Look out iPod, here comes Dell...again
That online music market must be awfully tempting catnip to Michael Dell.
The Wall Street Journal reported Wednesday that Dell for the last few months has been testing a digital music player that could go on sale as early as September. The story (which will surely serve as a nice trial balloon for Dell's marketers) says the music player could sell for less than $100. It will use Wi-Fi to connect to third-party music services.
Dell may get back in on the music action.
(Credit: Dell)If that's deja vu you're feeling, you're not the only one. In 2003, Dell jumped into music biz with its own player. Three years later, it jumped out, with around a 3 percent share of the market. It was one of several disappointing and ultimately abandoned consumer efforts, including forays into televisions and handheld computing devices (though there are reports that Dell may get back into the mobile market).
Could it be different this time around? While it's hard to imagine Dell posing a real threat to the iPod's more than 70-percent share of the digital music player market, never say never. The software behind Dell's device came from Zing, a small company Dell acquired a year ago, according to the WSJ. Dell's music software could also come pre-installed on new Dell PCs. An excerpt from the story:
Software would connect the device to an online subscription service that Dell expects to launch later this year. Through licensing agreements with online music providers, Dell's new service will let consumers download songs and move them between devices like PCs and cell phones. While the device Dell is testing is focused on playing music, Dell's new service also would allow movies to be downloaded and displayed on PCs, for example. Pricing for the new service hasn't been determined.
There are plenty of potential partners for Dell, of course. The company already has ties to music services from Pandora and Rhapsody. And MySpace Music, a major music service that's expected to launch in September with music from at least three of the four major record labels, could also be a major partner, though the Journal article doesn't mention it.
Then again, Dell could decide to do nothing at all. That's what trial balloons are for. But it's hard to imagine Dell or any other PC maker sitting by forever as Apple becomes more and more entrenched in home entertainment.
Jim Kerstetter has been writing about the high-tech industry for more than 13 years, as a senior editor at PC Week, a Silicon Valley correspondent at BusinessWeek, and now an executive editor at CNET News. He moved back to Boston because he missed the Red Sox. E-mail Jim. 
Example:
I will have a podcast playing. I have the system set to lock after five minutes, the longest you can have it delay. I also have Exchange email on it. That means if the podcast is playing for more than five minutes (default is one minute) and I want to stop/pause/change volume, I need to unlock the unit, then enter in my passcode in addition, then I will have access to the music player controls if those happen to be the screen that was last used. With no tactile feedback, you can't do any of this without looking- something you don't want to do while driving for example.
Ahh. I'm sick of every post like this some guy gets on and spouts nonsense. Let's clear up some things....
1. You are not locked in a certain file format. The ipod can play mp3's just like on your Creative Device. Yes the iPod also plays DRM AAC files.. but the Creative also plays DRM WMA files. Is one form of DRM better than another? I think not.
2. You have to use itunes to load the ipod and it's a lot more seamless than the program used for Creative. Read Cnet's own reviews.
So let's cut the crap. If you prefer one player over another fine. Everyone's taste is different...
but let's stop spreading the same lies and mistruths that seem to dominate these discussions everytime Apple or Microsoft is mentioned.
I'm sick of seeing it....
Just another locking mechanism.
As you said, everyone has his/ her own taste, so this also explains that not everyone like to use iTunes to transfer music.
I used to have a Dell DJ music player and it was terrible. It was hard to sync with MusicMatch because sometimes it would recognize it and other times it wouldn't. The actual device felt like cheap plastic. I can't speak for all non-Apple MP3 players, I'm sure there are some fine ones out there, the Creative Zen being one of the one's I've heard exceptional reviews about. I'm on my 3rd iPod myself and what I love most out of that is how seemless it syncs with iTunes. I don't know why Dell feels the need to get into the MP3 business again. Its like when Apple started making printers and digital cameras. It wasn't necessary.
Apple started making printers in 1982 with the ImageWriter and was fairly successful until it exited the business in 1997-98.
One way or another, you have to spend money to listen to music at your discretion (provided you are trying to maintain a legal position). Renting versus buying is a common debate (consider buying a car versus leasing) and the end result depends on your wants and needs.
From a renter's perspective, you (a buyer I assume) can spend $15 and become owner of one cd per month (or fifteen single serving downloads, whatever). For the same money, I can listen to the cd you bought, that artist's entire library, and about 2,999,000 other songs at my leisure.
To each his own.
I've purchased music from Amazon and Rhapsody, and Amazon is by far the best and will probably give iTunes a run for its money. Buying a song from Amazon automatically places it in your iTunes library as if you were using the iTunes store. The interface at Amazon isn't as nice as iTunes but I'm getting used to it.
The iPod has a strong foothold in the market, and I love my iPod, but I think with increased competition from other online music stores consumers might start to consider other portable players. Dell could offer one of those players provided they address some of the important selling points (IMHO):
1) Must cost less than an iPod. Saving money is probably the number one reason people will look at an alternative device.
2) Device must be as easy to use as an iPod.
3) Differentiate the music management software from iTunes by seamlessly integrating with all online retailers.
4) Open up the device with an API so third party developers can make other music management software. Choice is good. And while applications like Songbird do exist for the iPod I still can't forget how Apple sued RealNetworks for creating iPod sync software for its Real Player. Apple just doesn't want consumers using their iPods with anything but iTunes.
Actually, if Microsoft were to tweak the Zune a little bit and address some of these points, then they too could bring some real competition to Apple.
I'm not trashing Apple or hoping someone comes along and kicks their butt in the online music and portable player arena. I just think competition is good. Unfortunately, i don't see anyone seriously competing with Apple in this space.
1) Obviously, the device needs to be good, small, perform well, etc.
2) Marketing
3) Get it in people's hands no matter what (if it's Dell, throw it in free with a Dell computer. If it's Sony, or Samsung, bundle it with one of their $1000 products.) Basically, give these away by bundling, then maybe word of mouth will assist in the marketing.
4) There needs to be less competitors! Not no competition, but trimmed down to three or so. Sony, Samsung, Sandisk, MS, iAudio, iRiver, Dell, etc. People just look at all the others and think, why bother. So instead of 10 alt companies owning 3 percent of the market each, one alt company should come up with a true iPod killer, and two or three other alt companies use that technology but brand their own. That alt device would have a 30 percent market share and gain support by users and partners. Instead of the fractured picture that things look like right now, where company has enough support to gain traction against iPods.
As for you concerns about playing/pausing without unlocking - that makes me think you don't even own one. If you're using the Apple headphones just press the button near the mic and it'll pause/play and click it twice to skip to the next song. In addition you don't need to unlock your phone to get iPod controls - simply double click the home button and regardless of where you are you'll get the iPod controls.
- by enochrios July 31, 2008 8:09 AM PDT
- BOOOM! Head Shot. YEAAAAA!
- Reply to this comment
-
(21 Comments)