• On mySimon: Razor Pocket Rocket Electric Mini Bike
January 23, 2009 1:14 PM PST

DVR imperfection leads to 'Lost' night

by Emily Dreyfuss
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 32 comments

A few years ago, this wouldn't have happened. It would have been unthinkable, too terrible even to imagine. No, a few years ago, I never would have missed the season premiere of Lost.

So imagine my surprise when my boyfriend and I were minding our own business, watching our previously recorded Top Chef two nights ago, when, during a commercial break we were barreling through in fast forward, I happened to catch the words "Lost returns tonight." Stop. Rewind. What?

(Credit: ABC)

We backed up to the beginning of the ad, and sure enough, Bravo HD was proclaiming that Lost had returned a few hours before!

Had we set it to record? No. Had we even known it was coming back this week? No! We don't watch ads anymore. Ever. But without them, we are apparently living in a dark age so backwards it's as though TV Guide hasn't been invented yet. Now my grandpa is more informed than I am about television culture.

If we didn't have a DVR, we surely would have known, because I bet Lost ads have dominated the airwaves for the past few months. Lost isn't a show to announce itself softly: it usually has weeks of setup, marathons of previous seasons, call-in shows, etc. If we didn't have the ability to fast forward through that dreck, we would have known to be home, in front of the TV, at 8 p.m. on Wednesday. Sure, we would also have been brain-washed by a desire for a Snuggie and Wendy's new chicken sandwich, but information comes at a cost. As Tina Fey would say, "a doy."

Luckily, ABC anticipated that DVR-addled viewers like us may have missed the premiere, and so it offered the episode for free online, with one condition: you have to watch myriad 30-second spots for Desperate Housewives. Now that is my nightmare. But I'm willing to suffer through it to catch up on my show.

Anyone else find you are missing out on vital programming information by skipping through all the ads?

P.S. Jeez Comcast DVR, TiVo would never have let this happen. Somehow TiVo would have known I cared about Lost, even without my informing it, and it would have made sure to have the show recorded come premiere night. Before I switched to the cheaper Comcast box, TiVo always had helpful little suggestions for me, and despite the fact that it once recorded Dancing with Dogs without any prompting, I usually trusted it. Sigh.

Recent posts from Crave
One of Google Chrome OS's hardest tasks? Printing
Kid-friendly headphones
Moto Cliq gets software update
A necktie for music-loving commuters
Everything you need to know about buying a laptop this holiday season
Gimmicks are the new megapixels
On Call: All about the Droid
Twitter founder formally unveils 'Square' project
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 2 pages (32 Comments)
by the original mark January 23, 2009 1:25 PM PST
Like Emily, I rarely watch any live TV and I suspected I'd miss Lost if I removed it from my list of recorded programs on my DVR. I changed the preferences to "new episodes only" recently, since all the reruns were filling up my hard drive. Lost should be waiting for me on my DVR tonight. (It's nice to know that online is a back-up...just in case there are technical difficulties.)
Reply to this comment
by ashish_12 January 23, 2009 1:30 PM PST
Emily, they're showing it on ABC again on Saturday evening. 9/8c
Reply to this comment
by tsarchasm January 23, 2009 1:53 PM PST
Even the Comcast box is better than the Verizon FiOS HD DVR. It is constantly dropping channels for no good reason, requiring a hard reset or even a tech support reload. Even still NBC and CBS HD will not work along with about 10 other HD channels. Tech Support says they expect to have it fixed by June. I'm going back to TiVo. I <3 TiVo.
Reply to this comment
by arshield January 23, 2009 2:01 PM PST
I have had it happen before. Not with Lost but with other shows i like. What I wish is that Tivos were smart enough to know that a show on basic cable will play about 19 times but a show on a big network will play once, so even if the basic cable show is higher on the priority, the network show should be recorded because
Reply to this comment
by martinoflewis January 23, 2009 3:02 PM PST
I find myself missing out on new stuff all the time now that I have a DVR. I couldn't live without it though. RSS is helping me out big time. UK readers with the same problem might find the feeds at www.digitalspy.co.uk useful.
Reply to this comment
by CliffK2 January 23, 2009 3:12 PM PST
I love my TIVO. It is in my bedroom and faithfully recorded "Lost." But my Cox DVR, while not as elegant as the TIVO, also recorded "Lost." Many moons ago, I had told it to record all new episodes of "Lost," and it did. Can you not tell the Comcast DVR to record new episodes of your favorite show?
Reply to this comment
by isykal January 23, 2009 3:50 PM PST
This post is SUPER RETARDED! The point of A DVR is to avoid commercials or record shows that you would have otherwise missed.

If you love Lost as much as you claim you do, you don't need a commercial to tell you when the show is coming back.

Whiney people can never be pleased. They will always try to think of reasons to complain.
Reply to this comment
by superswiss January 23, 2009 4:15 PM PST
That's what Season Passes, Series recording and even keyword searches are for or whatever they are called on the Comcast DVR. You set it once and let it record every new episode. Learn how to operate your DVR. Now there's is the problem of running out of tuners if you love too many shows, but that's why I ditched Cable DVRs and Tivo a long time ago and replaced it with a whole house Windows Media Center custom installation with 4 tuners. Now I can't keep up with all the stuff my system is capable of recording concurrently.
Reply to this comment
by floydwall888 January 23, 2009 4:39 PM PST
Why wouldn't your DVR be recording new episodes of Lost if you're such a fan? Fail.
Reply to this comment
by CHETLY January 23, 2009 4:47 PM PST
Unfortunately, it is not always the fault of the fan who "would never forget" to record their favorite show...In my situation, my Brighthouse DVR has "Fringe" set to record all new episodes...but after watching a few DVR'ed shows one night last week, I noticed that it was not recording Fringe....BUT it was in the scheduled recordings list...it just didn't record. No conflicts...just didn't work...and it has happened before. Thankfully we can catch our missed episodes online nowadays. But I agree with the author...in our DVR society, we often are missing the ramp ups to new shows and even our favorites coming back for their season premieres....

"If it's made by man, then it will fail...."
by dreyfusse January 23, 2009 4:43 PM PST
You make a very good point, superswiss. I do know how to program my DVR, but because I didn't realize "Lost" was returning, I hadn't thought to set a season pass, since the show seemed to be on an interminable hiatus when I got it. But right you are: I should have set one anyway, looking forward to the future.
Reply to this comment
by joevai52 January 23, 2009 5:04 PM PST
I was just wondering why you hadn't just set a season pass for it if you enjoy the show so much. I can understand how you missed it if you didn't get the DVR until after the previous season ended. I bet you won't do it again with Lost or any other show you enjoy in the future.
by jimboxp January 23, 2009 5:12 PM PST
Why would you switch from a TiVo to a Comcast DVR? Are times sooo tough that you can't afford to pay 4 dollars more for the TiVo? I have two DVRs, a TiVo and Time Warners' DVR. Combined costing about $21 a month(and I'm in college). I use kwiry and mobile TiVo to control it and watch stuff everywhere. I don't know why you would sacrifice to downgrade. Plus my TiVo works amazing.
Reply to this comment
by De_UnKnOwN_1 January 23, 2009 8:51 PM PST
Comcasts DVR has season recordings just like Tivos...mine recorded Lost as scheduled...I havent adjusted its settings since the first season of Lost...
Reply to this comment
by lacfnc06 January 23, 2009 10:28 PM PST
the only thing I want to mention is that ABC's episode viewer is REALLY REALLY good quality in HD, especially when you have a strong internet connection. I would probably rather watch it online at abc.com that on TV becasue i have nothing even near HD on my TV.
Reply to this comment
by Eric Mason January 24, 2009 1:38 AM PST
I don't know about the rest of you, but my DVR remembers what shows I watched last season and automatically plans on recording the new episodes this season. I might have to do some minor tweaking as shows may conflict with one another, but it's already set up since I watched it last year as "fans" do. Also, if you are a fan of the show wouldn't you be checking to see when it comes back on? I know during September I check to see what's on and what time and get it all set up in advance. I might be alone on this though... Skipping through commercials is a dumb excuse. This post is founded on nothing at all.
Reply to this comment
by dcase99 January 24, 2009 7:38 AM PST
You people actually want to watch this show???? Wow
Reply to this comment
by EndlessBen January 24, 2009 8:23 PM PST
http://www.pogdesign.co.uk/cat/index.php is your friend.
Reply to this comment
by ThatsWhatSheSaid1 January 25, 2009 1:44 PM PST
Good to see that CNET attracts angry, judgmental commenters, too. Jeezums.

It's true; there's too much crap on TV to be able to keep up with it all. I've missed 30 Rock three weeks in a row and had to suffer through choppy online video, with interruptions brought to you by Reese's.

east coast misses the moon boots!
Reply to this comment
by anaphora68 January 26, 2009 6:19 AM PST
I have to say, I've had this happen to me as well. I never watch commercials anymore, so I miss a lot of TV that I would normally watch.

Another issue I have with Comcast is that their DVR is awful. I miss my Tivo box. For whatever reason, Comcast in Philadelphia uses boxes with a cable-card, and it does not interface with Tivo.
Reply to this comment
by dmbhhh420 January 26, 2009 6:26 AM PST
the quick fix for this is to set your DVR to record the series. this way you don't have to worry about whether or not you set your DVR. The only thing you would have to worry about at that point is conflicting shows since you can only record up to 2 shows at once.
Reply to this comment
by Borgslayer January 26, 2009 6:53 AM PST
Doesn't your DVR have a "seasson pass" feature? My tivo did, my crap Directv dvr does.
check it out
Reply to this comment
Showing 1 of 2 pages (32 Comments)
advertisement
advertisement

About Crave

The name says it all. Crave is our blog about gorgeous gadgets and other crushworthy stuff. If you would like to contact Crave with a tip or comment, please write to: crave@cnet.com

Add this feed to your online news reader

Crave topics

Inside the Apple, er, Microsoft Store

Although Redmond's foray into retail bears a big resemblance to Apple's approach, Microsoft has added some distinctive features to draw casual PC buyers and techies alike.

Big marketing budget drives Moto Droid sales

Verizon and Motorola are spending big bucks--$100 million--on marketing the new smartphone, and it looks like it will pay off with 1 million devices sold by year's end.