• On CHOW: Groundbreaking hangover cure
August 15, 2008 6:55 PM PDT

A freaky Friday for our iPhone 3G

by Kent German

With tales of iPhone 3G horror abounding on the Web, I figured I was just lucky.

Since Apple loaned CNET an iPhone 3G just over a month ago, I had experienced none of the problems that have plagued so many other users. I didn't have dropped calls or buggy software, and my iPhone wasn't cracking around the edges. Sure, the 3G connection was a bit shaky, and the battery life suffered during a day of heavy use, but on the whole my handset was doing just what it was supposed to do.

Uh-oh, it's the dreaded white screen of death.

(Credit: Kent German/CNET Networks)

That is, until today. Since I only got the iPhone back from the CNET Labs just this week--I'm convinced Eric Franklin was getting back at me for being cold-blooded--I had to wait until today to get the latest 2.0.1 software update.

After connecting the phone to iTunes and accepting the update, all was proceeding normally until suddenly, disaster struck. iTunes informed me that it was unable to complete the update because of an "unknown error" and my iPhone froze with the "connect to iTunes" prompt on the screen. Ouch...that was unexpected, particularly since I had updated CNET's first-generation iPhone moments before. But thinking it could just be a one-time quirk I tried a factory restore, reconnected the phone to iTunes in recovery mode, and accepted the update again. But alas, disaster struck a second time.

Though thoughts of doom began to flood my mind, I took the advice of my very knowledgeable colleague over at iPhone Atlas and tried the update a third time. And that's when Murphy's Law hit me over the head with a mallet. Not only did the "unknown error" flash across my computer screen again, but also my iPhone snowed over with the "white Apple logo screen of death."

Any screen of death, be it blue or white, is not fun as now it looks like a trip to the Apple store is in order. I was able to clear the screen with another restore, but now my iPhone won't get past the pesky iTunes prompt. It may not be bricked, but it might as well be.

It's more than clear, Cupertino, that we have a problem. I'm hardly the only one to experience this problem, as message boards across the Internet can attest. But so far, Apple has on this issue, not to mention the mounting reports of 3G reception problems and dropped calls. AT&T is denying responsibility, but the fact the user complaints are coming from outside the United States seems to support the theory that there is an issue with the phone.

Analysts and researchers have pointed to probable causes, from the Infineon chipset to a lack of 3G sensitivity, but so far iPhone users have been left to fend for themselves. And that's just shameful. According to a Business Week story, a software update to fix the reception problems is on the way. But until I hear anything officially, I consider it hearsay.

Apple, it goes without saying that you should fix these issues soon. But in the meantime, it would be nice if you could discuss them at all--even if it is a simple "we're working on it." I'm certain that even the very acknowledgment that something is afoot would put a lot of minds at ease. And AT&T, you should chime in as well. My iPhone is a free loaner so I deserve nothing. But there are plenty of people who paid a lot of money for your product. And they deserve better.

Have you been struck with the iTunes "white screen of death"? Leave a comment to let us know.

Kent German is a senior editor for cell phone reviews at CNET. When he's not testing the newest handsets on the market, he's blogging about cell phone news for Crave. In his On Call column, he answers reader questions and gives his take on the rapidly changing mobile industry. E-mail Kent.
Recent posts from Crave
Ricoh goes modular for GXR camera system
Moxi cuts price on its DVR, adds step-up model with a triple tuner
2010 Tesla Roadster Sport first drive
Sneak peek: Xobni e-mail app for BlackBerry
The DIY secret-knock door lock
New BlackBerry software will make your phone cooler
The 411: Storage limits and more on data plans
Can Bheestie Bag save your soaked device?
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 2 pages (31 Comments)
by Shaymojack August 15, 2008 7:57 PM PDT
I got this screen on my iPod touch, but after about ten seconds it changed to the Apple logo and everything worked normally. I was restoring because for some reason I am completely unable to change the background on my iPod. I've restored three times, deleted the picture from my iPod, deleted ALL pictures, everything. But I can't change it anymore.
Reply to this comment
by jake49 August 18, 2008 12:34 PM PDT
i'd just downgrade to 1.1.4, jailbreak it, and get all of the free apps from installer... they just sell them in 2.0 when you can get them for free... 2.0 is plauged with problems...
by michaelseanhansen August 15, 2008 11:59 PM PDT
Dear Apple -

I really want an iPhone. Like, badly. I have an 8-year-old phone that does nothing but make calls. No camera, no apps, and the interface is annoying as hell. But it makes calls. To use your own phrase, it "just works."

Looks like I'm still waiting. Please at least show your customers some respect by acknowledging the problem(s). That would go a long way towards giving me the faith and trust I need to buy your product.
Reply to this comment
by choreilly August 16, 2008 9:21 AM PDT
I get this screen all the time. Mostly, the cause is updating, downloading applications. I think my full restore count is 10+. :-(
Reply to this comment
by cummjejp2 August 16, 2008 9:23 AM PDT
This is the thing I can't stand about Apple. They're like a bad government that just doesn't admit when things are going wrong---they just pat themselves on the back when things go well. I've heard of numerous quality control issues for computers and whatnot that never get publicly acknowledged by Apple. It's one of the reasons I haven't yet purchased an Apple product.

But then, are the problems really not that bad? Maybe they're getting a lot of press simply because the iPhone's such a huge product.
Reply to this comment
by gsmiller88 August 16, 2008 9:44 AM PDT
Seems to me like the 3G iPhone was rushed to market. I mean c'mon, the first gen iPhone was only a year old.
Reply to this comment
by CWulf August 16, 2008 11:16 AM PDT
Fix iPhone's "Apple logo screen of death" with Recovery Mode

By Jacqui Cheng | Published: August 08, 2008 - 02:15PM CT

A number of iPhone users are experiencing one doozie of a bug after upgrading to the recent iPhone 2.0.1 firmware. After upgrading and rebooting, they are finding themselves unable to actually use the device; instead, they are faced with what's being referred to as the "Apple logo of death." The black screen with the Apple logo in the center typically shows up after rebooting your device, but users are reporting that the logo won't go away, even after a number of resets.

As it turns out, this particular bug isn't new with iPhone 2.0.1, but seems to have been triggered once again by the software's release. There are a handful of discussion threads on Apple's Support boards about the issue this week, although there are also a number of similar ones from earlier this year created by people with older iPhones and/or older versions of iPhone OS. Aside from rebooting the device, users aren't having luck plugging their iPhones into the computer to sync with iTunes either.

Luckily, these folks are not out of luck and won't have to find themselves waiting in line at the Apple Store's Genius Bar just yet. Putting the iPhone into Recovery Mode, which you can do by pressing and holding the Home button while reconnecting USB cable, will help jolt the iPhone out of its Apple logo screen of death loop. When "Connect to iTunes" shows up on the screen, you can finally let go of the Home button and iTunes will let you know that it's in the process of recovering your iPhone.

Ars Gaming Editor Ben Kuchera is actually the one who originally brought this issue to our attention, and he now reports that performing the Recovery Mode procedure saved his original iPhone from being carted back to the Apple Store. If you have found yourself faced with this issue, try it out and let us know how it goes.
Reply to this comment
by KentGerman August 16, 2008 5:14 PM PDT
Sorry CWulf. I tried that but had no luck.
by cgwalters1955 August 16, 2008 12:10 PM PDT
Cgwalters Romford Essex United Kingdom. After much deliberation I got my hands on a iphone 3G just over a week ago. I do travel around the south east of the UK a lot and I noticed that the signal strength of the iphone 3G is some areas is very weak usually one or two bars. I seem to get no coverage a bit too often to be confident to have the iphone 3G as my sole communications device. At the moment I will still walk with my Sony Ericsson P910i on TMobile network which has not let me down yet. Apple should not have sold this product if it was not fit for the market. I am certain that there is a fault with the iphone's because my son has another phone on the same network as my iphone (o2) and he seems to get very good reception all of the time, so I am sure it is not the network. Apple needs to sort this problem fast.

I have also done a software upgrade to 2.0.1. After doing the upgrade I noticed that when I set the international regoin to London United Kingdom, I cannot turn off the 24hour clock. It only allows me to turn of the 24hour clock when I set the region to United States. There are certainly a few bugs to sort out on this one Apple.
Reply to this comment
by IPMB August 16, 2008 12:27 PM PDT
yesterday i plugged in my original iphone and it did the same thing. it i tried every thing i could and nothing why cant Apple fix this problem quickly.
Reply to this comment
by tyrone8323 August 16, 2008 3:05 PM PDT
just like the first iPhone, this one also has many issues and just like normal SOP from Apple, is just sitting on their hands and not giving it's customers any answers. i'm very glad i stay away from Apple products because this seems to happen with EVERY product Apple releases and they ALWAYS take forever to provide a fix. which reminds me, the DNS security flaw in the Mac OS is still not fixed...i feel sorry for the Apple fans.
Reply to this comment
by killroyboy August 16, 2008 9:40 PM PDT
I got this same problem when I upgraded to 2.0.1 on my 3G. I tried to restore (to 2.0.1) 5 times and eventually did a downgrade back to 2.0 which finally worked. I haven't tried the 2.0.1 again and don't plan on it. I am waiting for 2.1.
Reply to this comment
by jaguaraja August 18, 2008 6:47 AM PDT
It drives me crazy that I'm in an area where I can get 5 bars of Edge or 5 bars of 3G but 90% of the time my phone picks the edge connection (and yes, my 3g setting is on).
Reply to this comment
by vr6veedub August 18, 2008 9:07 AM PDT
This happened to my friends iPhone 3G. Doing a restore from the same computer or a computer login account that had an iPhone backup file did not restore the iPhone. Basically what I did was:

1. Create a new account (administrator rights) on the computer (windows)
2. Open iTunes
3. Put iPhone in Restore Mode
4. Plug iPhone via USB to computer
5. Restore should take place and complete within 15-20 minutes
6. Once iPhone is restored, you could plug the phone back onto the computer or login to the account that has the original backup file of the phone you are restoring. Beware however many times the backups are corrupt. My friend recovered from his backup with no problem.

The key to this working is to restore on a computer or computer login that does not have a iPhone 3g backup file in iTunes. When you dont do it this way at times the restore could hang or continue with 2-3 hours (guess how I know this???). To check if the loging/iTunes has a backup file, check this under Preferences -> Sync tab

Hope this helps everyone
Reply to this comment
by bubblebathgirl August 18, 2008 12:14 PM PDT
Stop whining!

When you buy early this is what happens, it always does. YOU should know better. Next time wait 3 months and there will be less kinks to deal with, otherwise just expect this to happen - as you should expect Apple to fix the issue quickly and quietly.
Reply to this comment
by DarkHawke August 19, 2008 4:02 AM PDT
These "early adopters" are having problems with the SECOND version of the iPhone and the 2.0.1 version of its OS.
by ufcama August 18, 2008 1:45 PM PDT
windows95 or 98

i guess Apple finally reach Windows in a system crash loop
Reply to this comment
by socal210 August 18, 2008 2:08 PM PDT
Thank you Kent, for writing this story. I hope Apple comes forward with a solution to this, or at the very least an update that they are working on the problem. Most people paid a lot of money for these phones.
Reply to this comment
by Krupin2 August 18, 2008 2:19 PM PDT
Apples failure to address/admitt the issue has 100% made up my mind to NOT buy thier phone....Everyone makes mistakes and technology is going to have its ups/downs. Had they ADMITTED it and just said they were going to fix it I would still be a fan....Its a total shame!
Reply to this comment
by bruceslog August 18, 2008 4:22 PM PDT
Ok, so I won't be buying a iPhone anytime soon. Glad I waited...
my question now is, how are the other 'smartphones' fairing ?
Intuition, etc...
Reply to this comment
by ramakrishna_a2000 August 18, 2008 9:03 PM PDT
I get this kind of error now and then... not a white screen but a black screen.. all I do is connect it to my computer and once it get's detected, all will be fine. There are too many problems...
1. Signal is too bad
2. Response is too bad (Icons don't respond to my tap)
3. It freezes some(every) time.
4. Battery is too bad
5. Cannot hear the ring tone once I switch it from vibration mode.
6. Cannot accept a call when it is locked (not frequently)


hmm... good phone apple....
Reply to this comment
by jubjubstudio August 18, 2008 10:13 PM PDT
I am glad he wrote this article. Maybe he should just take it back to the Apple store and get a new one. If it is broke than get it fixed. In the length of time it took him to write the article, he could of got a new phone from Apple. I would of walked into the Apple store and said, someone better get me a new phone now or I am going to take a giant dump in your store. Nobody would like that... It leaves a big mess. Than I would take a brand new Mac Pro for my pain and suffering with a 30" monitor.

Case Closed...

I think this guy should get some balls instead of hiding behind his article.
Reply to this comment
by KentGerman August 19, 2008 8:37 AM PDT
Actually, jubjubstudio, the case isn't closed. This is the review phone that Apple loaned CNET, so it belongs to them. It is not my personal model and I don't have an AT&T account to take to the Apple store. Finally, because this is CNET's loaner iPhone that we used for our review, we're only doing our job when we tell our readers that it malfunctions.
by jgwinner August 19, 2008 10:20 AM PDT
Good to know ...

That's one thing that drives me more nuts than "F8" at a Windows screen ... the iPhone has SO many 'secret keys'.

Screenshot - Home + Power ...

stuff like that. Anyone have a cheat sheet?

== John ==
Reply to this comment
Showing 1 of 2 pages (31 Comments)

About Crave

The name says it all. Crave is our blog about gorgeous gadgets and other crushworthy stuff. If you would like to contact Crave with a tip or comment, please write to: crave@cnet.com

Add this feed to your online news reader

Crave topics

After 5 years, Firefox faces new challenges

Mozilla helped reshape the Web since releasing Firefox 1.0 five years ago. Now it's got a reawakened Microsoft and Google Chrome to reckon with.

There's a map for that: GPS or smartphone?

Almost every handset comes with mapping software these days, but standalone GPS devices are becoming more affordable than ever.