Elizabeth Armstrong Moore
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 17 comments
Freedom Leg

The Freedom Leg is 2.5 pounds.

(Credit: Forward Mobility)

Anyone who's ever worn crutches knows they are a pain at best. It's bad enough trying to walk, let alone surviving stairs, and we haven't even gotten to the underarm chafing.

Forward Mobility to the rescue. The Edmonds, Wash.-based company, which got its start manufacturing bicycles in the 1990s, is now designing and manufacturing a slew of medical mobility products, from a collapsible wheelchair to a seated scooter for foot and leg injuries. The Freedom Leg, released at MedTrade in October, functions like a hands-free brace. In the company's words:

Go beyond the limitations of crutches, wheelchairs, or scooters. It is truly an off-loading prosthetic that allows the user to fully integrate the device into their lives, giving them complete mobility. The user has the ability to accomplish all their normal day-to-day tasks without assistance, while at the same time keeping the strength in upper muscles of the injured leg.

According to "Emma" in the video, who broke her foot, the Freedom Leg transfers the weight of her step to her upper leg, enabling her to continue to use the muscles in her leg as she moves around without compromising the progress of her mending foot, which remains in a cast.

Forward Mobility is a finalist for $100,000 in grants from business magazine Inc. The company is among 13 entrepreneurs featured in a reader election that runs through Friday on Inc.'s Web site.

Part of Forward Mobility's popularity is not just its inventions, but its philosophy. The founders work with an organization in Vietnam, Kids First Enterprise, to manufacture its devices; 20 percent of the organization's workforce has disabilities, and all profits go to projects that support the disabled and disadvantaged.

When I talked to Bill Borders, VP of sales, by phone Thursday, he told me the device retails for about $350. "It's hard to compare it to a regular knee brace," he adds. "There's nothing like it that allows people to 100 percent off-load, hands-free. In that sense it's pretty revolutionary. And because you are putting some weight-bearing load on your injured leg, it really reduces the muscle atrophy in that leg."

We'll have to wait and see whether this invention takes off, and even though it looks like the underarm chafing issue of crutches has merely migrated down to the thigh, I'd take the hands-free device over crutches any day.

Elizabeth Armstrong Moore is a freelance journalist based in Portland, Ore. She has contributed to Wired magazine, The Christian Science Monitor, and public radio. Her semi-obscure hobbies include unicycling, slacklining, hula-hooping, scuba diving, billiards, Sudoku, Magic the Gathering, and classical piano. She is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET.
advertisement
 
Remove up to 2x more plaque* with an Oral-B electric toothbrush.
*Oral-B ProfessionalCare series vs. a regular manual toothbrush
Recent posts from Health Tech
Bedside vital signs monitor goes mobile
Germ alert: Attack of the killer necktie!
Philips' Ambient Experience relaxes heart patients
iPhone app scans bar codes for health, enviro ratings
A stethoscope app? Be still my beating heart
IBM chip to speed medical diagnostic testing
A new antidepressant really turns women on
Finding safe toys this holiday season
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (17 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by Rants&Raves November 5, 2009 2:29 PM PST
Q: Doesn't it inhibit the blood flow that is beneficial to recovery ?
Reply to this comment
by swiftmed November 5, 2009 3:06 PM PST
I am personally disabled, and cannot walk without crutches, so id love nothing more than to go through day-to-day life with my hands free to do something else, so i like the idea, however the only way this product will truly go global and really take off is if they sort their pricing out.

Right now, hospitals, people with disabilities etc are bound to go for the crutches option because 1, its proven and 2, its very cheap.

I understand when they start making bulk orders for these products, the price will eventually come down, but if they are serious about making this product take off, they need to look at their pricing.
Reply to this comment
by cpwatt November 5, 2009 3:11 PM PST
This is awesome! I just had foot surgery a few weeks ago, and this would have been a godsend, as I have 5 year-old twins, and the scooter/crutch combination is sorely lacking for mobility. Not to mention tough on the ego - fell last night on my crutches on the wet pavement - ouch, and "scooting" along into work is so dorky - total strangers have absolutely no problem laughing at me, and I kind of can't blame them! If it really works, I hope it takes off and I hope the insurance companies "hop" on board and cover it.
Reply to this comment
by jpmays November 5, 2009 3:35 PM PST
Get over it! Who cares if someone snickers at you or has a little laugh at your expense? Sure it's not right and it's not fun... but IT'S ONLY TEMPORARY! It's not a permanent condition, so stop feeling sorry for yourself!

I myself have a disability that confines me to my wheelchair all of the time... you just need to learn to smile at strangers and then ask them to take your picture because it lasts longer! It's a Kodak moment!
by ejhayes76 November 5, 2009 3:38 PM PST
I don't think cpwatt was feeling sorry for themselves. Not sure how you got that from their post.
by rmullen0 November 5, 2009 4:49 PM PST
Strangers laughing at a person on crutches. Sounds like they're morons. This is almost like when the lady died in the ER and was laying on the floor dead and no one even bothered to check to see what was wrong or do anything. They just let her lay there on the floor for hours. Makes you wonder what kind of losers there are in this country. The fact that Bush got in twice says something I guess.
by c|net Reader November 6, 2009 6:39 AM PST
@rmuullen0

Do you overreact much? The OP referred to "'scooting' along" which suggests something other/more than walking with crutches. It suggests something odd, if not funny. The OP even said it "is so dorky." Thus, those laughing were merely reacting to the oddity or humor in what seems a perfectly normal way.

Your reference to a story about a woman dying in an ER with no one stopping to check on her sounds unfortunate, but having no details, I can't comment on the specifics. However, those working in ERs are usually hard working, caring people. If they were too busy to notice the woman, or assumed that she was asleep, etc., they can't be called losers.

Finally, calling former President Bush and those who voted for him losers is ridiculous. I can infer that you voted for President Obama and, as much as I disagree with your decision and his policies, that hardly makes you horrible people or losers. I can think of you as misguided, misinformed, etc., but those don't make you "losers."

You needn't belittle those that disagree with you or have a different way of looking at things. Furthermore, you need to think a little more critically about what you read and what others say before jumping to conclusions.
by ghaff November 5, 2009 3:17 PM PST
It looks really clever. A price of $350 is really nothing compared to all the other costs that are probably associated with someone who has to wear crutches for some reason. The big question I would have is how robust and foolproof is it--i.e. what's the possibility of it sliding up by accident and suddenly putting weight on the foot or leg in a way that could undo weeks of healing. I'm sure that's been thought about but it's what jumped into my head.
Reply to this comment
by Chuck McKnight November 5, 2009 3:20 PM PST
Is it just me, or does that look exceedingly uncomfortable? I guess I'd have to try it, but at a glance it looks much more annoying than a crutch. The picture makes it seem like it would be cutting circulation off from the bottom of the leg.
Reply to this comment
by maleds November 5, 2009 4:44 PM PST
Will this be of help with those who have had a knee replacement,or broken their leg bones???
Reply to this comment
by jparkes1 November 5, 2009 4:47 PM PST
Great tech, I can imagine a variant that some double amputees could use to stand perhaps even walk.
The question is; how do we get these to everyone world wide who needs them, land mine victims are more numerous than you can imagine. Unfortunately the majority are in third world countries and the cost is for most more than a year's pay. It's also unthinkable that a veteran not have access to this technology, IUD's are responsible for a lot of amputees coming out of the middle east right now.
Reply to this comment
by ittesi259 November 6, 2009 12:31 PM PST
There already is tech for double amputees....did you not watch the last summer olympics that had a double amputee competing in track?
by Super2online November 5, 2009 4:54 PM PST
I snapped my tip and fib in half right above the ankle and was in a cast for a month before surgery and rehabilitation for a year. While crutches are a major pain, they gave me the mobity I wanted. Stairs are dangerous but I was very good with them and never had a problem. However, I can easily see where others might.

This looks like a great improvement over crutches but I"m sure they too have some drawbacks. I wish this company well as they sound like they are very interested in helping people overcome serious disabilities.
Reply to this comment
by contagionofcompassion November 5, 2009 5:55 PM PST
When a person's mobility is compromised, getting around on any device can be difficult. It sounds like Forward Mobility is trying to improve mobility options for people. I have used crutches and ended up with strains on my upper body - shoulders and arms. This looks like a really good way to get around. I guess it may take getting used to but so did the crutches and after 4 weeks, I still couldn't really get used to them.
Reply to this comment
by Hammerhand November 6, 2009 12:04 AM PST
She's glad to carry a cup of liquid without having to ask the _maid_ to do it? (And she gets a dig in at English teachers too.)

That's the market for this device... People with more money than brains.
Reply to this comment
by diadmer November 6, 2009 8:16 AM PST
Whoa there, Hammerhand, check your biases and check your hearing. She said "having to wait for *somebody* to do it for me."
by Stormspace November 6, 2009 6:55 AM PST
My grandfather had prosthetic legs that worked very much like this, except the knee was hinged. The legs placed all the weight on the upper thigh and knee instead of the missing bits below the knee. He paid thousands of dollars for his two legs so I hope this thing is cheaper. The construction certainly looks cheaper than what he had.
Reply to this comment
(17 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

E-tailers linked to 'scam' blame customers

Priceline, Classmates.com, and Orbitz say customers should read the fine print before complaining about being charged to join loyalty programs they didn't want.

The 411 on early-termination fees

Verizon Wireless has doubled its early-termination fees for smartphones, but what does it mean for the rest of the industry?

advertisement

About Health Tech

From advancements in electronic health records to cutting-edge surgical tools, CNET covers the medical-technology news buzzing through operating and waiting rooms.

Add this feed to your online news reader

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right