• On TV.com: TOP 10 Shows CANCELED Too Soon
November 28, 2008 4:00 AM PST

Unlocking iPhone 3Gs--the Vietnamese way

by Dong Ngo

Tuan Anh Do shows off an unlocked iPhone 3G at one of his cell phone repair shops in Hanoi.

(Credit: Dong Ngo/CBS Interactive)

Editor's note: CNET editor and Crave contributor Dong Ngo is spending the next month in his homeland of Vietnam, and plans to file occasional dispatches chronicling his impressions of how technology has permeated the culture there. Click here for more of Dong's stories from abroad.

HANOI, Vietnam--Every obstacle presents an opportunity. I saw this firsthand in Hanoi.

Tuan Anh's shop on Nguyen Du street.

(Credit: Dong Ngo/CBS Interactive)

The obstacle in question: the iPhone 3G. Since its launch, it has proven a much tougher nut to crack than the original iPhone. Without a viable software-based unlock solution, the only way to make the phone work with any GSM carrier has been the use of a proxy SIM. Put this piece of very thin circuitboard in the iPhone 3G atop the carrier's SIM, and you can make calls and text on a new network.

(I did experience some problems using the proxy SIM, including short battery life, instability, and, most seriously, incompatibility with iTunes.)

Unfortunately, the recently released 2.2 software update, for now, has made the iPhone 3G impossible to unlock--unless you happen to be in Hanoi. Here, I met a man who takes the job quite seriously and gets it done the hard way, literally.

His name is Tuan Anh Do, and he's a 29-year-old businessman who owns five cell phone repair shops. A big part of his business is servicing the iPhone and iPhone 3G, and that often involves getting those devices unlocked at the hardware level.

One of his shops is on Nguyen Du street, a relatively small, quiet block in Hanoi. It's located in a typically narrow four-story house, with one floor serving as a reception area, and another holding the accounting department. The top floor is the workshop, where the magic happens.

Here I witnessed a brand new iPhone 3G getting its hardware unlocked and was really impressed. This is how it happened.

First, a technician opened up the phone and stripped it to the motherboard. In his skillful hands, the device seemed much easier to dismantle than I expected.

The technician then extracted the baseband chip, the component that controls the connection between the phone and the mobile network, from the motherboard. (This is a painstaking task as the chip is strongly glued to the phone's motherboard. A mistake during this process could brick the phone completely.)

A technician opens up a brand new iPhone 3G in one of Tuan Anh's Hanoi shops.

(Credit: Dong Ngo/CBS Interactive)

The phone's motherboard with the baseband chip at the bottom and marked with a red X for viewing's sake.

(Credit: Dong Ngo/CBS Interactive)

Once the chip was extracted, it was Tuan Anh's turn. He used a chip reader to read information into a file. He then used a Hex editor to remove the locking data from the file, and after that, the chip got reprogrammed with the newly altered file. Now it was no longer programmed to work with only a specific provider.

The chip then got reassembled into the motherboard, another painstaking process.

As a last step, the technician put the phone back together, and it looked like nothing had been done to it.

However, the phone is now unlocked and can be used with any carrier's SIM. It can also be synced with iTunes and used with the original carrier and it can perform all other functions without any problem. But it's not yet jailbroken, which Tuan Anh will do for free. He'll even add lots of applications and utilities at no additional cost.

The baseband chip (which I marked with a red X to make it more visible) has been extracted from the motherboard.

(Credit: Dong Ngo/CBS Interactive)

Each such unlocking job takes about an hour to complete and costs 1.2 million dong (about $80), a small fortune over here. Tuan Anh said that so far, his business has unlocked hundreds of iPhone 3Gs and thousands of first-generation iPhones.

He also said that if an iPhone has been unlocked under the firmware version 2.1 or earlier, upgrading to version 2.2 will lock it again. This is because the 2.2 update is the first update that alters the baseband chip, a clear move by Apple to counter the software-based unlocking solution. In this case, Tuan Anh is willing to re-unlock it for a discount price of $50.

In case of mishaps, Tuan Anh said he would give clients a new phone. Considering that an iPhone 3G goes for somewhere between $800 and $1,000 in Hanoi, this is a bold statement, but so far, he has yet to brick a customer's iPhone. He did, however, lose two iPhone 3Gs while mastering the unlocking process in the phone's early days, a $2,800 investment at that time.

The chip gets glued back onto the motherboard.

(Credit: Dong Ngo/CBS Interactive)

The demand for the iPhone and iPhone 3G in Vietnam is amazing. Prior to my trip here, a few friends asked me to bring one for them from the States. Some even offered to pay me extra. I didn't have time to take up any offers and obviously missed an opportunity to get my trip partially paid for. Still, I've seen a lot of people here with the iPhone. Tuan Anh said most iPhones 3G in Hanoi come from the States and Australia.

Tuan Anh's shops also take care of repairing other kinds of cell phones from any vendors, especially those without a support office in Hanoi. And the shops are faring well. When I was at the Nguyen Du street business, all of his technicians were busy working on different phones, two of them iPhones. The workshop's atmosphere was professional and quiet; I figure a job like this requires a lot of concentration.

The phone is now unlocked and working with a Vietnamese provider.

(Credit: Dong Ngo/CBS Interactive)

It's striking to witness the amount of work these skillful workers get done, considering how modestly equipped the workshop is. The most sophisticated equipment I could see were a Pintex Oscilloscope and a couple of microscopes. The rest of the tools, such as solderers, tiny screwdrivers, tweezers, alcohol, and towels, are the sorts of things you could find at most hardware stores.

Tuan Anh now has about 30 employees, paying them $300 a month on average. That's a very good salary considering the average income of a Hanoian is just around $100 a month.

Asked why he decided to get into this business, Tuan Anh, who holds bachelor's degrees in history and journalism from Hanoi National University, traces it to a passion for computers and electronics, an interest he shares with many other Vietnamese.

He hopes that what he's been doing with the iPhones wouldn't be considered "illegal" in the States. Oddly enough, his dream is to become an Apple partner officially supporting the company's products in Vietnam.

But illegal or not, Apple's idiosyncratic policy has in a weird way given this bright man an opportunity to do more than just make a living. He's proven that we really can be the master of our tools, not vice versa.

Dong Ngo is a CNET editor who covers networking and network storage, and writes about anything else he finds interesting. You can also listen to his podcast at insidecnetlabs.cnet.com. E-mail Dong.
Recent posts from Crave
Ricoh goes modular for GXR camera system
Moxi cuts price on its DVR, adds step-up model with a triple tuner
2010 Tesla Roadster Sport first drive
Sneak peek: Xobni e-mail app for BlackBerry
The DIY secret-knock door lock
New BlackBerry software will make your phone cooler
The 411: Storage limits and more on data plans
Can Bheestie Bag save your soaked device?
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 2 pages (42 Comments)
by Philips November 28, 2008 4:19 AM PST
Uhm... I understand why that can be interesting in Vietnam, but I think for NA, it is much easier to import iPhone 3G from e.g. Europe where it is sold in "unbranded" variant. In Europe, phone locking is mostly forbidded and top what carriers do is to put some branding and unremovable proprietary applications on the "branded" phones. Yet, generally all phones are also available without branding.
Reply to this comment
by Benoneya December 18, 2008 5:58 PM PST
Well, the author is talking about what he FOUND in his visit to Vietnam. The whole point is what's going on over there, not what's going on here. DUH! The cost of an unlocked European phone is probably prohibitive for most Vietnamese citizens. Why even compare in that manner? The article has nothing to do with NA, and what we do here or what's available for us here. That's a very unpleasant attitude! Can you say ignorant and self centered?

The articles are about Vietnamese culture, and what they're doing, things the author discovered when he was visiting. He's not suggesting YOU or anyone else use this method of unlocking.
by Philip_for_ever November 28, 2008 5:02 AM PST
In Vietnam, there are more about tech than just iPhone, come to Ho Chi Minh City next week, they even have a huge meeting event for Mac users, as I know, Microsoft Hardware will joint it, too.
A funny video for the "meeting" could be seen from here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2v09nCcbYqA
Reply to this comment
by Philip_for_ever November 28, 2008 5:16 AM PST
Two more things: Apple already opens online store in Vietnam, really they consider 80 millions people nation/market with 45% under 30.
And here how Macintosh really is in Vietnam: www.macvn.com
Reply to this comment
by jfigueredo November 28, 2008 8:33 AM PST
Great story...nice to see how free enterprise is alive and well...
Reply to this comment
by the_redistributor November 28, 2008 9:18 AM PST
How stupid and dense people are in this world. With the cost of reprogramming the phone after every software update by Apple, why not just stick with AT&T or Apple's telecom partners. Or is it because AT&T represents American capitalism and most Appleheads are left leaning socialists? I'm probably right about the latter.
Reply to this comment
by undeniable November 28, 2008 10:21 AM PST
You're right, it's definitely not the fact that AT&T has horrible service. No, never that. It has to be a political issue, surely!
by dotKev November 28, 2008 12:15 PM PST
the_distributer - What if the people that want an iphone but its not available on their network or country or maybe they can't afford to get stuck with an 18 month or 2 year rip off contract or maybe don't have a bank account and can only afford pay as you go. Not everyone lives in the good ol' U.S.A. and can sign up to an AT&T contract.

Who's really stupid and dense?
by SixVodkas November 28, 2008 3:29 PM PST
undeniable;

I dunno, I was with Verizon for nearly 4 years, and have now been with AT&T for just over a year.

Service?

From Detroit to Houston, I've not seen ONE BIT of difference, and have most certainly NOT found AT&T to be inferior to Verizon in any way, manner, shape nor form.
by georgehoang November 30, 2008 2:13 PM PST
wow, u must really be stupid and dense...
this is vietnam we're talking about, if u have a little bit of knowledge and common sense, u no that apple DID NOT RELEASE THE IPHONE THERE YET. Other than importing the phone and unlocking it this way, there is no other way...
by p.shearer December 1, 2008 5:58 AM PST
Dense and stupid??? This article demonstrates the resiliency and innovation of the human spirit. The statist approach is what Apple and AT&T are doing by locking down the phones and demanding complete control. This is nothing more than a brilliant demonstration of the free market at work. People did not like being told what to do whether by centralized, totalitarian regimes or by corporate bureaucracies.
by cooper6--2008 December 1, 2008 1:26 PM PST
Uh, no.
With this operation, you can use your iPhone anywhere in the world. You still have to get a local SIM card, but you can use the phone outside of say, the States, and not only pay the local provider for their services.

Travelling outside of your local providers area can be brutal in terms of data charges.

And that guy in Vietnam? Looks like capitalism to me....
by cbong69 December 15, 2008 6:50 AM PST
huh..now I know how people like Bush can be the president of USA. It's from 51% of the voters who don't know what's going on outside their country. Get real, there're some 100+ countries in the world with a total of 400+ GSM networks, and Apple only officially launch iPhone 3G to about 80 countries with no more than 100 networks in the world. Even iPhone is available in my country but with another network, I may not want to switch not only because of cost and service, but just simply because I do not want to change my phone number ( Mobile Number Portability MNP is not working in every country yet )
by leson2403 October 11, 2009 9:32 PM PDT
AT&T? Nope, no AT&T exists in Vietnam. Apple's telecom partners? I hope you're able to find one, since there is none in Vietnam.
Have you ever been outside U.S.?
by Mr. Dee November 28, 2008 2:35 PM PST
Too bad he doesn't have a subsidary in Jamaica W.I. CLARO Jamaica recently launched the iPhone 3G here but it is absurdly expensive.
JA $50,000 with first month contract - thats US $650
JA $10,000 which is the minimum for a monthly contract is US $129

That's too much money, I get one abroad and jail break it to work with either Digicel or Cable & Wireless (LIME).
Reply to this comment
by eurek2000 November 29, 2008 12:20 PM PST
Bought unlocked iphone from australia $900.
by Mr. Dee November 30, 2008 4:09 PM PST
That's still too expensive, I think I will stick with my Motorola E398 or get a Black Jack with Windows Mobile when I'm ready to upgrade.
by meditermeow November 29, 2008 8:39 PM PST
" He'll even add lots of applications and utilities at no additional cost. "

Are the writers or editors allowed to praise software piracy?!!
Reply to this comment
by praneeth22 November 30, 2008 9:17 AM PST
Most software available for jailbroken iphones are free, i.e. they are free downloads from the legal authors of that software anyway, why would it be piracy?
by weeblnbob November 30, 2008 7:56 PM PST
I completely disagree with redistributor's viewpoint and use of name-calling. First of all, the phone belongs to ME, not Apple. I should be able to use MY OWN PHONE on any network and do whatever I feel like with it. It is not socialist or leftist. It's called property ownership. Something any good capitalist should understand. I personally hope our government enacts legislation that would forbid locking phones in the U.S. I sincerely doubt I'll ever buy another Apple product of any kind as long as they stick to such a repressive philosophy. It just isn't American.
Reply to this comment
by texaslabrat November 30, 2008 10:54 PM PST
While there's no law in the U.S. specifically forbidding companies from locking cell phones to carriers (obviously...), there is a DMCA exemption that legalizes the act of unlocking a cell phone (until it expires assuming that it isn't codified in law and/or renewed). It's not what you were asking for, but at least it's *something* ;) But, just because it's not a criminal act, it doesn't mean that the vendor(s) are required to do business with you after you've unlocked and/or jailbroken your phone (assuming they could detect it). And that's where a law such as you've suggested could come in...make a law that codifies the "carterphone decision", along with an explicit exemption in law for unlocking/jailbreaking devices that have been legally obtained (and/or forbidding the locking of such devices to begin with).
by November 30, 2008 8:29 PM PST
Why crack? Simply buy it from the HONG KONG APPLE STORE. It is sold as official unlock version and is from apple. Check it out at www.apple.com/hk
Reply to this comment
by texaslabrat November 30, 2008 11:04 PM PST
I doubt the Hong Kong Apple store ships unlocked iphones outside of the Hong Kong area...thus unless you are shopping in person that's not really an option for those who live elsewhere (maybe you can find one on ebay or craigslist...but that's a stretch).
by alan_06 December 1, 2008 1:05 AM PST
I don't think it's worth spending this much effort for cracking this phone. There are better alternate phones on the market.
Reply to this comment
by zhahadum December 1, 2008 8:36 PM PST
The marked chip pictured as being removed is an SRAM next to the baseband processor, not the baseband processor itself:

See the labeled motherboard at http://www.ifixit.com/Guide/First-Look/iPhone3G
Reply to this comment
by wswanson04 December 2, 2008 6:37 PM PST
Will that work on a cdma network like Verizon? I would pay double if so. Verizon phones are so.... well everyone knows!
Reply to this comment
by debt4life December 5, 2008 10:49 PM PST
Why did anyone have to go trhough this to unlock an iPhone 3G? Use Gevey Turbo SIM instead.
http://cgi.ebay.com/UNLOCK-3G-IPHONE-GEVEY-PLUS-TURBO-SIM-UNLOCKED-8gb-16gb_W0QQitemZ200281089925QQcmdZViewItemQQptZPDA_Accessories?hash=item200281089925&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14&_trkparms=72%3A1234|66%3A2|65%3A12|39%3A1|240%3A1309|301%3A1|293%3A1|294%3A50
Reply to this comment
by s3283 April 10, 2009 11:20 AM PDT
and you should use tinyurl.com
by boyhitech December 23, 2008 12:17 AM PST
TA MObile unlock iphone 3G by Hardware is FAke... that is True FAKE 100%
Reply to this comment
by boyhitech December 23, 2008 1:14 AM PST
TA Mobile unlock iphone 3G by Hardware is fake 100%.
Reply to this comment
by HUY.TQ December 23, 2008 2:16 AM PST
Em vi?t ti?ng Vi?t cho d? hi?u.

?óng c?a b?o nhau thoy các Bác!
Reply to this comment
by leson2403 October 11, 2009 9:35 PM PDT
?óng c?a b?o nhau làm ǵ, ??ng nào Apple c?ng ?âu th?a h?i mà kéo quân sang ?ánh ḿnh :))
Tr? phi M? l?y ??y làm c? ?? xâm l??c n??c ḿnh l?n 2 :))
by Nick_Lovin January 20, 2009 11:44 PM PST
Just to let every body know the import tax rate for importing electronics into Vietnam is 100 to 200 percent so, the cost can be increased to 2 to 3 times. The only way to get the iphone cheap is to have a relative bring one back from the states, etc and have it unlock.. You can make alot of money if you bring back a couple and sell them, but you will have to bribe the customs officer to let you thru without paying the tax...
Reply to this comment
by ta_mobile February 1, 2009 9:51 AM PST
This way of unlocking happen again whenever Apple release the new firmware to prevent software unlock. This method works ok with 2.2.1 3G iPhone firmware.
Reply to this comment
by nhucnha February 6, 2009 1:52 AM PST
If you would like to know how unlocking method this guy is doing just read this link:
http://bmt9x.com/?s=ta_mobile
and then click " click Here To Read More" you will see it.
If you would see how him reacted when Newspaper reporter asking him about the Scam unlocking method, and what he said, in Vietnamese
http://sohoa.vnexpress.net/News/Dien-thoai/2008/12/3B9AFA26/
Reply to this comment
by ta_mobile February 6, 2009 10:19 AM PST
@nhucnha: Competition has been shown to be useful up to a certain point and no further, but cooperation, which is the thing we must strive for today, begins where competition leaves off.

Be sincere; be brief; be seated.

BR
Reply to this comment
Showing 1 of 2 pages (42 Comments)

About Crave

The name says it all. Crave is our blog about gorgeous gadgets and other crushworthy stuff. If you would like to contact Crave with a tip or comment, please write to: crave@cnet.com

Add this feed to your online news reader

Crave topics

After 5 years, Firefox faces new challenges

Mozilla helped reshape the Web since releasing Firefox 1.0 five years ago. Now it's got a reawakened Microsoft and Google Chrome to reckon with.

There's a map for that: GPS or smartphone?

Almost every handset comes with mapping software these days, but standalone GPS devices are becoming more affordable than ever.