Ten issues I have with Twitter (and its community)
We all know and love Twitter, but it's not perfect. A few months ago, I used these pages to tell you what I liked about Twitter and what I didn't.
Since then, Twitter has undergone some major changes. It has enjoyed worldwide acclaim. It has a new design. And its community is bigger than ever.
All those things are great. But I'm not as happy with it as I could be. Unfortunately, I've found some issues with Twitter and its community that need to be addressed.
Five Twitter issues
1. The "more" has to go Say what you will about Twitter's new design, but sifting through the stream is too difficult. In the previous design, I was able to click the "next" button to get to older tweets. From there, I could quickly change the URL in the address bar to get to the page I wanted. For example, if I wanted to refer back to a tweet that, by now, was on page three, all I needed to do was change the "page=1" command to "page=3." Once it loaded, I was on the right page.
But in Twitter's new design, it requires me to keep hitting "more" to see tweets. It's a real annoyance. Quickly getting to the tweet I want to find takes too long. And although it makes the site more "Web 2.0," I don't like it. Bring back the "next" option, Twitter.
No more more, please.
(Credit: Screenshot by Don Reisinger/CNET)2. Down times are back For a while, Twitter was on its game. There were so few down times, it seemed the Fail Whale was finally in the past. But as of late, I've noticed many more down times on the service. Almost each day, it's down for a minute or two at a time. It's not nearly as bad as it used to be, but it's still present. Down times have been a problem with Twitter since the beginning. They need to be averted.
3. Search still sucks Sorry, but Twitter Search doesn't even compare to some of the third-party apps available on the Web. I've used it on numerous occasions and each time, I'm left wanting more. So, I followed CNET Editor Rafe Needleman's advice and tried out Twazzup. It's more robust than Twitter's search. It helps me find results more quickly. Don't waste your time with Twitter Search. I don't.
Twitter Search isn't as good as it could be.
(Credit: Screenshot by Don Reisinger/CNET)4. Security is a problem Although I've yet to be affected by a Twitter security problem, it's starting to become a concern. In the past six months alone, Twitter has been affected by several security flaws. Some have been worse than others, but considering many of them have something to do with phishing attacks and malware, they're all worth being worried about.
Twitter needs to enhance security. It's not nearly as secure as it should be. It might still the "place to be" if you're a social-networking fanatic, but it's also attracting malicious hackers. And that's not good.
5. It still doesn't have groups I know I've complained about this for as long as I can remember, but it's still a major issue I have with Twitter. I think groups could transform the experience. It would help bloggers target their readers more effectively, it could help celebrities form communities around their talents, and it would help companies communicate with employees. It just seems like the next logical step for the service and so far, it hasn't delivered. That's too bad.
Five Twitter community issues
1. Ditch the spammers In recent months, there has been a severe upswing in the number of spammers targeting Twitter. Every day, I see some portion of my stream invaded by spammers trying to get me to click on links to all kinds that bring me to fake products and schemes. It used to be an annoyance, but now, it's getting ridiculous. Something needs to be done.
2. Enough with the special days Although #FollowFriday is a favorite of some, I've found that many users are starting to come up with days of their own. Tune Thursday comes to mind. So does Wacky Wednesday, where one of my followers asked users to share a "wacky moment with everybody else." Ugh. Just stop. Please.
First off, alliteration isn't that cool. Secondly, we don't need special days. Let's just stick to talking about interesting stuff. It's so much cooler that way.
Enough with all the special days.
(Credit: Screenshot by Don Reisinger/CNET)3. Following promises need to go I'm sick and tired of people who use their Twitter accounts to tell you how to add "1,000 followers in a single day!" First off, it ruins the Twitter experience. Secondly, most of those techniques require you to follow people who follow everyone else. For the most part, that means you'll be following people who will spam you. These scams need to be actively eradicated.
4. There's too much linkage I'll be the first to admit that I engage in too much linking. Every article I write goes to Twitter. But at the same time, I don't like the community's reliance on links. I realize that Twitter is a great way to get news and I know it's a place to share cool stuff. But at the same time, I do want to hear what people have to say. I'm following you for a reason--I want to know what you think. Tell me, instead of regurgitating a news headline and sending a link along.
Twitter and all that tracking needs to go.
(Credit: Screenshot by Don Reisinger/CNET)5. We need more celebrities to care Although I applaud some celebrities (like Ashton Kutcher) who use Twitter as a platform to communicate with fans, there are still far too many celebs who use their assistants to do the tweeting. Yes, it's nice to know that you have a concert coming up, but let's hear what you think about it. We want to know what your life is like. We want to understand more about you. Using an assistant to update your stream won't do that.
Oh, and while you're at it, follow me on Twitter.
Don Reisinger is a technology columnist who has written about everything from HDTVs to computers to Flowbee Haircut Systems. Don is a member of the CNET Blog Network, and posts at The Digital Home. He is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure.




One of the most self important statements ever printed at c.net. "Because I love it, you all must too."
Some of us really don't give a darn about Twitter.
Perhaps you're right...
If there is any retard, it's me for following pornstars. The pornstars themselves are friggin' geniuses! They rock!
Ahahahahahaha!!!!
Perhaps, but it made the beer I was drinking come out my nose when I read it.
Yes, words have an impact. We're human beings, we cling on to words and define our entire world with language. So, if I say "gay" to mean "strange", that's ok? Doesn't that imply that being gay is strange?
That may not be the intention of all those high schoolers, but that's the effect it has whether you like it or not.
And if you say "gay" to mean "homosexual", doesn't that imply that all happy people are gay?
As paulej said, words are words and new meanings are introduced all the time.
http://news.cnet.com/8301-17939_109-10138918-2.html?tag=mncol
harsh but funny :)
In some cases it's worse than Second Life because people are tweeting about their actual mundane lives ("I'm at the Embarcardero BART station!") rather than creating some sort of fictitious, marginally entertaining scenario ("I take off my robe and wizard hat...").
In other cases, there's some actual content. These are either thoughtful, carefully composed posts, or brash, realtime snippets from some attention wh*re's life. Sometimes there's even news (or newslike gossip).
1. Yes, using twitter to make updates like "making breakfast" and other mundane things is quite a waste of time and self-fulfilling. The thought that others really care about such petty little things is funny. However, I think there is a much more useful and reasonable use of Twitter. That is, using it to pose questions, post comments on a certain topic, and otherwise network with those with similar interests. Being a web professional myself, it is very useful to be able to follow other web professionals. I have a constant stream from some of the brightest minds in my field, as well as organizations such as @smashingmag who post regular links to interesting and useful topics. With a large network of followers I can ask questions regarding a web design or development problem and expect a thoughtful answer from people who know what they are talking about. The value in this is indisputable.
2. I really hate how celebrities are bringing Twitter into the forefront like they are. It used to be a smaller network of people using it for the "right" reasons, as described above, with less spam and idiots. Ashton's "race to 1,000,000" was just pathetic and I think really helped to put a negative light on twitter for people not in-the-know. Now, when you mention Twitter at a party or something, you are overwhelmed with things like "ugh, who cares when you are taking a ****" and such, and have to spend an eternity trying to explain to people who don't "get" technology that there are other useful uses for twitter other than what has become stereotypical.
What did it lack? That's right - the narcissistic notion of "followers".
Twitter Search is going through it's growing pains now, but I still find it useful. I see a lot of potential for Twitter Search but we need better spam filters.
"Almost each day, it's down for a minute or two at a time."
Perhaps you're 'twittering' too much of your life away if this is a real problem for you.
You may love, but not we. We do not love any software, nor hardware. People and animals we love...
Maybe I did like the code I wrote early days,, but never loved. And will not love any s/w or h/w or suc!
JJ
I think this is editorialism trying to be a news story when there's no news at all to cover.
As for spamming, it is not an issue for me. I never follow anyone automatically. If a follower profile indicates a spammer, I block them. If a follower's profile and recent tweets are interesting, they get a reciprocal follower.
I can easily read all the tweets from anybody without following them but usually I just dont have the desire to follow a celeb on Twitter. That's what Facebook is for.
It obviously is one, at least to thinking people.
- by fjpoblam July 11, 2009 7:16 AM PDT
- My favorite gripe is still, celebs who either (1) post inane tweets including linkages to articles in their area of "expertise" every three seconds...filling up my wall, or (2) post at a reasonable rate, say once per three hours or so, but NEVER respond to @ replies even though THEY HAVE FOLLOWED YOU.
- Reply to this comment
-
Showing 1 of 2 pages (65 Comments)