• On GameSpot: So-called 'Halo killer' gets 23 to life
November 28, 2008 12:00 PM PST

'Buy Nothing Day' a sign of the times?

by Elsa Wenzel
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 46 comments

Retailers anticipate a bleak Black Friday. Yet, despite the economic downturn, many Americans are still cramming into malls in hopes of snagging the best and earliest holiday buys.

Some consumers, on the other hand, will shun shopping and observe "Buy Nothing Day," a loosely organized protest against conspicuous consumption. The idea comes from Adbusters, an artsy glossy that counts a circulation of 100,000, plus 80,000 online members of its "culture-jamming" network of social pranksters.

Participants in a wiki for the event have planned demonstrations at shopping centers around the country, including the mammoth Mall of America in Minnesota. Some San Franciscans are opting to swap used stuff at the Really Really Free Market outside in Dolores Park. Wikipedia entries track activities in 65 countries.

Followers of Buy Nothing Day blame unchecked consumerism for ecological woes, psychological depression, and the economic crisis.

Followers of Buy Nothing Day blame unchecked consumerism for ecological woes, psychological depression, and the economic crisis.

(Credit: Adbusters Media Foundation)

The Adbusters Web site suggests repeating pranks performed by tens of thousands of people at malls in recent years, like wandering around in zombie gear. Some might stage a "Whirl Mart," roaming in packs at Wal-Mart stores with packed shopping carts, yet declining to buy anything. Armed with scissors, other participants may offer strangers the free "service" of a credit card cut-up.

Millions of people have heard of Buy Nothing Day by now and it grows each year, although there's no official count of the faithful, according to Kalle Lasn, Adbusters editor in chief and co-founder.

As lists of corporate collapses and layoffs lengthen, the notion of buying less or nothing is becoming less an option and more of a necessity for many people. That's an "I told you so" moment for activists such as those at Adbusters.

"If people had heeded the buy-nothing message, then we wouldn't be in this mess," Lasn said. "This glorified spending and borrowing of the past 10 years is really the root cause of this financial and economic meltdown we're in now."

The event launched in 1992 in Adbusters' pages and sparked a small following in the Pacific Northwest. It started attracting attention internationally in 1995--long before Twitter and other viral, Internet-enabled phenomena like flash mobs took hold--after the magazine touted Buy Nothing Day on a Web site.

"It was stunning for us at the time, that we just put up some information and a few photos and all of sudden without us even knowing it, we heard about some prank that people pulled off in Melbourne, Australia, and then people in the U.K. decided to call it "No Shop Day,"" Lasn said. "It was like what I call a 'metameme' that started spreading on its own power."

We're entering a "post-materialist" era in which people are weaning off an addiction to consumption, he says. "That era has got to do with buying more green and greening your life, having a lighter footprint, buying ethically and above all buying locally, not from big malls and stores with stuff that comes from China."

He seems to have company among an emerging crop of consumers. Recent polls show that younger adults are willing to pay a premium for green products, for example. Marketers are painting consumers as "bright green" or "dark green" according to the lengths they'll go to lighten their environmental impact.

(Credit: Adbusters Media Foundation)

Among the latter group are Compactors, 10 San Franciscans who pledged to buy nothing new for a year, then found themselves joined by thousands around the world, and overwhelmed by media requests.

Green blogs and Twitter feeds abound that chronicle individuals' efforts to lessen their economic and ecological debts, or to live off the grid entirely, rediscovering forgotten frugality. There's the well-publicized blog of Colin Beavan, aka "No Impact Man," a New Yorker who rejected toilet paper and electricity for a year. In California, bloggers Beth Terry, Dave Chameides, and Ari Derfel turned their lives inside out saving their garbage and struggling to cut out certain types of waste, like toxic plastic packaging.

Such bloggers have lauded "The Story of Stuff," a short, animated online film about the material waste of consumerism, which has been viewed more than 4.5 million times in the past year, according to its star Annie Leonard. She aims to turn the message into a sustainable-consumerism movement.

Technophiles appear to be increasingly concerned with energy efficiency and keeping old hardware from landfills; the growth of blogs like EcoGeek are one indication. Corporate and municipal e-waste collection programs have expanded, and entrepreneurs run sites like BuyMyTronics and Second Rotation that pay people to mail in their tired gadgets for recycling.

As disposable income shrinks and people must save goods and energy to trim necessary expenses, is conservation becoming cool?

You might see it in the big grin President-elect Barack Obama flashed Barbara Walters this week as he talked about greening the White House, and admitted flicking off the lights in each room at home in Chicago to shave electricity use. It's a far cry from President Carter's dorky, cardigan sweater-clad plea for people to dial down the household thermostat.

Recent posts from Crave
Crave giveaway of the day: Panasonic Lumix DMC-ZR1 digital camera
iFotoGuide nature photography guides for the iPhone
Hands-on with Ilford's Gold Silk inkjet paper
Fancy a free phone?
Inside CNET Labs Podcast 71: 'Very' good at counting!
Digital City Podcast 60: Attack of Cyber Monday!
How the Grinch iPhone game stole my $1.99
Project with the powerful LG Expo
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 2 pages (46 Comments)
by HlLLARY CLITON November 28, 2008 12:23 PM PST
it was easy for me to participate in buying nothing, there was nothing to buy. Retailers offered very few deals this Black Friday, I think they will pay for it in the end
Reply to this comment
by thenet411 November 28, 2008 1:13 PM PST
Black Friday needs to stop. As of 1:10pm PST, at least 3 people are dead in connection with this absolutely sickening behavior. 1 was a Walmart employee that was trampled to death by idiots looking for a deal and two other people are dead in a shooting at a Toys R Us. This is absolutely disgusting and if you took part in this display of rampant consumerism, you should be ashamed of yourself.
Reply to this comment
by 2wired November 29, 2008 2:12 AM PST
oh man just READ the articles involving the Toys R Us story and you'll see that that shooting had nothing to do with Black Friday....headless chicken reaction to a newpaper heading you didnt even bother to read......
by Get_Bent November 29, 2008 4:09 PM PST
But Black Friday had EVERYTHING to do with the Wal-Mart employee in Long Island, New York, who got trampled by a brainless herd of rabid consumers when he unlocked the doors at 5 AM.
by wusupjohn November 28, 2008 1:38 PM PST
Yeah, we should all go live in a hole.
Econ 101; take it.
Reply to this comment
by Zeeshan47 November 29, 2008 2:53 PM PST
We did take Econ 101, and we cared to pay attention during class. Rampant consumerism along with Clintonian/Greenspanian deregulation make a pretty nasty combo to take down your country's economy.
by h_blankett November 29, 2008 7:32 PM PST
Econ 101: After seeing how the U.S. has been brought to its knees by the "free market" consumerist economy, it's going to be interesting to see how future editions of freshman economics textbooks will justify devoting any space to Milton Friedman's ideas other than as examples of "failed ideologies" or "economics con games".
by mmntech November 28, 2008 1:45 PM PST
Don't buy anything! They don't realize that the vast majority of the US economy is dependent on consumer spending. If that dries up, its "wow, I'm suddenly out of a job." The idiots will all be echoing the words of George McFly: "When the hell did this happen?!" Adbusters has always been out of touch with the real world, just like their readers.
Reply to this comment
by h_blankett November 29, 2008 7:24 PM PST
"They don't realize that the vast majority of the US economy is dependent on consumer spending."

That's precisely the problem: our economy is stupidly based on consuming things, not producing things. Kill the consumer culture, and bring back the producer culture.
by TechnoMan475392 November 28, 2008 3:11 PM PST
I bought a 16 GB flash drive...
30 dollars!
Reply to this comment
by twitter_1963 November 28, 2008 3:12 PM PST
I brought a $39.99 Microsoft Laser mouse for $14.99 at Fry's. Not becuase I needed it, but because it was so cheap :) You get what you pay for. It works only if you are a few feet form the wireless adapter, which was bigger than the mouse. I'll take it back tomorrow :)
Reply to this comment
by minonda November 28, 2008 3:55 PM PST
I bought a Boston Acoustics iPod dock with AM/FM radio.
Reply to this comment
by DGASINT November 28, 2008 4:17 PM PST
I bought two coffee's from Starbucks. Keeping in the spirit of "Black Friday", I drank them both, "Black". :)
Reply to this comment
by d4nowar November 28, 2008 4:18 PM PST
I bought a half ounce.
Reply to this comment
by jpmays November 28, 2008 5:13 PM PST
@d4nowar

You bought a half ounce of what? And what did it cost?

Inquiring minds want to know!
by karpenterskids November 28, 2008 7:40 PM PST
Why am I left thinking it was a half ounce of drugs? lol
by 2wired November 29, 2008 2:13 AM PST
how much is weed over there anyways? lot weaker than the stuff over here though :-P go dutch baby!!!
by Seaspray0 November 30, 2008 8:25 AM PST
Did you get a black friday sale price for it?
by etiahwhite November 28, 2008 5:57 PM PST
I didn't bother heading out today I wasn't impressed with the offerings...I work in retail and walk through a macys everyday on my way to work and they had better deals a week ago then they had today.
Reply to this comment
by HighwayHome November 28, 2008 7:50 PM PST
Sorry, but I wasn't really in the mood to wake up at 3:30 AM and go down to a major corporate retailer to get trampled by a bunch of mindless brainwashed drones.
Reply to this comment
by Hammerhand November 28, 2008 8:07 PM PST
Buy Nothing Day is a fallacy. "Buying Nothing" doesn't mean a thing if you've got consumable goods at home/available to you.

You turned on your computer today to read this stuff - you bought electricity.
You decided not to buy a $7 Starbucks coffee, so you made one at home - you bought water and electricity (not to mention the coffee grounds you used, which you previously purchased).
You also decided not to eat out, so you cooked your own meals at home - you bought natural gas and/or electricity, water, and consumed food you'd already paid for.

Whether or not you buy today or tomorrow, you're still buying. If people really wanted to make an impact it would be "Consume Less Month" or "Purchase Necessities Only Month".

The dupes who take part in stuff like "Buy Nothing Day" and believe that by reading Adbusters they're part of some kind of counter-culture - they're not really a part of the solution...
Reply to this comment
by Zeeshan47 November 29, 2008 3:04 PM PST
Some of us actually do take the message to heart year-round. Shut your mouth and educate yourself before you bash an entire community on speculation. Electricity, water, natural gas, unprepared foodstuffs, and other items of the sort cost very little compared to prepared bought items, while allowing a relatively enjoyable standard of living. Hell, even a vagrant "consumes" electricity by living in a big city and being surrounded by city lighting, and we all "consume" oxygen when we breathe. The movement is not about "greenness" but rather economic intelligence and prudence.
by h_blankett November 29, 2008 7:22 PM PST
Buy Nothing Day is not targeted at buying necessities such as food, heat, and basic clothing; it's aimed at buying cheap, plastic crap sold at Wal-Mart and the like.
by humanssssss November 28, 2008 9:02 PM PST
It's good that people start to understand how to save. It's about time we get back to the basic! Save money! Only buy the basic and let the guys building excess die.
Reply to this comment
by Seaspray0 November 30, 2008 8:38 AM PST
Try telling that to congress and see how far it gets you. LOL.
by BlueCollarBrain November 28, 2008 10:01 PM PST
No mention of the Reverend Billy and the Church of Stop Shopping?

Hammerhand, too bad the idea is over your head, you seem like you might be intelligent.
Reply to this comment
by NocturnalCT November 28, 2008 10:04 PM PST
The economy must shrink to save us. Interest rates must go back up to prevent frivolous borrowing, both for houses and other goods. Saving to spend rather than borrowing to spend should become the norm again, just like it was when we were kinds. Save your allowance to buy that 'big' toy. Let's get rid of the 0% balance transfer credit cards and other gimmicks that trick people into buying stuff they have no hope of ever repaying. Prohibit 5 year ARMs that trick people into thinking they can afford more house than they really can.

All this will cause the economy to shrink back to what we're actually producing rather than what we hope to produce. It'll be painful. People will get laid off and wages will come down. Some people will end up in jobs they didn't want just last year. Maybe we can bring some jobs back from overseas and then start increasing productivity again which will allow for higher wages etc. Put back some emphasis on education in this country and train a new generation of engineers, tradesmen and scientists that produce and create. Fewer lawyers, realtors and financial traders. More farmers, teachers, welders, metal workers, engineers, scientists, road builders, construction workers.

Oh well, I've rambled enough. I'm a well paid software engineer myself and I like my toys like most everyone else. But we're going to try to make some changes in my family. Starting by paying of the CCs and keeping them at 0 at the end of every month. Try to save. It'll be tough.
Reply to this comment
by elysianfields123 November 28, 2008 10:43 PM PST
Why do some companies give cheaper prices to "new" customers, when those of us who have been loyal are forced to pay double the price? Why should I stay a loyal customer? Maybe it's time we hop from service to service to get these new customer deals. I would rather spend my money with a company that is LOYAL to me.
Reply to this comment
by DarkHawke November 29, 2008 1:21 AM PST
Man, if it ain't one line of bull, it's another! I'd like to find at least one member of the obviously large, well funded and planet-wide gang that continually puts guns to the heads of the general population and makes them buy things they don't need and accumulate debt that they can't pay off!

What a bizarre mix of anti-capitalism, anti-consumerism and the unique narcissism of the "green movement!" The irony of the situation is that without the capitalist, consumer-oriented economy that has made this country the economic superpower that it is, these nutjobs wouldn't have ANY of the means they're using to spew their pathetic drivel! No computers, no internet, no telephones (let alone cell phones), not even inexpensive printing for their newsletters! It's like the hippies of yesteryear all over again, who spent much of their time decrying the culture that without which they could not have maintained their hedonistic lifestyle. Only now, these idiots increasingly have the ear of "mainstream" news and are sometimes even a part of the media, lending their otherwise insane blather a patina of credence.

I'm so glad I participated in flying the finger at these morons and picked up some DVDs and Blu-Ray discs yesterday! And watch out, you self-destructive twits! Before the year is out I'm gonna drop upwards of $4000 on my credit card for a kick-ass plasma flat-screen-based home theater system! Do I need it? No, not really! Can I pay it off even in six months? HELL no! I'm already hip-deep in debt! Will I do it anyway? Watch my dust!!! ;)
Reply to this comment
by MSSlayer November 29, 2008 10:59 PM PST
Stupidity.

This country became an economic powerhouse through production, not consumerism.

Rampant consumerism has brought us to the brink and we are not in debt beyond repair.
by DarkHawke November 30, 2008 3:32 AM PST
@MSSlayer: And with all the production that has gone overseas, how do you then explain the fact that the U.S. is STILL the "economic powerhouse" that drives the world economy? As evidenced by the current circumstances, the maxim is still true that when the U.S. sneezes, the world catches cold. Could it be that we've gone past the necessity to produce everything ourselves? Could it be we've shifted from a production-based economy to an information base? That now we have what we need produced elsewhere, where it's more cost-efficient to do so and yet still yields the same benefits? Food for thought...apparently.
by Seaspray0 November 30, 2008 8:41 AM PST
I'll explain it DarkHawke. It's called excessive government deficits and a lopsided trade deficit. And you think that's a good thing?
by DarkHawke November 30, 2008 11:26 PM PST
@Seaspray0: Government deficits have nothing to do with this discussion. Trade deficits are also quite irrelevant. We've had trade deficits of varying sizes all my life and the U.S. remains the world's leading economy. China's trade surplus with the U.S. doesn't seem to be doing it a hell of a lot of good. If a trade deficit is so bad, and conversely a trade surplus is all that, shouldn't they already be running the world?
by js358 November 29, 2008 5:04 AM PST
Do these morons realize that they are hurting everyone by these acts of stupidity. Yes, we're in a recession and yes, it is time to show some prudence when spending. But to fill up shopping carts in Walmat and leave them. Grow up. These retailers are struggling to survive like we all are. And in order for this economy to begin recovering, people will need to start spending.
Reply to this comment
by MSSlayer November 29, 2008 11:01 PM PST
Really?

Spending money at a store where 90% of it goes overseas and into rich peoples pockets will save us?

Real investment is what is needed, we have become a demand side economy where the supply is coming from across the ocean. The US will never fully recover without a good dose of real investment.
by DarkHawke November 30, 2008 3:23 AM PST
@MSSlayer: Economics and world trade are not zero-sum games. Never have been, never will be. Literally, what goes around comes around. Doesn't matter if the cash goes into the pocket of the guy down the street, Bill Gates or someone in Beijing, so long as it's not sequestered by government fiat (taxes), it's all part of the rising tide that'll lift all boats...if we let it.
by MSSlayer November 30, 2008 9:30 AM PST
LOL

Yeah right. I guess there are still a few flat earth-ers that buy into trickle down.

It does matter!
by DarkHawke November 30, 2008 11:18 PM PST
@MSSlayer: Maybe the earth is flat where you are, but denying how macro-economics works doesn't stop it from working. Always has, always will.
by MadLyb November 29, 2008 5:20 AM PST
I am so sick and tired of Self-Righteous, Sanctimonious pricks trying to tell me how to live my life.

Did I participate in Black Friday? Nope. I don't buy something because it is a deal, I buy it because it is the right thing to buy. Black Friday deals, especially on electronics, on usually low-end junk.

Will I spend a lot of money at Christmas? I already have, since I work at it all year to find the right gifts.

You look at the rampant commercialism and consumption and what I see is my whole family gathering and sharing gifts, large and small, to not celebrate the holiday, but each other.

So, go do the 'right' thing as you see it, and be smug about it, but don't EVER try to tell me how I should live my life.
Reply to this comment
by MSSlayer November 29, 2008 11:02 PM PST
And you need to buy things for "my whole family gathering and sharing gifts, large and small, to not celebrate the holiday, but each other. "?

How sad for you and your family.
by MadLyb December 1, 2008 7:31 AM PST
@MSSlayer You prove my point.

You think that it is sad for my family to exchange gifts as part of the celebration and we think the exact reverse and that is fine, but where it crosses the line is when people try to 'make' me change my behavior based upon their own beliefs.

So, you enjoy your holidays in your manner and I will enjoy mine.
by Blacksheep1982 November 29, 2008 7:54 AM PST
I've never shopped on Black Friday in my entire life, long before I even heard about these anti-consumerism movements. First, I didn't know it existed till I was in my late teens, second, I like sleeping till 10 or 11 when I can, two, I like to go to places when there are no crowds as opposed to 10 times as many people.

Of course, I am opposed to out of control consumerism anyway, but that came later in my life. We used to produce more things in this country and sold them overseas. Now we don't produce anything and 2/3rds of the economy is based on consumer spending. It's a danger to the structure of the economy and risks us falling into a permanent circle loop. So we don't produce anything, the economy is driven by buying, people have been talked into 401Ks over pensions (guaranteed money) and now all their 401Ks are down and they aren't buying. But not buying drives the stock market down further! See what I mean, this risks a death spiral like we have never seen before.
Reply to this comment
Showing 1 of 2 pages (46 Comments)
advertisement

About Crave

The name says it all. Crave is our blog about gorgeous gadgets and other crushworthy stuff. If you would like to contact Crave with a tip or comment, please write to: crave@cnet.com

Add this feed to your online news reader

Crave topics

S.F. hacker space: Heaven for the DIY set?

The Noisebridge hacker space offers sewing and Mandarin classes, soldering workshops, Internet-controlled front door access, and a server room with no door.
• Photos: Circuits, code, community

The browser battles go on and on

roundup From Firefox to IE and from Chrome to Opera and Safari, there's no sitting still for browser makers looking to keep their products fresh and competitive.