• On The Insider: Britney's Bikini-Clad Top 10
April 12, 2007 9:32 AM PDT

CableCard hopes dashed for now

by Rich Brown

It's been over a week since I reported that we got CableCard working on a Velocity Micro CineMagix Grand Theater PC, and I promised that I'd take requests for things to try out. I wish I could deliver. Sadly, 12 hours after we got it working, we lost the signal completely. I haven't reported since then because I wanted to know what the problem was before setting off a wild string of speculation. About all I can confirm is that it still doesn't work.

CableCard or no, we still like Velocity Micro's CineMagix Grand Theater.

(Credit: CNET)

I hoped yesterday I'd either get it working or have an answer as to why it won't stick. Time Warner Cable came out and boosted the cable signal to my apartment. My Internet speed went up, so they definitely did something, but still no CableCard reception. Velocity Micro's Chris Morley then connected remotely into the system and ran through all kinds of trouble shooting steps. No dice. The card diagnostic screens reported that the card and the tuners are paired together properly, but all of the other readings indicating signal strength and such gave us nothing but zeroes.

Our best guess is that somehow between the initial signal loss and ensuing troubleshooting, our pair of CableCards either went bad (which would make them the second off batch), or some setting unknown to either TWC or Velocity Micro (possibly at a firmware level, which would explain why they might not know) is preventing the PC and the cards from seeing each other. I could have TWC come out with yet another set of CableCards, but I'm not confident that would solve the problem, and frankly, I think it's clear CableCard on the PC isn't ready yet. As further evidence, I submit almost every other preview system out there and the installation troubles they've run into.

Regardless of the technical reasons why CableCard is so troublesome, I don't believe that the technology has any insurmountable problems that can't be sorted out. We're mostly frustrated about the timing. Dell and Velocity Micro got everyone's hopes up by showing off these preview systems too early (although Velocity Micro has actually sold a few to a handful of intrepid early adopters). And AMD gets a special share of the blame for letting its TV Wonder OCUR cards out the door before they were fully cooked (which we reported back on March 29th, for the record).

I can't really shame Microsoft or Time Warner Cable, because neither of them have claimed PC-based CableCard is ready yet. I still have hopes that all of the core technology providers will get things together before the end of this year, in time for Microsoft's "official" CableCard launch. Time Warner also told me that, on Microsoft's recommendation (which hopefully means that this will apply to other providers as well) it's likely going to authorize self-installs of CableCard, regardless of the receiving hardware. You'll simply need to get the card(s) and call your provider to authorize them remotely. That means a) you won't have to waste four hours waiting for a tech to show up and b) hopefully the customer service rep will know what you're talking about when you call.

So that's where we're at. I'll revisit CableCard when things are a little more robust. I did manage to record a few shows in HD in the 12 hours it did work (Lennie Briscoe never looked better), so I'll see about answering your questions from the last post as best as I can. I also still have this fairly powerful HTPC sitting in the middle of my living room, along with a handful of input devices, an Xbox 360, and a multiplatform home network. I've held off on all that stuff in the interest of keeping the PC as pristine as possible for troubleshooting purposes. Now that I've put CableCard on the back burner, I think there's still some interesting things to check out here. Anything non-CableCard related you'd like me to check out, hit me up.

Rich Brown reviews desktops and various other components and peripherals for CNET. E-mail Rich.
Recent posts from Crave
I wear my suncontacts at night
Fireplace doubles as pizza oven
Wi-Fi Body Scale Twitters your weight daily
Sponge absorbs 180 times its weight (in toxic sludge)
Prizefight: Motorola Droid vs. iPhone 3GS
Accessories for the iPod Touch
Beware the Blue Yeti
Smartphone users, keep complaining
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (9 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
Non-CableCard Questions
by mcantelon April 12, 2007 5:24 PM PDT
I have none. I have a bazillion CableCard questions ... But that's all.

Thanks for the update Rich. I hope you get everything straightened out quick.

CableCard has been unreliable all over. Hopefully these problems will get worked out as more of us dare to dive into them.

Looking forword to more information (regarding simultaneous use through multiple MCE's--including the Xbox 360) when you are able to find those things out. I want to see how close you can get to the "Windows Vista, CableCard, and you" diagram from November.

I've got the money, and I've got my Velocity Micro PC picked out ... I'm just waiting to see that someone has actually got it working.
Reply to this comment
Cablecard garbage
by jtimouri April 13, 2007 4:13 AM PDT
I had a bad experience with "cablecard" too. Hours of wasted time, we all have been through it with "new" technology, although I thought cablecard was around long enough to work. I gave up on it.
Reply to this comment
Cablecard economics
by dougoxley April 13, 2007 6:08 AM PDT
The real problem is that cable companies do not have an incentive to properly support cablecards. They would rather rent a set-top box for $5-10 per month than a cablecard for less. This also allows some measure of control over how the signal is output.
Reply to this comment
As a last resort try this...
by bgallemore April 13, 2007 6:16 AM PDT
I had a very similar experience with a Sony DHG-500. 2 visits from TWC and getting it woirking only to have it stop. Finally not caring if I nuked it or not I took the card out, rebooted everthing, and with everthing on slaped the card in... it came up with a snyc message and it's been working great for 1 1/2+ years. HTH
Reply to this comment
Hardware problem
by Adeian April 13, 2007 7:24 AM PDT
From what you mention in the article I would say you have a hardware problem. It's either the actual connector where the cable from the wall plugs into the box or the connection between the card that is handling the RF and the cablecard. I work with these things all day and one thing is that signal level is very important. More isn't better as most set top boxes work best in digital mode at between negitive 5 and 10db. Some equipment is so sensitive that much higher than 20 db fries them.

There are other problems with cablecard technology. A cablecard is actually a little tiny set top box running linux. Everytime you boot the cablecard needs to load it's stack then figure out what it's host is and load that stack then if there were no problems load all the guide data and applications and figure out what part of the RF network it belongs too. Although cablecards have been around for awhile none of the cable TV companies head end people have much experience with them. Everytime there is a code update there is also day long conference calls and engineers flying around trying to figure out why the new code doesn't load in the wild.

Things are getting better the closer we get to 7/7/2007 but unless you are willing to be without your digital cable for awhile sometimes and don't mind paying the same amount for less services I would hold off buying anything with a cablecard in it.
Reply to this comment
Cablecard Fiasco
by derekbill April 13, 2007 8:57 AM PDT
Fourteen cards tried over eight visits by three Comcast employees, and still no
reliable service on my TiVO S3. Enough is enough, so I've gone OTA-only.
HOWEVER....now it is apparent that local Albuquerque network outlets are still
buried under the learning curve, as dropouts and miscues are the order of the
day. Jack Bauer fights nukes while I struggle to keep him onscreen. It's truly the
best of times and the worst of times for the early adopter.
Reply to this comment
CableCards In Spokane
by spokanedj April 13, 2007 9:49 AM PDT
I have two Motorola CableCards from Comcast in Spokane, both in Toshiba 65HM15 TVs. I've had both for about six months, self-installed both and haven't had any problems with either card.

Signal strength (like any digital signal) is certainly a factor and I had to re-***** both installations. The cable boxes seem to be a lot more tolerant of weaker or stronger digital signals.
Reply to this comment
Where's the support from the mgf's?
by JohnnyL April 13, 2007 11:20 AM PDT
In all of the above I haven't seen one comment as to any support from the ass hats who actually make the cable cards. Seems like they would be avail for support. You would guess that they know how the card is supposed to work. you would also think that someone would have tested the tech out to see if it works before committing to production.
Reply to this comment
New question about TV Wonder Digital Cable Tuner
by mcantelon April 20, 2007 6:43 AM PDT
Okay Rich; you've been on a hiatus for a few days now and so I've had to do my own reasearch into CableCard and all that, and I've got a new question.

The TV Wonder Digital Cable Tuners you have seem to handle only one stream of data ... They're each acting as single tuners. I figured that this meant that they were only capable of acting as single tuners; but now that M-cards are showing up in the real world, I have to ask:

Does the TV Wonder Digital Cable Tuner support M-cards, and is it capable of handling multiple streams if it has an M-card? Is your dual-device setup a result of limitations of the TV Wonder Digital Cable Tuner? Or just due to a limitation in the CableCards you were issued?
Reply to this comment
(9 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next

About Crave

The name says it all. Crave is our blog about gorgeous gadgets and other crushworthy stuff. If you would like to contact Crave with a tip or comment, please write to: crave@cnet.com

Add this feed to your online news reader

Crave topics

After 5 years, Firefox faces new challenges

Mozilla helped reshape the Web since releasing Firefox 1.0 five years ago. Now it's got a reawakened Microsoft and Google Chrome to reckon with.

There's a map for that: GPS or smartphone?

Almost every handset comes with mapping software these days, but standalone GPS devices are becoming more affordable than ever.