April 4, 2008 3:30 PM PDT

MacBook Air verdict: Seminal computer, five reasons

The Apple MacBook Air is a seminal computer. There I said it. I'm not going to pretend that my opinion is the final word (or anything close to it) but I will weigh in by saying it's a ground-breaking product. After using it for about two months, here's why.

(Note: I am not a Mac enthusiast. This is the first Apple I've ever owned.)

This is not a CNET review. The CNET review is here.

MacBook Air

MacBook Air

(Credit: Apple)

1. Very thin, very light but comparatively fast. That's no mean feat. Subnotebooks I've had in the past (e.g., the Compaq Evo N400c) were thin and light but slow. Usually compromised by an ultra-slow hard disk drive (more on that below). The Air is not a speed demon but it's not slow either. (It uses a full-blown Core 2 Duo 1.8-GHz processor not a slower ultra-low-voltage processor). Granted, this is a subjective evaluation. But day-to-day subjective experience matters too.

2. Solid state drive (SSD): The SSD is revolutionary. At first, I thought the SSD was, at best, a fascinating novelty. But it has turned out to be one of the most practical, useful hardware improvements to a notebook computer since the active-matrix color liquid crystal display, in my opinion. I can't overstate enough that hard drive bottlenecks have been virtually eliminated. I could give a number of examples but here's the most salient: No disk thrashing. On my other (faster, high-end) PC notebook, lots of open applications means lots of disk activity. Which slows everything down. This has not happened on the Air. A blessing.

3. Sturdy. For a sub-one-inch-thin notebook, it feels remarkably solid. Enough said.

4. Battery life. The consensus is that the Air's battery life is bad to awful. I can only compare the battery life against the other PC notebooks I use. The Air beats them all. For what I do on the Air (a lot of open windows, occasional moderate Web development, writing), it lasts anywhere from three to five hours. In this sense, I agree with this post that says using the Air as your main, do-everything computer (which I do not do) is missing the point of what the Air is intended to be (and will result in lousy battery life).

5. Looks. You can't beat the aesthetics. The Starbucks status factor can't be ignored.

Notes. Obviously, the Air has its (well-publicized) shortcomings. I will mention three: It can get hot occasionally, the keyboard is OK but not great, and the high price is off-putting. But I will say this: for a cutting-edge, groundbreaking design, it has surprisingly few faults. (The fact that it has few ports and no optical drive has not fazed me one bit.)

Here's another take at Macworld.

Recent posts from Nanotech: The Circuits Blog
Timing rumors surface for AMD plant spin-off
Nvidia, AMD gaming graphics buck green-PC trend
Intel ready to announce six-core chip
Intel invests in WiMax again amid doubts
Intel lists new low-cost processors
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 6 comments
by cyberDJ April 4, 2008 4:20 PM PDT
Let's give credit where credit is due.

If it weren't for Intel, there would be no Air.
This thin of a laptop would not have been possible with IBM or Motorola CPUs.

Intel is the ONLY reason Apple finally has the hardware to backup its ridiculous hype.

Apple is finally realizing what PC hobbyist have always known,
if you don't have any ass under the hood, it doesn't matter what the body looks like.
Reply to this comment
by only_truth April 4, 2008 4:33 PM PDT
You list only THREE shortcomings... you can't be serious. Let's try no optical drive, no removable battery, only one USB port, and come on, no ethernet? Everything the Macbook Air lacks the Lonovo X300 makes up for and then some.

Let me tell you something about SSDs too. They are not the end-all devices that free the demand for growth in memory storage. Research is being conducted on many new polymers that can store bits of data in polarized cells. After a few million writes on NAND flash, it will wear out. That's unacceptable for many real-life applications. NAND is not as fast as NOR, nor as cheap as SATA. There will be a day when NAND is outdated.

You called SSD a novelty... take a look at your Air and you'll see a novelty item. It's over-priced and under-functional. Sure it looks pretty, but I got over that in about 5 minutes.
Reply to this comment
by Mam00th April 5, 2008 6:48 AM PDT
Personnaly I dont really like the ultra thin look of the Macbook Air, but again this is my opinion but I find it rather strange that many people are saying that SSD is an advantage for the macbook air. Many laptops out there can have a SSD for a lot less then the 3200$ price tag for the macbook air... SSD are expensive, thats a fact but not 1300 bucks for 64 gb...
Reply to this comment
by jmpgh April 7, 2008 7:57 AM PDT
Credit for using an Intel chip to produce an ultrathin, fully functional computer is due to Apple. Isn't it the case that the other manufacturers have also been able to buy Intel chips and haven't made such excellent use of them?
Reply to this comment
by Llib Setag April 7, 2008 8:22 AM PDT
No Ethernet? Uhm...MBAIR is a road warrior jet set book.
Ethernet on a jet?
USB TO ETHERNET ADAPTOR.
No optical drive?
Uhm...WIRELESS INTERNET BUILT IN.
Movies & music can be downloaded.
Large USB Memory flash sticks instead of CD.
Install info & program before traveling.
Install info or program WIRELESSLY via PC / MAC computer optical drives with software included with AIR.
WHY would a travelor need more than one USB port?

WIRELESS + INTERNET is the power of the MBAIR.

Not for everyone, but not designed for everyone.
Reply to this comment
by jmo507 April 8, 2008 8:02 AM PDT
"using the Air as your main, do-everything computer (which I do not do) is missing the point of what the Air is intended to be (and will result in lousy battery life)."

ummmm... for $3k I would be planning on using this for everything. that is quite possibly the stupidest idea I've ever heard... drop $3k on a laptop to use as my secondary device? I guess if you are pretentious enough to spend $3k to look better at starbucks, maybe you do have a $6k computer for the heavy work. ha ha ha. Let's face it, the $1800 air with the slow ipod hd is a joke, and $3k for a SSD is a joke if you can't use it for your primary computer. get the regular macbook for $999 with waaaay better stuff.

If I wanted a secondary computer, I would get an eee pc or something like that for $500, to spend $3k on something to surf the web on.
Reply to this comment
Powered by Jive Software
advertisement

Latest tech news headlines

Resource center from News.com sponsors
What you need in business class email.
Mailtrust

Click Here!
Never worry about email again. From mobility and shared calendaring to virus and spam protection starting at only $3 per mailbox. more>

Rackspace Mailtrust
Total Email Relief

We'll take care of your email so you can take care of your business.

14 Day Free Trial

With expert support 24x7x365 we guarentee 100% uptime. Try us for free for 14 days. Never worry about your email again.

Just $3 per mailbox

Choose the plan that is right for your company and only pay for what you need.

About Nanotech: The Circuits Blog

Brooke Crothers was formerly editor-at-large at CNET News.com, an analyst at IDC (International Data Corp.) Japan, and an editor at The Asian Wall Street Journal Weekly (The Wall Street Journal, Dow Jones), among other endeavors, including a recent hiatus from the tech industry when he co-managed an after-school math and reading center. Nanotech covers computer chip technology and how it defines the computing experience. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network, and is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Nanotech: The Circuits Blog topics

Featured blogs

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right
  • Nanotech: The Circuits Blog

    Timing rumors surface for AMD plant spin-off

    Rumors persist that Advanced Micro Devices is planning to spin off all or part of its manufacturing operations.

  • Gallery

    Photos: Ron Paul's RNC alternative

    As the Republican convention took place just miles away, a crowd rallied for the former presidential candidate and his message of limited government, ensured civil liberties, lower taxes, and peace.

  • Digital Noise: Music and Tech

    Was 1980s music that bad?

    NPR asks listeners which year featured the best music, and the 1980s emerge as a bleak era. Personally, the '80s figure prominently in my collection, but well behind the 1970s.

  • Beyond Binary

    Microsoft begins big ad push

    Microsoft's multi-year push, estimated at $300 million, begins with a spot featuring Bill Gates and Jerry Seinfeld aired during Thursday's NFL game.

  • Video

    YouTube plays party politics

    During the presidential campaigning four years ago, YouTube didn't even exist. Now it's a tool candidates must master to get their message across. CNET's Kara Tsuboi stops by the YouTube upload booths at the Democratic and Republican conventions to find out why Google's video site has such a big presence in Denver and St. Paul, Minn.

  • News - Digital Media

    Michael Moore plans Net-only film premiere

    Filmmaker plans to premiere his latest documentary exclusively on the Internet for free, forgoing the traditional theatrical release.

  • Video

    Political party playlists

    We know the Democrats and Republicans are split over policy issues, but does their musical taste fall down party lines too? And what kind of gadgets did they bring to the conventions to listen to their music? CNET reporter Kara Tsuboi finds out.

  • News - Politics and Law

    What you can--and can't--find about Palin on the Internet

    John McCain's choice of Sarah Palin as a running mate has inspired a wealth of creativity on the Internet.

  • News - Cutting Edge

    Execs predict next Google-like tech

    On eve of company's 10-year anniversary, researchers and business pundits speculate about what technologies might someday have as much impact as Google.

  • Gallery

    Photos: The brains behind Google Chrome

    Here's a look at some of the engineers and executives who took the stage at the company's headquarters as they unveiled the new browser.

  • Crossfade

    Ying Yang Twins, 'Look Back At It': Free MP3 of the Day

    This amped-up duo gets the party started with a mix of crisp, Southern hip-hop beats and shout-along rhymes. Download a free MP3 of "Look Back At It" courtesy of CNET Download Music.

  • Green Tech

    Clean-tech group forms to support Obama

    "Clean Tech and Green Business for Obama" aims to raise $1 million for the Democratic presidential nominee while elevating issues of climate change and alternative energy.