• On TV.com: NARUTO SHIPPUDEN Episode 138: The End
November 23, 2009 5:45 PM PST

New Apple ads to Verizon: Can Droid do this?

by Chris Matyszczyk
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 203 comments

It seems that Apple doesn't respect Verizon's Droid phone quite as much as it does Microsoft's PCs. But two new ad spots, launching Monday evening, come as close as Apple has done thus far to directly attack the allegedly do-it-all robotphone.

The Droid, you see, went after Apple in its teaser campaign with some telling remarks and the hearty claim that Droid does what the iPhone doesn't. Then Verizon decided it would be fun to knock both the iPhone and AT&T's spotty 3G coverage with its "Misfit Toys" concept.

AT&T has already replied by hustling a hastily-dressed Luke Wilson into directing a few resentful pins at Verizon's effigy. However these new ads, while entirely in keeping with the iPhone tone and style, end with a line that expressly assaults the doings of Droid--or rather, its alleged non-doings.

Both ads focus on the iPhone's ability to allow you to use voice and data capabilities simultaneously over the AT&T network. By asking gently at the end of each spot "Can your phone and your network do that?" Apple is bursting what it sees as the inflated stealth bombing that accompanied the launch of the Droid.

Apple iPhone Ad - Did You See My Email? from Arik Hesseldahl on Vimeo.

Apple iPhone Ad - What Time's The Movie? from Arik Hesseldahl on Vimeo.

These ads don't mention the Droid or Verizon by name. But the fact that Apple has decided to address its rivals, however obliquely, suggests that one can look forward to more accusations, more bickering, and more attempted one-upmanship.

'Tis the season of goodwill, after all.

Chris Matyszczyk is an award-winning creative director who advises major corporations on content creation and marketing. He brings an irreverent, sarcastic, and sometimes ironic voice to the tech world. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET.
Recent posts from Technically Incorrect
Did this Metro PCS ad make the tech world cringe?
Twins learn of teen brother's death on Facebook
Audi wins the Super Bowl
Survey: Majority of people don't want an iPad
Google to air ad during Super Bowl?
Obscene tweet gets Vodafone rep suspended
Invention to help Brits stop 'glassing' each other
What kind of virus has Fiorina's ad spread?
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 4 pages (203 Comments)
by November 23, 2009 5:54 PM PST
Nice try, Apple/AT&T. The pimp slap you got from Verizon/Motorola must really sting, eh?

FYI, I don't think these ads are valid anyway because AT&T would drop your call way before you even think of firing up Safari.
Reply to this comment
by lesbihonest17 November 23, 2009 6:26 PM PST
nope i always multitask when im making calls from my iphone. first hand experience buddy.
by professionaladventurer November 23, 2009 6:52 PM PST
Negative copy ghost rider. My phone works as the commercial shows.
by CHRIS99182340 November 23, 2009 7:01 PM PST
Nice try troll. Try streaming pandora, and getting a phone call --- nope, they goto voicemail. Or worse yet, try mapping somewhere while on the phone with a frantic family member in an emergency. Tons of other examples.
by CHRIS99182340 November 23, 2009 7:02 PM PST
Nice try troll. Try streaming pandora, and getting a phone call --- nope, they goto voicemail. Or worse yet, try mapping somewhere while on the phone with a frantic family member in an emergency. Tons of other examples.
by protagonistic November 23, 2009 7:17 PM PST
You might try just using whatever tool works for you. If you have an iPhone/AT&T and they are giving you that much heartburn look elsewhere. If you don't then you really don't know what you are talking about.
by cnetguard November 23, 2009 7:24 PM PST
CHRIS99182340: I don't use Pandora so I can't try that. I'm not sure why you would want to use an AUDIO app while on a call. I check my adress book, my calendar and my emails among other stuff while on a call, but I never even try to play music at the same time, that's just silly.

On your other point: Try mapping somewhere on any phone with a frantic family member in front of you in an emergency. The problem is not the phone call, but the frantic relative.

Nice try troll indeed, Chris.
by DasScooter November 23, 2009 7:52 PM PST
Ghost writer is probably Apple Sux Leo in discuise as everyone thinks hes a tool and hates him so he hides his name
by tektaktyks November 23, 2009 8:12 PM PST
cnetguard try downloading free pandora,run it and have somebody call you,troll
by Eat_A_Peach November 23, 2009 8:46 PM PST
@ CHRIS99182340 I have both an iPhone and Pandora (free) and just tried your suggestion (although I've had this experience before) just now to prove the fallacy. I ran Pandora and streamed music for 5 minutes then used my boyfriend's phone to call my iPhone while it was running Pandora and not shockingly it paused and the image and ringtone I have set for my boyfriend's phone # came right up and I answered the call. It does NOT go to voicemail. Even had my girlfriend with an iPhone try it and I called her and again, no surprise that Pandora stopped playing and she answered my call within seconds of it ringing. If you're having calls going to voicemail, you either have a problem with the phone (needs an OS update?) or with the app (needs an update?) because the senario you describe just doesn't happen with an iPhone 3G (updated) or 3GS (updated) and the current Pandora (free) app.
by guest18934367 November 23, 2009 10:30 PM PST
Why would you want to run Pandora and take a call at the same time, so the person on the other end can listen to your music? That's just plain rude.
See more comment replies
by shiningdevil November 23, 2009 5:56 PM PST
Assuming you get connect into a phone call in the first place.
Reply to this comment
by protagonistic November 23, 2009 7:22 PM PST
No problems getting through here in the boondocks. Maybe you should move.
by bctexas November 23, 2009 9:48 PM PST
Yeah, this talk about AT&T's coverage area just confuses me. I believe if you get bad coverage, then you probably live in North Dakota or somewhere that doesnt really matter anyways. You know, one of those states that we could just give to Canada and never really notice. My iPhone works well everywhere in Dallas, and never leaves 3G mode either, hrmmmm,....how's that with all this talk about spotty coverage? Idiots.
by solitare_pax November 24, 2009 2:10 AM PST
The Verizon ad is pointing out AT&T's lack of 3G coverage - but I imagine AT&T has nationwide coverage for calls and slower data transfer coverage.

Trouble is, in a 30-second spot, you don't always notice that disclaimer for the maps, which makes AT&T look really bad.
by summershoe November 24, 2009 6:29 AM PST
@bctexas - of course you're confused. you're from texas, a state we should have given away to mexico about 9 years ago :)
1 person likes this comment
by Lennron November 25, 2009 7:24 AM PST
@summershoe

Texas said they were going to succeed a few months back and become their own country. I don't know about you, but I say let them go. :)
And when they become their own country and are finally able to build that border fence they've been obsessing over, they can keep going and build a fence around all their borders. Not that anybody from the other states are ever going to want to get in.
by shuyin84 November 25, 2009 11:00 AM PST
how did we go from arguing bout the iphone, to arguing bout texas?
by xcopy November 25, 2009 11:24 AM PST
@ shuyin84

not sure, but I think it was because someone is from TX, but regardless it's pretty funny.

There are a few good people in TX, but my only question now is since we didn't give it to Mexico 9 years ago (a colossal mistake that nearly ruined the world), can we now arrange to have it permanently hermetically sealed so noting in there can ever get out again? If so,round a few of the more prominent problems up (like Dick) and jam them in there too before we do the deed. We won't ever have to worry about TX soiling the rest of the country again. :)
by rob90278 November 25, 2009 1:27 PM PST
@lenron: Perhaps you should spend more time in school and less time on the internet. "Succeed" means to be successful, which the state of Texas is. More people are moving there than any other state. I believe what you were trying to say was "secede," which means to formally withdraw from an alliance.
by UCVirus November 23, 2009 6:02 PM PST
LOL. Wow AT&T is focusing on the one thing the iPhone can do that any other phone can't.
Reply to this comment
by Deelron November 23, 2009 6:12 PM PST
Other phones can do it, just not Verizon's network.

It must suck to have one in an area with no coverage, where I live and travel it has excellent coverage. Luckily we don't all live in NY or SF.
by professionaladventurer November 23, 2009 6:54 PM PST
I live in Alaska and have an off grid place on the island of Hawaii. ATT 3G works just about every where I go: http://www.professionaladventurer.com
by bburn--2008 November 23, 2009 8:36 PM PST
Well, the thing is, the Palm Pre or Motorola Droid may have better (although quite unstable) multitasking sure but who really cares? Everything else, browser, media player and the App Store flushes all those clones down the toilet.

I do QA for Roger Canada and we get to try A LOT of phones. And I am sorry but the iPhone kicks every other smartphone in the rear! Some come close but, well, Android is not quite up to speed yet. Windows Mobile is plain terrible. Only Blackberry is still the best alternative but, it's not always easy for the ego to admit but, the iPhone is the clear leader!!!
by DasScooter November 23, 2009 9:27 PM PST
I Live near Gotham and when I enter my iPhone works its 3G just fine
by celticbrewer November 24, 2009 7:20 AM PST
...And the one thing most people don't care about.

Cmon, first off- who wants to actually make a voice call anymore? Everyone I know uses text 98% of the time at least. And if they do happen to actually call someone, they're not going to be surfing the web or checking e-mail at the same time.

That's a pretty lame comeback Apple/AT&T...
by Mr_fleabite November 24, 2009 8:28 AM PST
@celticbrewer
Those who want to relay info to someone quickly call them and talk. If you want to get some info to a lot of people at once yeah a mass text works great. Some of us hate mashing our thumbs on a tiny screen or absurdly small qwerty keyboard. It's faster to call and say:
-Movie is at 7:10 6th and Main theater you in?
-yeah
-cool see you there.
by Michichael November 24, 2009 9:58 AM PST
Actually the G1 can do that just fine. Did it last night when I was lost trying to find a gas station while talking to my boss. :)
by grtgrfx November 24, 2009 11:33 AM PST
Actually the 1G CAN'T do that. We have an original 8GB iPhone and, with WiFi disabled, we cannot use any internet-necessary apps while on a voice call. The phone says (depending on the app), "cannot access the internet, please try later," or something similar. Obviously you can get internet app data if you're in WiFi range and allowed on that network, but Apple has no disclaimer in the ads saying "may require WiFi for simultaneous data and voice functionality."

So if this does work in iPhones through the AT&T network alone, it's obviously a 3G or better function and not universal to ANY iPhone. Bummer for older iPhone owners.
by Robert aka ted November 24, 2009 1:04 PM PST
The best part is everything that the Droid and iPhone advertise as being capable of has already been done with Windows Mobile phones. I cannot believe people with iPhones can even stand not being able to run simultaneous apps. It's just so amusing that a phone like the Touch Pro 2 does more than both of these phones and has had predecessors that also were as capable.
Window Mobile phones may get joked a lot, but they actually do everything. However, the Droid commercial was awesome- I hate the snobby iPhone commercials.
by frozenjello November 24, 2009 1:39 PM PST
@grtgrfx; I think Michichael was talking about the T-Mobile G1, not the first generation iPhone.

But you do bring up a good point. Simultaneous voice and data is not possible on GSM EDGE, only on GSM 3G.
by November 23, 2009 6:09 PM PST
No, Apple, my Droid can't do that (if I'm not on wifi). But it can do everything else pretty darn well, including making phone calls without worrying of the call getting dropped.

And I'd argue the whole viewing emails thing while on a call, but I'll let that one go.
Reply to this comment
by timber2005 November 23, 2009 6:28 PM PST
Wait your Droid can't? Huh.... I can on the Hero (sprint). But its really not the "network" which has anything to do with it.
by chabig83 November 23, 2009 6:49 PM PST
Timber, it is the network. Verizon's CDMA network can't support both data and voice simultaneously on the same device.
by davidmcelroy_dotmac November 23, 2009 6:50 PM PST
Why would you "argue the whole viewing emails thing while on a call"? Are you claiming that it can't be done? Are you claiming that it's not useful? Or what? Almost every single day, I perform data functions while I'm on my iPhone. Sometimes it has to do with the call I'm on and sometimes it's just a matter of getting things done while somebody talks. I wouldn't bother doing it with the speaker phone (just because I don't personally like speaker phones), but using the earbuds really enables me to get a lot done while I talk on the phone. If you've never experienced it, maybe you're just unaware of how useful it is. That seems hard to believe, though, because it was a feature that I frequently needed with the original iPhone (before we had 3G).

It amazes me how ignorant people keep repeating the claim about every iPhone user having to worry about calls being dropped. The truth is that I don't have any more dropped calls than I had with my RAZR before this or the various Nokias and Sony Ericksons I had before that (on several different phone networks). From what I've read, AT&T truly might be overloaded in NYC and San Francisco, but most of us don't happen to live or work there, so it's irrelevant to us for the most part. I'm sure it's a bummer for people in those areas, but I'm also sure that AT&T is smart enough to be bringing new capacity online as soon as possible. For most people, the "dropped calls" thing is a total red herring.

I couldn't care less what phone you use, but it makes you look ignorant to pretend that data use while on a call isn't important.
by mluvas November 23, 2009 6:51 PM PST
You make phone call using your smartphone. How dumb is that!! So 19th century.
by timber2005 November 23, 2009 7:05 PM PST
Oh. Well that stinks. I had no idea of that.
by November 23, 2009 7:08 PM PST
@davidmcelroy_dotmac

First off:
SIMMA DOWN NAH

Secondly:
I wasn't arguing the usefulness of doing emailing while on the phone. I'm arguing that you can do it on the Droid too. Even with no reception (aka underground in the subway) I can read/write/label/archive emails while heading to work.

THAT is my argument. Next time calm the hell down before you fly off the handle on someone.
by cnetguard November 23, 2009 7:11 PM PST
Actually, I do use other apps while on a call VERY frequently, in particular (but not only) mail and calendar. Normally it's a little bit cumbersome because you have the phone in front of you, not next to your ear. You can put the handset on speaker-phone, but that's very rude with the people around you. So what I do is plug in the earphones/microphone if I have it with me, which is not always the case.

Of course you think people would not do that, but that's because you never think of doing it. And you don't think it because... well, because you can't do it!

Oh, and one more thing: I never worry about the call getting dropped. I guess I am blessed by living in a city with good coverage and far less people clogging the network, but still it's never in my mind.
by ktappe November 23, 2009 7:22 PM PST
The ads do not show using e-mail while on a call. Perhaps you could spare a mere 60 seconds to view the ads you were so eager to incorrectly reply to?!? Oh, and don't bother posting back until your Droid has 100,000 apps to choose from.
by November 23, 2009 7:26 PM PST
@cnetguard actually, that's not entirely true that the Droid "can't do that". I've definitely had calls where I had to switch between my email, calendar, and my note taking app. The argument is that you cannot do any data related activities while on a phone call. Gmail and calendar can work in offline mode, then syncs once it picks up a data connection again.
by protagonistic November 23, 2009 7:27 PM PST
You must be on someones s**t list. Dropped calls are extremely rare for me.
See more comment replies
by frozenjello November 23, 2009 6:18 PM PST
I found it refreshing to have iPhone commercials that advertise the usefulness of the iPhone's standard apps (with some third-party apps thrown in there) without the need to say "there's an app for that".
Reply to this comment
by Seaspray0 November 24, 2009 2:50 PM PST
I want to see more commercials from both att and verizon that throw mud at the competitors phone because it can't do something trivial or irrealivent for most people. I want to see the half truths and sarchastic criticisms blossom in each new ad. I want the slander to explode on the airwaves and the public inundated with the tripe each one can make up about the other. I want it to continue until everyone becomes sick of the ads and the companies involved.
by November 23, 2009 6:19 PM PST
Remember back in the days when it was cool to have an AOL account because everyone was on it and it was the first to commercialize internet access? Then it went downhill because there were always busy signals and you could never get online?

Yeah...
Reply to this comment
by Edicius00 November 23, 2009 6:30 PM PST
No, it was never "cool" to be on AOL.
by November 23, 2009 6:33 PM PST
@Edicius00 Yup, I say the same thing about having an iPhone.
by ktappe November 23, 2009 7:29 PM PST
I'm not trying to be cool with my iPhone, I'm simply walking around being productive and happy. Heaven forbid.
You guys who are trying to be cool by calling the iPhone uncool are really pathetic. It's amazing how far some people go out of their way to not understand.
by Edicius00 November 23, 2009 7:31 PM PST
Glad we agree, I never said it was cool to own an iPhone.
by ausernamenoonehaschosen November 24, 2009 5:49 AM PST
It was definitely never ever ever cool to use AOL. God I cringe at those three letters even though the torture was so long ago.
by celticbrewer November 24, 2009 7:15 AM PST
Compuserve was the first to commercialize internet access. Maybe even prodigy next, AOL was next down the line. But point taken...
by Renegade Knight November 24, 2009 11:27 AM PST
AOL start wasn't internet anything. They were their own network.The rise of the internet was the end of Compuserve and Prodogy, while AOL did a fairly good job making the transition but has lost a lot of ground lately.
by DigitalAngelic November 24, 2009 8:11 PM PST
AOL. Ugh. I never did use their service (I had Earthlink for a while, I believe) but I recently worked on the computer of someone that was still using AOL dial-up. Oh, the horror.

(Also, AOL Instant Messenger is still the most popular IM service in the US. Can you believe that?)
by DigitalAngelic November 24, 2009 8:11 PM PST
AOL. Ugh. I never did use their service (I had Earthlink for a while, I believe) but I recently worked on the computer of someone that was still using AOL dial-up. Oh, the horror.

(Also, AOL Instant Messenger is still the most popular IM service in the US. Can you believe that?)
by kcm117 November 23, 2009 6:19 PM PST
I have an android phone on T-Mobile (mytouch3g) and i can do all of those things on android already?? Does verizon have a restriction on multitasking on the Droid's android build?
Reply to this comment
by cbscowards November 23, 2009 6:27 PM PST
It's not a restriction on multitasking -- CDMA cannot support both voice and data at the same time.
by mluvas November 23, 2009 6:50 PM PST
Yes it a restriction on multi-tasking at the most basic level, the network. It can only do one thing at a time and that too real SSSLLLOOOWWW!!.
by daniel172008 November 24, 2009 12:56 AM PST
You can still multi-task while on a call, you just cant use the internet and be on the phone at the same time. If you have Gmail syncing turned on then it doesn't matter because your emails will be updated periodically anyway. Its a limitation but is it really that big of a deal to call someone back?

Then again, I guess its just not a big deal for me since I'm usually texting and not on the phone anyway...
by Bakkster November 24, 2009 6:11 AM PST
@daniel172008: Only the mobile internet. Wi-fi works fine while in a call.
by JuggerNaut November 23, 2009 6:27 PM PST
The Droid has too many movable parts and Verizon's mostly reliable network is SLOW. So, IMHO, it's a stale mate. Also the Droids lack of good multi touch features (gestures, etc...) means that it doesn't hold a candle to the iPhone in its current form.

On a different note: it's good to see the Google Android OS getting some good marketing/press.
Reply to this comment
by mattumanu November 23, 2009 6:48 PM PST
The Droid Eris has multitouch. Oh well, iPhool can't win everytime.
by fortyonejb November 23, 2009 7:22 PM PST
I thought I would clarify that the droid handset can very much support multi touch, its just that apple gets all uppity defending their vapid patents that end up getting invalidated anyways, so Google is just biding their time before enabling it. Android > iPhoneOS hands down. Especially when I know my apps won't get nullified because some minimum wage app reviewer won't axe it because they are cranky one day.
by CyR00k November 23, 2009 8:12 PM PST
@fortyonejb If I remember correctly, Apple never owned the patents for multi-touch in the first place which is one of many reasons that they have been sued for the iPhone and iPod Touch infringing on other people's patents.
by daniel172008 November 24, 2009 1:10 AM PST
If you are refering to the keyboard and the battery being "movable" then most people would consider that a good thing. Actually, why would that matter unless your a complete clutz and cant hold on to your phone anyway?

As to the speed of the networks... see this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r9YGvLHvUxQ

The Droid does have multi-touch, just not in any of the native applications... and honestly you (and everyone else that uses this argument) make it sound like the phone can't zoom at all...

I would have to say that the Droid is an equal competitor to the iPhone and it really comes down to preference. That, and if your an techno-idiot then the iPhone might be slightly easier to use.
by Renegade Knight November 24, 2009 11:26 AM PST
Multitouch is nice, but it's not the end all be all. I find that having options makes the most sence. I'd like Multi Touch with a point stick and buttons for example. Both do different things well. I'd mix and match.
by Edicius00 November 23, 2009 6:28 PM PST
I've had my iPhone 3g since they came out and I've never had a single dropped call. My friends have verizon and the always complain about their signals and dropped calls. Just because it happens to some, doesn't mean that it happens to all.

ps: Verizon should be careful when poking Apple about the iPhone as they've already stated that they would love to have it on their network.
Reply to this comment
by November 23, 2009 6:36 PM PST
It really depends on the area you're in. AT&T ************************ in small towns like New York City.
by November 23, 2009 6:38 PM PST
Wow, I can't say "suckz h@iry d0nkey b@lls" on cnet? Lame...
by SIGHUP November 23, 2009 7:42 PM PST
"ps: Verizon should be careful when poking Apple about the iPhone as they've already stated that they would love to have it on their network."

Where did you hear that? It's been widely published that Apple approached Verizon first and Verizon said NO ( http://www.theregister.co.uk/2007/01/30/verizon_turned_down_iphone/ ). Hopefully it stays that way.
by lesbihonest17 November 23, 2009 6:28 PM PST
the droid sucks. i tried out that keyboard at bestbuy. it was awful. ill gladly stick with my iphone
Reply to this comment
by mr_kingpin November 23, 2009 7:22 PM PST
umm the keyboard is an option for people that dont like the touchpad keypad..nice to have the option dont you think?
by EnslavedYeti November 23, 2009 7:29 PM PST
The only thing you tried was the keyboard? Either way the physical keyboard is MUCH better than the iphone's physical keyboard... The virtual keyboard is just as good, if not better because it lists multiple words if you misspell a word, instead of iphone's single word suggestion.
by jimmyhoops November 24, 2009 12:25 AM PST
@Kingpin...not it's not, the thing weighs a ton. Why add a useless feature when a touch keyboard works just as well if not better. Driod needs to pick an option and stick with it.
by zyxxy November 24, 2009 5:17 AM PST
Droid did pick an option, the physical keyboard. The virtual keyboard is an app. What was your point, exactly?
by Bakkster November 24, 2009 6:30 AM PST
@jimmyhoops: I disagree, a physical keyboard is far better than a touch keyboard. I only use the touch on my Droid when absolutely necessary, it's far too easy to make mistakes on a touch keyboard. Also, it's faster to use capitals and symbols on the physical keyboard (can tap the shift or alt button to have only the next keypress activated), which is a big deal when you use strong passphrases.

As for being heavy, it's not overly so, although definitely more than an iPhone. Regardless, I'd rather have the extra weight of the keyboard than not be able to type easily on a light-weight phone.
by Renegade Knight November 24, 2009 11:23 AM PST
You tried out both keyboards?
by November 24, 2009 4:23 PM PST
@jimmyhoops

In a way it picked both, If you want the physical keyboard, get the droid. If you want touch keyboard only, get the droid eris. Personally, I'll stick with my Touch Pro2, great phone and does everything I need it to.

sidenote at main article, Chris I wouldn't say that Verizon was knocking the iPhone with the Misfit toys commercial. It seemed more like they were saying the iPhone was a good phone that was a misfit due to At&t.
by Gold_Storm_Mac November 23, 2009 6:31 PM PST
this is a great ad that indirectly attacks verizon well.
Reply to this comment
by November 23, 2009 6:35 PM PST
I'd say it's more grasping at straws, at best.
by Perry_Clease November 23, 2009 6:38 PM PST
"I'd say it's more grasping at straws, at best."

Yeah, I woud think that you would say that, but it is more like grabbing the brass ring.
by November 23, 2009 6:53 PM PST
"Yeah, I woud think that you would say that, but it is more like grabbing the brass ring."

So you're saying that's how an iPhone user pleasures himself?
by Perry_Clease November 24, 2009 4:15 AM PST
"So you're saying that's how an iPhone user pleasures himself?"

No surprise that you don't understand the phrase.
by Vegaman_Dan November 24, 2009 11:07 AM PST
@Gold_Storm_Mac:

Based on the story and the comments here as a response, it would appear that the ad turned out to be more of an embarassment for Apple. :/

@Perry_Clease:

"Grabbing the brass ring." That's a reference to old carnival rides on the carousel in which peopl would use sticks and lean out from the ride to try to snag brass rings from the overhanging canopy in exchange for prizes. Frequently this would result in the rider falling and causing great bodily injury to the point where this practice was banned as an unsafe and unwise activity.

Are you SURE you want to suggest that this is a GOOD thing for Apple to be compared to?

(disclosure: Still on my first year of my 2 year iPhone/AT&T contract, with a pretty decent call completion rate of 65-70%).
by bblande November 23, 2009 6:36 PM PST
timber2005, the Sprint Hero will do it only if wifi is enabled....guess it's a good thing I'm near a wifi hotspot most of the time, eh?
Reply to this comment
by mluvas November 23, 2009 6:47 PM PST
Cannot take a call and perform other tasks at the same time. Shows what a crappy network Verizon has.
Reply to this comment
by November 23, 2009 7:03 PM PST
Yup seriously. It's so crappy that it has 5x more coverage than AT&T and beat out all other networks (with AT&T at the bottom of the list) in call quality and customer satisfaction from JD Power & Associates.

Really, what a piece of turd.
by DasScooter November 23, 2009 8:56 PM PST
MR________________________ what relevance does this have when Verizon switches to LTE (GSM)?
by ausernamenoonehaschosen November 24, 2009 5:53 AM PST
Ghostwriter, AT&T was second, Sprint was last (this was on the overall average rating graph). You can't link to it over the internet though, but I read this is the magazine. Stop falsifying.
by Blader4175 November 24, 2009 9:01 AM PST
I have Sprint and i can say that i hate them more than my piece of junk PC laptop im surprised they haven't been buried under their crap phones yet.
by Renegade Knight November 24, 2009 11:22 AM PST
Is that the network of is that the Phone?
by squirrel1022 November 29, 2009 9:35 PM PST
too funny, the moto droid can do voice and web at same time. don't knock if you don't know
by drfriday November 23, 2009 7:25 PM PST
I bought the Droid the day it came out and I must say it is one cool computer. This phone definately has Apple worried and rightly so. It is very fun to use. Google is the third player that is dangerous to both Microsoft and Apple.
Reply to this comment
by jimmyhoops November 24, 2009 12:27 AM PST
Apple's not worried, it's about market share. If Driod starts to gobble that up then you might have a point. But those results won't be in for at least a year or more. Competition is a good thing. The iPhone is likely to get better, faster, as a result.
by mike234x November 24, 2009 1:01 AM PST
"Apple's not worried, it's about market share." - And Apple's market share is still small. - "The iPhone is likely to get better, faster, as a result." - The main problem with iPhone isn't quality or speed, it's price. For $1000 (unlocked), it's easy to build a kick-ass phone. But you will soon be able to get Android phones for $150 (unlocked). And Apple seems to be incapable of making anything really competitively priced. Who do you think is going to have the market share?
by gerrrg November 23, 2009 7:42 PM PST
I guess this is the perfect time to plug T-Mo, which will be running 21Mbps next year, and 7.2 Mbps by the end of this year, with no problems running data and phone calls at the same time.

Android on TMo...works for me.
Reply to this comment
by frozenjello November 23, 2009 9:38 PM PST
Those download speeds are great, but isn't it commonly accepted that T-Mobile's 3G coverage is even more sparse than AT&T's? T-Mo only started building their 3G network in 2008, after all.
by robnesstheawesome November 23, 2009 7:56 PM PST
I have a Droid, and yes... Yes my phone does do that. On my network. What do you got to say now?
Reply to this comment
by DasScooter November 23, 2009 8:24 PM PST
Which parts does it do please inform us of details
by ecyfoto November 23, 2009 7:57 PM PST
Um, so i read the article and thought I'd give it a shot with my HTC Eris. I called myself from the land line and then accessed my gmail account. No problem. Voice and data simultaneously. Should that result be any different on a Droid on the same network? Hmm.
Reply to this comment
by DasScooter November 23, 2009 8:23 PM PST
try surfing the net and get back to me
by drezjohnson November 23, 2009 8:32 PM PST
Yes, surfing the web works just as usual
by JayMonster November 24, 2009 8:42 AM PST
No... you did not get Voice and Data simultaneously. You got voice, and a cached application. It is a limitation of CDMA that you cannot do both at the same time. The simple fact of the matter is though... very few people actually care. Sure you will see lots of Apple Fanboys claiming "Oh yeah... I do that all the time." now that this ad is out but really? How often do you need to get a movie time while on the phone? And how long is the other person on the line supposed to wait while you lousy connection (even if it is 3G) loads the web page?
by drezjohnson November 23, 2009 8:28 PM PST
I don't use the Droid but I do use the MyTouch 3G on T-Mobile. I frequently check my email, send texts and use other apps while I'm on the phone. Correct me if I'm wrong but none of those features mentioned are unique to just the Iphone. The Droid is running the latest version of Android so I see no reason why the features wouldn't be the same (or better)...unless of course Verizon has some network restrictions that prevent these features
Reply to this comment
by frozenjello November 23, 2009 9:59 PM PST
Both T-Mobile and AT&T use the GSM wireless standard, so any GSM smartphone can potentially do the features shown in the above commercials. Verizon and Sprint use the CDMA standard, which can't do simultaneous voice and data. The Motorola Droid suffers from this limitation, but the GSM version, the Motorola Milestone, shouldn't have this problem.
by DrtyDogg November 24, 2009 3:05 AM PST
Actually CDMA is capable of voice and data at the same time, though Sprint and Verizon decided against it while building out their network.
by drezjohnson November 24, 2009 11:04 AM PST
Hmm...interesting...well I've never used Verizon and its been a loooooooong time since I've had Sprint but that is some useful info
by jguzman277 November 23, 2009 8:38 PM PST
While Verizon and AT&T are bickering between each other, Sprint is slowly coming from behind, one thing I know people care about more than features is how much the bill is at the end of the month. And with these two, nickel and diming people with all their fees and charging 30 for data access, they are bound to start losing customers to Sprint and T-Mobile. When I tell my friends on Verizon and AT&T how much I pay for my two phones per month their jaws drop (a little bit more than what they pay for one phone). I already got a couple to switch.
Reply to this comment
by krazytrixxxsta November 30, 2009 5:54 PM PST
i hear that...i read an article last week about how tmobile will be the leading mobile company in a few years, because of their better sevices, prices and 3 g network than the others company. not to long ago there was an article about how android os would have the second largest market share and knock iphone down to third place.
by NikEst November 23, 2009 8:46 PM PST
I have the LG Envy (yes, the first one), and I can be on the phone and sending a text message, although why I would need to I will never figure out. I also fail to see why I need my email in my pocket. We could solve all this tussle if people just realized that connectnedness is not that important.

Before being blasted as a technophobe, I am a software engineer who doubles as the IT person for a small development company. Despite all that, I get my job done well without my email in my pocket.
Reply to this comment
by jimmyhoops November 24, 2009 12:32 AM PST
You may shun connectedness, but that's not most of the rest of the world. Device convergence is the future regardless of wether or not those features are useful to you.
Showing 1 of 4 pages (203 Comments)
advertisement

Tech at the Olympics: 'No room to fail'

Q&A The Olympics relies on thousands of servers and PCs to manage all the athletes and scores. Magnus Alvarsson is the guy who must make sure everything works.

How CoverItLive lost it on iPad day

The live-blogging tool fell apart under the strain of a Steve Jobs keynote. Here's what happened, and what comes next for the company.

advertisement

About Technically Incorrect

Chris Matyszczyk brings a fresh and irreverent perspective to the tech world in his CNET blog, Technically Incorrect. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Technically Incorrect topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right