April 4, 2007 12:00 PM PDT

3D desktops

by Donald Bell
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 11 comments
Screenshot of the Beryl 3D desktop

Beryl gives you four desktops to mess up.

While we all wait for Windows Vista to bring the "Wow" and Apple Inc. to drop its Leopard, it's a good time to examine what might make a next-generation computer desktops really cool. One thing is certain; your next desktop will be more 3D and have task-juggling capabilities to satisfy even the most ADD among us.

BumpTop is a physics-based desktop prototype meant to behave as much as possible like an actual desk. It debuted last June but is getting renewed attention from the developer's presentation at Demo Camp in Montreal. With BumpTop, files can be thrown into loose piles, tidied into neat stacks, or fanned out like a deck of cards. BumpTop looks like good fun, but the Type A part of my personality shudders to think that my computer's desktop could look just as messy and cluttered as my physical desktop.

If you want an experimental desktop to play around with now, you can install a Linux-based operating system called Beryl that goes absolutely nuts with 3D. This is a multitasker's dream platform that not only uses an OS X Expose-like method for juggling windows but goes a step further by letting you juggle four distinct desktops across a 3D cube. There are tons of Beryl 3D videos up on YouTube (that's right, popular videos of people showing off their desktops), but here's one with a soundtrack and a presumably caffeinated user.

Will we see features like these in a conventional Windows or Apple operating system? Maybe not. Will the alpha geeks among us take up the cause of tactile 3D computer interfaces and 3D desktop systems in an effort to impress the girls? Undoubtedly.

Donald Bell is CNET Reviews' senior editor for MP3 players and portable audio, and one half of the MP3 Insider blog and weekly podcast. He also likes getting his hands dirty with digital audio tools for musicians and DJs.
Recent posts from Crave
Japan university develops see-through fish
Robots in 2009: The wackier, the better
Time Warner Cable shows subscribers how to cut cord
Times Square New Year's Eve Ball, a timeline
Want to see Google's new phone on YouTube?
Photographers bless improved Canon autofocus
Gadgettes Podcast 168: The Web obviously-not-exclusive-at-all-anymore Episode
Report: Apple event to be held January 26
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (11 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
Linux has changed alot in just a short time...
by JWilliams06 April 4, 2007 3:10 PM PDT
This is truly evident by what off-work programmers are able to do with "legacy" hardware. While Microsoft's tagline is "Wow" for Windows Vista; in all honesty - anyone that has been around a computer at all know that Vista's graphics are far from revolutionary.

Mac has had Expose for quite a while now, and in my opinion, works better than Flip 3D used in Vista.

Beryl, as mentioned in the article, is head and shoulders above any of the graphics possibilities of the "major" OS (Apple & Mac). Not only is linux completely free of charge, including all it's programs that come with it and are downloadable -- it's extremely efficient and truly works on a vast array of computers.

If you want to see a real "wow" Beryl is the second coming of what computer graphics can do for your desktop.

If anyone is interested in Linux, the easiest I've tried is PCLinuxOS which is really easy to set up and start up from Windows. Unfortunately, their online messageboard and community is lacking; although if you need help and want to try an OS that is constantly upgraded try Ubuntu Linux which has a new version of their OS coming out in about a week -- and their online community is some of the nicest and smartest I've seen on the Internet.
Reply to this comment
One word... Awesome!!!
by doughboy_10466 April 4, 2007 6:12 PM PDT
Both of the future desktops were amazing, but I feel that the Beryl desktop is
something that could/should be implemented in the major OS's (Windows & OS
X)right now!
Reply to this comment
Greaaaat !!! Linux
by thecroesus April 4, 2007 9:23 PM PDT
Most of the new Linux distro's now come with beryl or compiz built in so effects like the 3D desktop and other fancy effects (I Mean Really Great Effects) are what we now kinda used to. Considering how dynamic the linux community is i expect to see more improvement in desktop 3D graphics later in the year. You can check out the beryl site and that of compiz also. I dont see windows moving into this area that soon but i expect seeing apple incoporating more of this into the mac.
Reply to this comment
The "me too" operating system strikes again
by b_baggins April 6, 2007 6:25 AM PDT
Typical linux. Nothing new, just playing catch up and worse than Microsoft in
thinking that flashy graphics equals good UI.
Reply to this comment
Underneath its all the same
by mrpiddly1 April 6, 2007 12:27 PM PDT
Really underneath both linix and Windows are the same complicated mess of
**** with hundreds of lines of not needed codes that you have to modify just
to change a tiny feature. OXS is different in that i can actually find something
and then change it with a click and without wrting any code. OSX is also 10
times faster hence runiing 10 full 1080i movies at the same time with no lag
on a laptop or running all the aplications on the comuter, including games
photoshop, final cut and other demanding thaning, at the same time. Try that
on your 3d desktops. They also decrease funtionality unlike expose which
actually serves a purpose. None of the other OS have simple way to pull up
widgets, space, go directly to the desktop or flip through 100s of windows.

Also people think that OSX can not be modified. To them i say come look at
my matrix desktop where the icons and background are made up of scrolling
matrix codes. Infact every thing is a matrix code scrolling and windows are
defined by a 3d hight difference in this code. Sound uterly useless, well it is
but still fun as hell.

actually most of the linix thing they showed are stolen from OSX which still
does it better and easier and earlier. If you really get down to it, all modern
OS things were basically stolen from NEXT who existen in the early 90's and
was founded by steve jobs.
Reply to this comment
Boring and unimpressed
by OscarWeb April 6, 2007 7:40 PM PDT
BumpTop is a complete waste of time. Interesting how the video did not show how to locate one specific document. Simulating the clutter of a physical desktop on my computer's 2D screen is not exactly what most users want or need. Try BumpTop with thousands of documents and see if you could find anything. LOL.
As for Beryl, I was not impressed at all. It basically has OS X's Dock Genie effect, Cube Flip animation, and Expose. Not exactly ground-breaking when you are playing catchup.
Reply to this comment
Who says Mac is the original?
by scales April 6, 2007 10:39 PM PDT
I have to laugh at those of you Mac users who are claiming "this is just a rip off ot Mac, Mac does it better, blah blah blah." I hope you are aware that up until OSX mac had diddly squat, and was a terrible OS. While expose is a nice feature, that whole dock Mac has going on the bottom of the screen, yah know the one that stores shortcuts, and currently open or minimized windows? with pretty animations opening and shrinking a window, yah that happens to be a complete rip off of windows start bar and stardocks window restore/minimizing plugin. Go look it up, came out a long time ago. Mac is no better than everyone else, they all copy and learn from eachother, and yeah mac can be customized, but so can windows, and in the whole realm of customizing, linux is first, then windows, then mac. Now, about the article, 3D is cool, but really just pretty. Bumptop or whatever looks neat, but i am not sure how useful it alone will be. Beryl is slick as ever and definately makes me want to get back to linux. Key thing about beryl and linux is, that it will run beautifully on an older machine, unlike OSX or Vista....
Reply to this comment
RE: That i****
by nickc8 April 7, 2007 2:00 AM PDT
That guy is just one of those geeky (or nerdy) Microsoft fan and shows no respect to apple who invented the Operating System. And I must say that even OS X Tiger, released in 2005 outshines Windows Vista (released in 2007). Search cnet.com or the web to get proof!
View reply
could I boot both linux and windows vista?
by straylight516 April 7, 2007 11:41 AM PDT
I'm buying a dell pc with windows vista. I'm wondering if i could run both operating systems instead of just one. This makes me want to run linux which looks very nice.
Reply to this comment
You Can But....
by Homestarrunner April 7, 2007 2:42 PM PDT
I'm all for the promotion of Linux (I use it myself), But unless you have above average knowledge of computers and troubleshooting skills (Hard to tell your skill level from you comment) I would strongly caution you. It is not as easy to use as Windows. And if you are going to start using linux, don't do it for the flashy effects. In my oppinion, they get old pretty quickly, and slow down the computer a little bit. But if you want to try it, download Mandriva One ( http://www.mandriva.com/en/download) It allows you to start up linux right from the cd without installing it to your hard disk, and it has Beryl built in from the get go ( Beryl is not an operating system like they said but an add-on for linux, more specifcally a window manager).
(11 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

About Crave

The name says it all. Crave is our blog about gorgeous gadgets and other crushworthy stuff. If you would like to contact Crave with a tip or comment, please write to: crave@cnet.com

Add this feed to your online news reader

Crave topics

15 sites that went kaput in 2009

Web sites launch all the time, but they also shut their doors. We highlight 15 that bit the dust this year.

Top 10 news stories of the decade

Let the debate begin: Was the iPhone more important than iTunes? Was anything bigger than Google finding a great business model? CNET offers its list of the 10 most important stories of the '00s.