• On TV.com: Why Is Everyone in TV High School SO OLD
March 2, 2009 8:20 PM PST

Psion says Intel 'unjustly enriched' by Netbook

by Brooke Crothers
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 5 comments

Psion Teklogix has answered Intel's claims regarding the chipmaker's right to use the term "Netbook." The Canadian company claims that Intel is being "unjustly enriched" by unauthorized use of the trademark.

Psion Teklogix Netbook Pro

Psion Teklogix Netbook Pro

(Credit: Psion Teklogix)

Last week, Intel filed for a declaratory judgment against Psion Teklogix, claiming that the the term "netbook" is a "widely used generic term that describes a class of affordable computing devices, much like the term 'notebook' or 'ultra-mobile PC,'" Intel said in a statement last week.

Not surprisingly, Psion had a firm response: "Intel has acted willfully and maliciously, has unlawfully attempted to trade on the tremendous commercial value, reputation and goodwill of the NETBOOK mark," Psion said in a court filing in the U.S. District Court Northern District of California.

Ironically, Psion lists a product called "Netbook Pro" as discontinued on its Web site. It describes the product as having the "virtues of a larger laptop device such as a large screen, full keyboard and multiple communications ports."

Psion did not use the Netbook trademark on laptop computers for five consecutive years following the date of registration in 2000--apparently a legal requirement--mostly because Psion's mobile computers did not succeed in the market and were discontinued, according to Intel.

Psion denies its discontinued selling laptop computers under the mark netbook in approximately 2003, as Intel alleges. In October 2003, Psion launched the Netbook Pro laptop computer and denies that sales of the Netbook Pro have been discontinued.

In the filing, Psion lists retail sales (in dollars) of laptop computers "under Psion's NETBOOK mark" in the U.S. from 1999 to the present. For example, in 2005 Psion cites sales of netbooks at $1,709,433, in 2006 sales were $2,073,207, and in 2007, Psion says retail sales were $586,680.

Psion Teklogix was formed in 2000 when Teklogix merged with Psion PLC, a U.K. company which made handheld "organizers" in the 1980s and 1990s whose tiny clamshell design resembled the smallest Netbooks offered today.

The company is also demanding a jury trial.

Brooke Crothers has been an editor at large at CNET News, an analyst at IDC Japan, and an editor at The Asian Wall Street Journal Weekly, among other endeavors, including co-manager of an after-school math-and-reading center. He writes for the CNET Blog Network and is not a current employee of CNET. Disclosure.
Recent posts from Nanotech - The Circuits Blog
Netbook vs. iPhone: A better comparison
Nvidia calls Intel's graphics chip tactics 'aggressive'
$1.25 billion later, can AMD take business from Intel?
AMD: Our claims about Intel have been 'ratified'
AMD talks 'Hemlock' graphics, next ultra-thin laptops
Intel Celeron chip anchors $249 Acer Windows 7 laptop
Nvidia CEO says 'no' to Intel-compatible chip
First iPhone, now Droid. Who needs Windows?
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (5 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by docparkny March 2, 2009 9:08 PM PST
This is all terribly sad. At one point, Psion was the only manufacturer to create the box (Psion Series 5) and the operating system (EPOC OS), but gave up the ghost when faced with turbulence at the end of the dot.com boom. What they had in the original netbook was the absolute best combination of form factor and operating system with the technology available at that time. By giving the OS away to Symbian and giving up on consumer electronics, Psion basically gave up on early smartphones, leaving it to Treo and others. But what really killed them was Microsoft -not in its dominance this time, but in the suckiness of Windows CE on clamshell PDA's. People saw these more frequently -horrible lookalike, crash alike failures from Casio, HP, NEC, and others, and rarely saw the British jewels created by Psion, that people assumed all clamshell PDA's just sucked.

Palm almost died this death by Windows Mobile (CE), and is just escaping (maybe) with their new OS and Pre phone.

What netbooks should be are what the first netbook by Psion promised to be: instant on, portable, wireless, great keyboard, 8-10hrs battery, and instant off. Windows is again killing the category by proving to everyone that a netbook is just a really small and barely usable Windows laptop. Runs acceptably well with XP and not so great with VISTA, but hey, you get what you pay for -so goes Microsoft thinking.

netbooks should do what the Nokia 810 achieves and what iPhone maddeningly dances around -true portable internet appliance. The clamshell formfactor needs a hero, but not one that boots up Vista like the Fujitsu 820, or costs over $2000 like the Sony UX50 UMPC. Psion shouldn't be suing, but updating its Revo with a color screen, Li battery, Wifi, and maybe a phone, using Linux or EPOC 6.0. It should offer an updated, wireless, Series 5mx. And simply put, if they merely offered their netbook Pro, which they sucked up and failed by using Windows CE, by updating with built in wireless and a working Linux and sold it for $500 to $700, they would sell these hand over fist.

I've been bellyaching about this on my blog entries below:
http://golfism.wordpress.com/2009/03/02/top-12-features-not-yet-found-on-any-one-netbook/

http://golfism.wordpress.com/2009/01/10/the-netbook/

http://golfism.wordpress.com/2009/02/18/the-protonetbook/

http://golfism.wordpress.com/2009/01/31/12-things-i-hate-about-iphone/
Reply to this comment
by slickuser March 2, 2009 9:37 PM PST
Intel called a "category" of notebooks as netbooks. They did not sell any
Intel branded notebooks as "netbooks".

psian's claim is wrong and looks like they are after $$$$
Reply to this comment
by forever4now March 3, 2009 1:52 AM PST
Independent of the outcome of this trademark case, Psion Teklogix should consider refreshing the hardware of their Netbook Pro and offering it with Android. Everyone else is getting into this market and the Netbook Pro already has many of the important attributes: attractive compact design, touchscreen, long battery life, etc.

Since Android is expected to become a significant OS in the mobile computing space, attaching themselves to it early could provide them a significant boost in visibility & product sales.
Reply to this comment
by hammeroftruth March 3, 2009 9:18 AM PST
Intel has a lot of money. They should just pull an Apple and buy a license to use the phrase "netbook" and then have all the manufacturers buy a license as well. Hey it worked for Cisco, they licensed "iPhone" to Apple and are raking in the cash.
Reply to this comment
by Button Boy March 3, 2009 12:24 PM PST
Psion ran out of ideas, so in come the lawyers.
Reply to this comment
(5 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

A CNET Conversation with Eric Schmidt

CNET's Tom Krazit and Molly Wood sit down with Google CEO Eric Schmidt to discuss the future of Android, the Chrome OS, the problem of real-time search indexing, and more.

Verizon tests sending RIAA copyright notices

The No. 2 phone company, known for its reluctance to intervene in antipiracy cases, strikes an agreement to forward copyright notices on behalf of the music industry.

advertisement

About Nanotech - The Circuits Blog

Brooke Crothers was formerly editor-at-large at CNET News.com, an analyst at IDC (International Data Corp.) Japan, and an editor at The Asian Wall Street Journal Weekly (The Wall Street Journal, Dow Jones), among other endeavors, including a recent hiatus from the tech industry when he co-managed an after-school math and reading center. Nanotech covers computer chip technology and how it defines the computing experience. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network, and is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Nanotech - The Circuits Blog topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right