Wetpaint offers up wikis for Facebook: I don't get it
Wetpaint is officially launching their whiteboard wiki app for Facebook tomorrow morning, although it's been alive and kicking in Facebook's apps directory for the past two weeks. The idea behind it is about as simple as it gets--just stick an entire Wetpaint wiki inside of Facebook, and edit things with your Facebook friends. In addition to a blank canvas to do whatever you want with, the service has also included student-geared templates to get you going, including a notes tool, party planner, and dorm hall wiki. The real draw here is that you'll be able to start making and sharing Wetpaint wikis without the need to sign up for the service, and be able to be share any of your creations via URL to people outside of Facebook. The only catch is that your Facebook-created wikis won't show up on Wetpaint's main site, at least not yet.
Make widget-filled wikis right inside of Facebook using Wetpaint's Whiteboard Wiki app.
(Credit: CNET Networks)What I don't get about the whole app is why you'd want to use some of these templates inside of Facebook. For example, the selling point of the party invitation app is that you can set up RSVPs and upload photos and videos. You can already do all these things in Facebook using the first-party events app that everyone's got by default. The same thing goes for class notes, which encourages grouping and discussion forums--something which is also available for everyone right off the bat with Facebook groups.
Speaking of groups, Wetpaint also goes a step beyond, by auto-creating a wiki for every group you're a member of. On the surface, this might seem like a handy way to help you get started in your wiki indeavors, although it feels more like the service is attempting to drag participation and interaction away from Facebook's group, and into their own domain.
The real saving grace of this app is that you can add third-party widgets onto one big page along with the rest of your content--something I had wanted after taking a look at the Amnesty Hypercube Facebook app last week. The fact that you can drop any old embed code to create a new widget means you're getting a lot of extensibility with one app. This is the kind of thing that can open up creativity and participation. Trying to piggyback on Facebook's successful, and easy-to-use features with a whole other system--not so much. Hopefully Wetpaint can find a balance.
Josh Lowensohn writes for Webware.com, CNET's blog about Web applications and services. E-mail Josh, or follow him on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/Josh. 
It has been designed to be very easy to use (my grandmother could use it): no overcrowded sidebar of misleading feature links.
I was wondering if you might clarify your point on some of the features within
the Wetpaint application as being "misleading." Based on the feedback from
users who've added the Wiki Whiteboard and those who've created over
600,000 Wetpaint wiki sites outside of Facebook, we were pretty certain the
features performed as described. However, if that isn't the case, we'd love to
get working on it to make the Wetpaint experience even better. Any insight
would be appreciated.
Best of luck to you and your Facebook wiki application.
Kevin
Wetpaint
- Wikimono wikis for Facebook
- by RGeronimi October 16, 2007 12:19 PM PDT
- Wikimono (http://www.wikimono.com/) also offers straightforward wikis for Facebook.
- Like this Reply to this comment
-
-
- "Misleading Feature Links" - Can you clarify?
- by kbflaherty October 16, 2007 8:39 PM PDT
- Hi Raphael,
- Like this
-
(4 Comments)It has been designed to be very easy to use (my grandmother could use it): no overcrowded sidebar of misleading feature links.
I was wondering if you might clarify your point on some of the features within
the Wetpaint application as being "misleading." Based on the feedback from
users who've added the Wiki Whiteboard and those who've created over
600,000 Wetpaint wiki sites outside of Facebook, we were pretty certain the
features performed as described. However, if that isn't the case, we'd love to
get working on it to make the Wetpaint experience even better. Any insight
would be appreciated.
Best of luck to you and your Facebook wiki application.
Kevin
Wetpaint