• On The Insider: Judge Bans Real Housewives Sex Tape
November 1, 2007 10:06 AM PDT

Why Novell is like Napster-era Metallica

by Dave Rosenberg

Remember back when Metallica isolated the majority of their fan base with their over-the-top stance against Napster (for the moment let's leave the stupidity of the music business and the fact that it only has itself to blame for people pirating songs out of this) and what it did to the band and the fans that supported them for all those years? That's how I am starting to think of Novell.

Metallica went from being loved by millions to being whiny about Napster, taking the focus of the band off the music and onto the ugly business of the music industry. Ultimately, instead of proving a point, the argument took on a sheen of greed. This made people not like the band.

Drawing a parallel to Novell, the company went from being a player in the Linux market, to an open source pariah as the focus changed from the software to their pact with Microsoft. Add to that the fact that Novell handled the situation rather poorly (with more obnoxious details filtering out all the time) and you find a company that lost its way. The big question if Novell can turn the ship all the way.

When we look at the market dynamics facing Novell it's fairly obvious why Novell did the deal with Microsoft:
  • Red Hat has a dominant position for Linux servers with Ubuntu taking the desktop
  • NetWare is pretty much dead
  • Chronic management changes drained the corporate brain trust
  • Microsoft needed to make a deal with a Linux vendor and Novell was desperate while Red Hat is not.

Onto the crux of the problem: Metallica's music has stood the test of time, while Novell's software has not. Metallica's last album when James was finally off the booze was better than the last release of Netware. Even with the new virtualization functions of Netware (Brad makes some good points) it just doesn't matter. Novell has already missed pretty much every chance it had for a true resurgence.

Dave Rosenberg dishes up "Software, Interrupted" with nearly 15 years of technology and marketing experience that spans from Bell Labs to multiple start-up IPOs to open-source enterprise software companies. He is co-founder of MuleSource and currently serves as the general manager of Hardy Way. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure. You can contact Dave via e-mail at softwareinterrupted@gmail.com.
Recent posts from Software, Interrupted
Ramen robots invade Japanese restaurant
Firefox 3.5 and the potential of Web typography
Blizzard chooses cloud over LAN for new game
Japan continues to build robot army
Ricoh jumps from copiers to the cloud
China bans online 'gold farming'
Japan airport starts motorized tricycle patrols
Why Oracle will continue to win
Add a Comment (Log in or register)
great tech ... bad company
by scabrous1 November 1, 2007 8:43 PM PDT
Netware has gotten a bad rap ... it does what it does very very well. As does edirectory, IMHO the best directory service around. I could go on.

But ... Novell is a very bad company. They basically have no clue, really about any aspect of the industry. They are trying hard and doing some good things with SUSE ... but they really don't "get" that they need to be a fully OSS company. They really, just, don't get ... much of anything. Either they need to open source NCP, NSS, and FLAIM (ie EVERYTHING) or, they need to be bought up by some private investor. Get OUT of the publicly traded company biz. And if that happens, probably it would be the proprietary stuff split off from the OSS stuff.

<sigh> It really is too bad, because there was so much potential, but we have known that for nearly 10 years and they still have yet to make the potential into an actual biz plan.
Reply to this comment
Oh For Pete's Sake
by xenomentat November 4, 2007 3:02 PM PST
I'm sick of hearing all the whining that's going on about Novell and their Linux business. I agree that the patent thing was about as stupid as you can get, but the rest of the agreement is bearing good fruit, SLES is even certified to run on Microsoft's Virtual Server these days.

This means nothing to wooly-jumpered geeks still living with their parents and trying out the latest fads in the distro world, but having things work together well in windows/linux land is damned important to a lot of us.

Look, I have to live in a world where there's competition, and so do all of you commenters and pundits. You can carp and harp about how Novell should get out of the business and just die once and for all, but who really cares what you think?

Go Novell, don't listen to the nay-sayers, keep on making SUSE better and more friendly to subscribe and use, and don't let these bastards grind you down.

XM
Reply to this comment
advertisement
Click Here

Making sense of Windows 7 upgrades

faq The basics and the fine print on Microsoft's options for those eyeing the next operating system from Redmond.
• Full Windows 7 coverage

Road Trip 2009: Big Sky Country

CNET News reporter Daniel Terdiman takes his car full of gadgets to the Rockies and the Great Plains in search of tech, science, nature, and more.
• America's Fortress: Cheyenne Mountain

About Software, Interrupted

In "Software, Interrupted," Dave Rosenberg discusses disruption in the software market, as well as the products and services that keep business technology norms in perpetual flux.

With nearly 15 years of technology and marketing experience spanning from Bell Labs to multiple start-up IPOs, Dave co-founded open-source software company MuleSource and now serves as general manager of Hardy Way. He also happens to be a U.S. patent holder and a workaholic. Technology is his best friend and mortal enemy.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Software, Interrupted topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right