• On CBS MoneyWatch: Report: Tiger to Pay Wife $60 Million
March 26, 2009 9:00 AM PDT

The right way to destroy an old hard drive

by Dennis O'Reilly
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 32 comments
Share

I'm a confirmed pack rat. I've got stacks of old utility-bill statements dating back to the 1980s. Alongside the boxes of ancient paper records in our attic are about a half dozen old PCs. The jewel of my "collection" is an original 60-MHz Pentium PC, complete with the famous floating-point bug. Well, it was famous in 1994.

One benefit of holding onto these PC relics is not worrying about their data falling into the wrong hands. (OK, I suppose a determined thief could break into our attic and walk off with the computer antiques, but I wish them luck finding the cables and peripherals required to bring the machines back to life.)

Not everyone is so attached to their old electronic equipment as I am. You probably know that you need to completely wipe or remove the hard drives from your PCs before you donate or recycle them. How to ensure that the data on the drives will be out of the bad guys' reach is another matter.

(On a related subject, don't ever let a computer repair shop hold onto your old hard drive if they replace it. And don't believe them if they say they returned the drive to the vendor. If they give you this spiel, call the cops and demand that they return the old hard drive to you, right then, right there.)

Free data-wiping program obliterates your data
If you want to keep the drive usable but totally erased, use the free Darik's Boot and Nuke (DBAN), which comes in a version that runs off floppy disks and USB flash drives and another that runs off a CD or a DVD. The program's interface won't win any awards, but DBAN has a solid reputation among security experts.

Attack the platter to render a hard-disk unreadable
No matter how thorough a data-wiping program is, the only way to be certain that a hard-drive's data is unrecoverable is by rendering the drive's platters unspinnable. I've heard and read all kinds of methods people use to destroy an old drive, some of which are downright dangerous.

Put it in a fire? There are lots of toxic chemicals in that gadget. Do you really want to be breathing them or otherwise releasing them into the environment? Microwaves are handy for destroying CDs and DVDs, but you'd have to cook a hard drive for a long, long time to blister the drive's platters.

Several Web sites suggest soaking the drive in diluted hydrochloric or muriatic acid. This might work, but you run the risk of burning yourself or breathing toxic fumes. Lots of people recommend breaking out the power tools and drilling several holes through the drive. You can achieve the same effect by pounding some nails through it, or simply by whacking the heck out of it with a hammer, sledge or otherwise.

I'm normally a big fan of brute-force methods, for the vicarious thrill if for no other reason. But the goal is to make sure you can't spin the drive's platters. There's a more subtle approach that achieves this, without necessarily requiring safety goggles.

I found a great step-by-step tutorial written by David Gewirtz that describes how to disassemble a drive, remove the platters (and other components, including the drive's magnets), and sand or grind the platter surfaces, which renders them unreadable.

David's method requires the use of TORX driver bits to remove the small screws holding the drive's case in place. These can set you back about $20, but you might be able to save the money by using a large, flat-head screwdriver to pry the case off.

David also suggests degaussing the platters by placing them between neodymium magnets before grinding their surfaces, which obliterates the data they hold. This strikes me as overkill, but I guess you can't be too careful when protecting your private data. Making wind chimes out of the degaussed and sanded platters, as David's wife did, is strictly optional.

Dennis O'Reilly has covered PCs and other technologies in print and online since 1985. Along with more than a decade as editor for Ziff-Davis's Computer Select, Dennis edited PC World's award-winning Here's How section for more than seven years. He is a member of the CNET blog Network, and is not an employee of CNET.
Recent posts from Workers' Edge
The best of Windows 7's new interface features
Four ways to reduce your PC's carbon footprint
Five tips for safe Web shopping
Browser security features compared
Essential Firefox security add-ons
Troubleshoot Microsoft Word printer problems
Troubleshoot Windows 7 upgrade woes
Browse safely by blocking Web ads
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (32 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by Get_Bent March 26, 2009 10:10 AM PDT
My personal favorite: take the drive to the target range, put it 50 yards out, and shoot it several times with a .308. Guaranteed to render the drive unreadable and a great stress reliever, too!
Reply to this comment
by geekbully March 27, 2009 2:22 PM PDT
A person after my own heart. This is the funnest way to end the life of a magnetic platter.
by ferretboy88 March 29, 2009 9:16 PM PDT
That would do the trick. I was going to say .223 but .308 would be so much better.
by viper396 March 26, 2009 10:47 AM PDT
I have a problem with the author's comment about not believing the repair shop when they say the drive went back to the vendor. He assumes that every repair shop is manned by identy thieves prying into your data. For the author to say "call the cops" is just irresponsible journalism. (Like cops don't have anything better to do)

Fact, if a drive fails under warranty you usually have to send the drive back to the vendor before they will give you a replacement. It 's completely absurd if repair shops are going to get the cops call on them everytime they actually try to do their job.
Reply to this comment
by c|net Reader March 27, 2009 9:19 AM PDT
A legitimate repair shop should have no problem giving the disk to the customer for warranty replacement. There are, sadly, too many unscrupulous folks to trust any shop, not well known, with one's data.
by pcfish March 27, 2009 10:18 AM PDT
If you want to trust them, fine. But telling us to trust the repair shops, that's irresponsible.
by geekbully March 27, 2009 2:19 PM PDT
Agreed with CNET Reader and pcfish
Trust no one with data you wouldn't freely share with the public.
by lupin_3rd March 26, 2009 11:28 AM PDT
sledge hammer
Reply to this comment
by Rick Cavaretti March 26, 2009 3:50 PM PDT
End result similar to ex's personality...
by woodygg March 27, 2009 7:26 AM PDT
transfer platters to recovery... still readable... to simply stop the platters from spinning is irrelevant and the wrong test if you truly want to ensure your data is unreadable.
by geekbully March 26, 2009 12:56 PM PDT
I'd take this a step back and start by using a PC safely to begin with. Aside from when it's time to ditch the PC, there's also the chance that the PC could be stolen from your home or office. Using a program like TrueCrypt you can perform total drive Encryption to protect your data. This really is the only practical answer. Mac users (I'm one of those too) have encryption options built right into the OS called File Vault.
Reply to this comment
by donsms March 27, 2009 5:09 AM PDT
What?,you work for Steve Gibson or somethin?
by pcfish March 27, 2009 10:20 AM PDT
If you are working on classified materials, sure. But these drive encryption just make the already not-so-fast hard disk even so unbearably slow.
by geekbully March 27, 2009 2:05 PM PDT
donsms Don't work for him but am a huge fan of Steve Gibson!

pcfish Classified materials or not I don't want anyone looking at my personal data without my permission. :) Unless your a hardcore gamer looking for maximum frame rates, you aren't going to see much if any difference in performance. I run a media center PC several years old now with total drive encryption. It plays content localy and streams media to a console on my LAN without any hiccups what so ever. I believe your statement was true a few years ago with previous encryption technologies. However TrueCrypt is engineered very well. Speed is not an issue for encryption anymore.
by treet007 March 26, 2009 2:26 PM PDT
The one thing that is missing in the tutorial "How to destroy a hard drive (on purpose) (continued)" is that you should recycle your old hard drive, not dump it in the trash. Most recycling centers will take electronic equipment at no or little charge.
Reply to this comment
by doreilly March 26, 2009 3:51 PM PDT
Dear treet007,

Part 2 on recycling your drive and other electronic equipment will appear on March 30. Stay tuned!

Thanks,
Dennis
by pcfish March 27, 2009 10:21 AM PDT
If I hammer it to pieces, would they still take it?
by kevinsmacdonald March 29, 2009 5:31 PM PDT
pcfish: not sure about if you hammer it, but i've drilled holes in mine before and they took it
by tipoo_ March 26, 2009 2:31 PM PDT
Just open the thing up and use it as a high-tech mirror.
Reply to this comment
by tcr071 March 26, 2009 3:53 PM PDT
Open it up and sand grind the platters? How boring is that.

1. Mix a large amount of styrofoam with gasoline and Tide (washing detergent) in a large metal container.

2. Find an area safe from fire hazards (not near you house, in your backyard, etc. Go to a construction site where the only thing they've done is cleared the land and laid cement.)

3. Cover hard drive with napalm.

4. Light on fire.

5. Shoot roman candle at fire.

Much more fun.
Reply to this comment
by rpen25 March 29, 2009 5:25 AM PDT
Better yet, you can melt it in thermite.

1. Go to a machine shop and get some aluminum powder by sweeping the floor or the going through the shop vac.

2. Get iron oxide (rust), you can find it in paint stores (they usually sell it in powered form so people can mix it in paint as a pigment).

3. Mix 8 grams of iron oxide to 3 grams of aluminum powder. Mix thoroughly. Combine the mixture with Play-Doh or other similar material and knead thoroughly(4 parts thermite to 1 part Play-Doh or clay to make moldable). Thermite requires a high heat source to ignite, so dust off the old blasting caps or Det-Cord and have fun melting your hard drive!
by angry jubu March 27, 2009 4:33 AM PDT
This entire article is purely ridiculous. Firstly, if you MUST physically destroy a hard drive - a hammer will suffice.

Secondly - Overwriting using one of the many readily-available utilities, such as DBan, will suffice for nearly everyone. How likely is it that an identity thief will purchase your system on eBay, or Craigslist, or swipe it from the school to which you've donated it, or whatever, and spend hours reconstructing your data on the off-chance that he might be able to salvage a credit card number? If your privacy is so critical that you cannot take that chance, then you work for the government and already have access to the best prophylactic security measures in the industry. Otherwise - get over yourself.
Reply to this comment
by jaycustom March 27, 2009 6:35 AM PDT
HAHA! Is this the movies??!! Are there foreign enemies after you and your data?They won't stop until they get that HDD and your dead or what? Grab a sledge,if you don't have one use a regular hammer and chisel to put small shrp dents into it, either pinching the platters or smashing them. BETTER YET....SEND IT TO THE MYTH BUSTERS LOLOLOL!!!!
Reply to this comment
by sting7k March 27, 2009 7:14 AM PDT
I think a big hammer will normally be fine. But I've also been told just opening it up destroys it. The drive should be totally sealed and air tight. The data written is so small that dust getting on the platters destroys it, it's like huge boulders crashing into the platters.

To open it up all you need is one of those ratchet heads that conforms to any screw, they sell them every where. A hammer will take of it.
Reply to this comment
by The_happy_switcher March 27, 2009 10:23 AM PDT
There's a simpler and cheaper method: Drill a hole through it.
Reply to this comment
by john55440 March 28, 2009 6:17 AM PDT
I recently recycled many years of my computers, but removed the hard drives before doing so.

One of these decades, I will get around to destroying and recycling the hard drives. (grin)
Reply to this comment
by JixHedgehog March 28, 2009 4:44 PM PDT
Or take it to an airport and run it through an xray scanner... worked for me
Reply to this comment
by Shaun822 March 29, 2009 2:30 PM PDT
I'm a fan of the hack and slash methods. Last HDD I demo'ed I pried open took a hammer to it for a good couple minutes. Then I put the remnants in a metal fire-proof container and took some boiling water and doused the remains in that left it overnight and the next morning properly disposed of it at a hazardous waste station in my town.
Reply to this comment
by dirty55409 March 30, 2009 12:11 AM PDT
active Killdisk.... and then sell that old HDD on ebay! Don't be paranoid... nobody wants to spy on you.
Reply to this comment
by GoatCheck March 30, 2009 12:48 AM PDT
Soon after reading the Article title, a 3 step process came to me:

Buy gunpowder: Available to any U.S. citizen at a sporting goods / guns supply store.

Stick hard drive in bucket of gunpowder

Light Gunpowder.


Sure, you may blow off a few limbs and possibly blind yourself, but you can rest assured that you're Identity and personal information is safe (note: you may be resting 6 feet under in a coffin, be warned).
Reply to this comment
by NewTractors1103 April 1, 2009 9:12 PM PDT
[url="http://www.youtractor.com/index.php?page=videos&section=view&vid_id=102160"]Fendt Tractor[/url]
Reply to this comment
by NewTractors1103 April 1, 2009 9:13 PM PDT
[url=http://www.youtractor.com/index.php?page=videos&section=view&vid_id=102160]Fendt Tractor[/url]
Reply to this comment
(32 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement
Click Here

The yogurt makers of tech: Gadgets to avoid

Don't buy these one-trick ponies--unless you like gizmos that gather dust.

Google wants to unclog Net's DNS plumbing

The Net giant, ever eager for a faster Internet, debuts its Google Public DNS service. With it, Google could become even more central to the Net.

advertisement

About Workers' Edge

Dennis O'Reilly has covered PCs and other technologies in print and online since 1985. Along with more than a decade as editor for Ziff-Davis's Computer Select, Dennis edited PC World's award-winning Here's How section for more than seven years. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Workers' Edge topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right