• On GameSpot: Wii Fit tells 10-year-old she's fat
July 6, 2008 5:15 PM PDT

Apple MacBook: Change is in the Air

The Apple MacBook Air has been a ground-breaking first-generation product (in my opinion). So, what will Apple do to top it when an update comes later this year? There are some telling indicators already. This is what I expect--and hope for--as a user.

(Credit: Apple)

First, a disclaimer. I am not an Apple fanatic. The MacBook Air is the first Apple product I have ever used for more than a few days. For well over a decade, I have been wedded to Wintel (Windows-Intel) laptops.

Before I dive into upcoming features, I should also mention that I have been extremely pleased with the Air and have used it almost daily for the last four months. But I would be remiss if I didn't say it is overpriced, as all subnotebooks are.

• Overpriced but still an amazing design Apple made a very studied decision to exclude certain features. This makes the Air an Air. Apple could have included more ports and a little more of this and pinch of that--but then it would have been just another subnotebook.

So, I expect Apple to maintain the uniqueness of the Air for the next refresh.

But improvements are always welcome. And here are a few things that potential buyers can expect to see when a new Air is rolled out.

Apple has begun to give us hints of things to come. A $500 price cut for the solid state drive (SSD) model is one of the biggest indicators so far.

• A bigger, better solid state drive The next Air will offer drives that range in size to more than 100GB. A likely offering would be 128GB from vendors like STEC. (Samsung supplies the current SSD.) Intel and Micron Technology can't be ruled out. Their drives will come in 80GB and 160GB capacities.

These SSDs will also likely use multiple-level cell (MLC) technology, in contrast with current drives that use single-level-cell (SLC). MLC allows higher-capacities but presents power and data reliability challenges, which suppliers claim to have overcome.

• Processors Invariably, all notebooks get upgraded with better processors and graphics. I think the Air's current performance is superb for a subnotebook. I have owned many subnotebooks over the years and anemic performance can render them practically unusable as an everyday machine. But I haven't had this problem with the Air (see note at bottom).

Intel's upcoming 45-nanometer "Montevina" (Centrino 2) low-power offerings should make this experience even better. Though an initial Montevina refresh is slated for July 14, low-power versions won't appear until this fall. Intel refers to these as SFF (small form factor) processors. They will come in high-performance, low-voltage, and ultra-low-voltage variants.

SFF Montevina processors will range from 25-watt (2.4GHz) to 17-watt (1.86GHz) to 10-watt (1.2GHz). The current Intel processor used in the Air is rated at 20 watts at 1.8GHz.

Whether Apple chooses one of these or opts for something not currently on the Intel roadmap of course remains to be seen.

• Graphics Graphics will get upgraded. Montevina will come with Intel's GMA X4500 graphics, which Intel has said repeatedly will be three times faster than current X3100 integrated graphics.

• Battery Insufficient battery life is a problem that plagues all subnotebooks. It has often been suggested that Apple include a removable battery (for easy replacement), but that could compromise the ultraslim design. Having said that, I have been pleased with the battery life compared with other notebooks I have owned.

Hazarding a guess at other features such as upgraded hard disk drives, better screens, and external extras like a docking station is too speculative (and the latter would also compromise the design), so I'll refrain from making any predictions.

But the Air shouldn't change too much. With a simple performance upgrade, it would be an even more remarkable computer.

(Note: No, the Air is not as fast as a 14-inch Hewlett-Packard 6910P, for example, but no PC maker can squeeze that kind of performance into a Air-like form factor.)

Brooke Crothers is a former editor at large at CNET News.com, and has been an editor for the Asian weekly version of the Wall Street Journal. He writes for the CNET Blog Network, and is not a current employee of CNET. Contact him at mbcrothers@gmail.com. Disclosure.
Recent posts from Nanotech: The Circuits Blog
Micron to buy $400 million stake in memory maker
Chip forecasts head south
Micron to cut workforce by 15 percent, slash flash output
Eying solid-state drives, Seagate tries to quell fears
AMD deal triggers Intel license warning
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 32 comments (Showing first 20 comments)
by Mam00th July 6, 2008 5:46 PM PDT
"Apple could have included more ports and a little more of this and pinch of that--but then it would have been just another subnotebook."

I don't know but for me this killed your credibility as an Apple critic (althought you aren't really one). To say that having less features makes this subnotebook somewhat better just prove how deep you are in the reality distortion field...At least you did said that it was overpriced but what you missed is that it is overpriced even for a subnotebook althought the new price since the price drop much better.

"Insufficient battery life is a problem that plagues all subnotebooks". Well I haven't heard many people with the X300 complain.

All in all I mean is come on... be objective. I know this is not journalism but still. I have to admit that the Macbook air is far from being a piece of ****; actually it does its job really well as a subnotebook. But you have to admit that in term of price feature there are far better options out there.

Watch this Macbook Air spoof, it's hilarious wether you like the MBA or not.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_hnOCUkbix0
Reply to this comment
by Mam00th July 6, 2008 6:04 PM PDT
Sorry for this wall of text but your comment system doesn't like paragraphs
Reply to this comment
by anonymous x July 6, 2008 7:15 PM PDT
I agree with on thing in this article- the macbook air is groundbreaking. In fact, it is so ground breaking that Apple decided to cut out features from its new laptop- I don't see other manufacturers doing that.
*sarcasm*
Reply to this comment
by dechah July 6, 2008 7:55 PM PDT
NEWSFLASH - The next model of the Apple Macbook Air will have better CPU, Bigger storage, better graphics and battery life...wow such a bold prediction, you lady rank as one of the great seers of the tech world.

And maybe the reason Apple dropped $500 off the solid state HDD model price four and half months after it become available to purchase, is because they weren't selling many (even by Apple's low standards) at the old price.
Reply to this comment View reply
by kccsf July 6, 2008 9:35 PM PDT
ummm... you left out more RAM. 2GB just does not cut it anymore. if they could get 4GB of RAM, the solid state drive over 100-120GB, and a faster proc(2.2-2.4), I'd be all over the new AIR. Anyone of those missing, though, and I'll just buy a standard MacBook(they better not get rid of the current black macbook!).
Reply to this comment
by protagonistic July 6, 2008 9:49 PM PDT
2GB of RAM works fine with just about every OS except Vista.
Reply to this comment
by dechah July 6, 2008 11:07 PM PDT
2GB of RAM works perfectly fine with Vista as well
Reply to this comment
by irfaanp July 6, 2008 11:53 PM PDT
"but no PC maker can squeeze that kind of performance into a Air-like form factor." Are you kidding? Check out the Voodoo Envy. Brilliant, loaded, and thinner than the Macbook Air.
Reply to this comment View reply
by webterractive July 7, 2008 12:10 AM PDT
Reality is that everything is moving towards the minimal scale and no one can do that better than Apple. People should also keep in mind that price cuts don't always mean something better coming. I'm surprised that the Macbook didn't freeze, something very apparent with these computers.
Reply to this comment
by digbychicken July 7, 2008 2:12 AM PDT
irfaanp does have a point, Apple seriously needs to pull their finger out with the next version of the Air. the Voodoo Envy does have everything I'm looking for out of an ultra thin laptop that also has the same specs as the Air plus more.

Included optical drive, esata (cleverly combined with another usb port) and an express card slot, the charger also doubles as a WiFi hotspot ala airport express. It doesn't run my os of choice however and not sure how it would react to having linux installed as opposed to using Vista (99% Microsoft free here since 2004, I'm not going back)
Reply to this comment
by WhuzYoDaddy July 7, 2008 4:50 AM PDT
The Air is the Jessica Simpson of laptops - nice to look at, but......
Reply to this comment
by badasscat July 7, 2008 6:58 AM PDT
So basically, the point of this article is that Apple will boost the performance of the MacBook Air without addressing a single one of its shortcomings?

This is usually the opposite of what Apple does. They make a big deal out of fixing problems (without ever admitting that they were problems) and adding features, and they save the performance bumps for random times throughout the year without even announcing them.

Look at the Mac G5 vs. the Mac Pro. "The PowerPC is the fastest CPU on Earth!" 2 months later... "All hail Intel!" G5: "We only have one optical drive slot because that's all anyone needs." Mac Pro: "We're doubling the number of optical drive slots!"

They love taking solutions to problems and making them sound like great new features they thought up.

I expect we'll see more ports on the Air, and possibly a built-in optical drive. It would surprise me if we didn't eventually see a removeable battery, although maybe not in the next iteration.
Reply to this comment View reply
by Seaspray0 July 7, 2008 7:17 AM PDT
NEWS FLASH. What we can expect from ALL computer makers in the future are improved hard drives, memory, and processors... not just apple. As for my speculation, people would rather have a laptop that includes an optical drive built into it.
Reply to this comment
by Zaunto July 7, 2008 8:29 AM PDT
The Macbook Air is designed for a limited user base- Executives who can do without the features they left out of it. The Solid State Drive and thinness of the notebook are the only real "WOW factor" features about it. As with the iPhone, Apple didn't produce anything new that hasn't already been done. They just eliminated features and produced a clean product that does what it's advertised to do and does it well. Would I buy one? No. The missing features are the deal breaker for me. Would I use a Macbook Pro as my primary computer? Sure. It has everything needed to get the job done as well as dual boot into Windows.
Reply to this comment
by InertAgent July 7, 2008 8:53 AM PDT
Hopefully the overheating and core shutdown issues with normal use of the Macbook Air will be fixed in the next version.

http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1387729&tstart=0
Reply to this comment
by Vegaman_Dan July 7, 2008 9:33 AM PDT
I would suggest Apple do something like make it sellable to customers. Right now it's a unit that people buy to be seen with it, not actually using it. It's a status symbol, but even Mac fans admit that when it comes down to it and they need to get something done, they use a MacBookPro instead of the Air. Right now the Air is tops for being the most expensive and least capable, but it is damnably sexy. Sure there are plenty of other laptops available that are smaller, thinner, lighter, cheaper, more powerful- all the things that Apple promotes, but only the Air has that Apple logo. You're buying prestige, elitism, snobbery. Then there are people who actually use laptops and they go with any of the other models out there from Apple, Dell, Toshiba, Sony and others. It's a nice toy, but really... not much more than that. I'ld rather have a MBP.
Reply to this comment View reply
by lakelarry July 7, 2008 10:16 AM PDT
when is Apple going to support blu-ray drives? That is what I am looking for next from Apple.
Reply to this comment
by JoeAllenWrench July 7, 2008 10:48 AM PDT
I personally have found owning apple products to be frustratingly restrictive. This goes back to my Apple IIc, then my Ipod, and I?m sure it will be the same with my Iphone on Friday. I have always felt like they decide what features I need and then, they don?t just leave out the other features I want, they almost go to lengths to prohibit me from figuring out a way (or hack) to get them myself. With that said, I am also so sucked into experience of owning Apple products. From the way it?s packaged, to its documentation, and then the experience of using it, (granted ? all for a price) I don?t think any other technology company can replicate this. I?m in the market for a ultra portable or mini notebook. I like the Eee PC (1000) but I do keep coming back to the Air. Are there any rumors as to when the next Air will be available????
Reply to this comment
by qquidd July 8, 2008 5:19 AM PDT
Macbook Air is for "AIRHEADS".
Zaunto says - "The Macbook Air is designed for a limited user base- Executives who can do without the features they left out of it."

Say what? Executives die without the features Apple left out. Have you seen the Lenovo laptops that real Execs carry? I personally would run from any exec who carries an Apple laptop - it is a clear sign of a pretentious bastard who can't get any work done.
Reply to this comment View reply
by JoeAllenWrench July 8, 2008 8:16 AM PDT
Sorry for the dup comment (replying doesn't work very well)

I won't argue about pretentious or executives who need/want features, but can't get any work done with an Air? I have a CAD workstation for when I need to do design work, I would never do that on a laptop for reasons beyond horsepower. But on the train or sitting in bed, do I need all that much power for responding to emails, writing specs, researching on the web?

I'm considering the Air because its so portable and because it Apple, but not so much because of the bling affect. The Lenovo you sepak of, is that the X300???
Reply to this comment
 See all 32 Comments >>
Powered by Jive Software
Resource center from CNET News sponsors
What Do You Get With Your Hosting Provider?
The Rackspace Essential Server

Rackspace Hosting
It's a server that automatically comes with unlimited support never outsourced, and a world-class network & data centers with solid guarantees all working for your business. We are here 24x7x365 Live

Click Here!
Unlimited, 24x7x365 Live Support

It means customer support with no call centers or automated phone systems

100% Network Uptime Guarantee

Can you afford for your website to offline? Can you trust your current provider?

The Manageable Green Hosting Solution

Choose a green configuration or customize one that works for your business.

The Fanatical Support Promise

Your complete satisfaction is our sole ambition. Anything less is unacceptable.

Certified Windows or Red Hat Expertise

Every customer has a dedicated team of experts managing your IT critical needs.

About Nanotech: The Circuits Blog

Brooke Crothers was formerly editor-at-large at CNET News.com, an analyst at IDC (International Data Corp.) Japan, and an editor at The Asian Wall Street Journal Weekly (The Wall Street Journal, Dow Jones), among other endeavors, including a recent hiatus from the tech industry when he co-managed an after-school math and reading center. Nanotech covers computer chip technology and how it defines the computing experience. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network, and is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Nanotech: The Circuits Blog topics

Featured blogs

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right