• On GameFAQs: Is it OK to lay my Wii down on its side?
The Cheapskate
 DEALS LEFT
July 13, 2009 7:29 AM PDT

Get a Magnavox Blu-ray player for $98

by Rick Broida
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 53 comments

Update: Just came from the Wal-Mart store in Commerce Township, Mich. Not only was the Magnavox priced at $168, but the sales guys had never seen a Blu-ray player for $98. Could be this is a regional thing, or it could just be bad reporting (on my part and others'). Were you able to find this deal? In any case, my apologies if you went to Wal-Mart and came up empty.

The good news: You can finally buy a new, non-refurbished Blu-ray player for under $100--no rebates required.

The bad news: You have to go to Wal-Mart to get it. And not Walmart.com, either, for now this deal is in-store only. (I'd phone first; this story first broke on Friday, so I wouldn't be surprised if many stores were sold out.)

Another Blu-ray player shatters the $100 barrier.

(Credit: Magnavox)

This isn't the first time a Blu-ray player has dipped below the magical $100 mark: Sears had a refurbished Magnavox for $99.99 last month, and shortly thereafter Meijer had a new Curtis Mathes model for the same price. Both are long gone.

The Wal-Mart player is the Magnavox NB530MGX, a no-frills, no-BD Live model. Of course, I suspect most buyers upgrade to Blu-ray for the better picture and sound, not for mostly fluff extras. I honestly couldn't care less about Profile 2.0 and all that.

However, I know from previous posts that many readers dislike Wal-Mart, so this begs the question: Is a $98 Blu-ray player enough to draw you into the store?

If not, why? Are Blu-ray movies still too expensive? Are you satisfied with your current DVD player? Or are you streaming/downloading most of your movies nowadays, and therefore don't need a player at all?

If you do happen to visit a Wal-Mart today, hit the comments and let your fellow Cheapskaters know which stores have or don't have the player in stock.

Rick Broida, a technology writer for nearly 20 years, is the author of more than a dozen books. In addition to writing CNET's The Cheapskate blog, he oversees BNET's Business Hacks. Rick is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CBS Interactive. Disclosure. Deals found on The Cheapskate are subject to availability, expiration, and other terms determined by sellers. Follow Rick on Twitter at cheapskateblog.
Recent posts from The Cheapskate
Get a 25-inch 1080p monitor for $149.99 shipped
Get a Dell Mini 10v netbook for $229 shipped
iPhone app rounds up free Redbox rental codes
Three pre-Black Friday deals you shouldn't miss
Get an 80GB Zune for $129.99 shipped
Get a 10-inch Netbook for $199
Five Black Friday deals you shouldn't miss
Get a 10-inch Lenovo Netbook for $209 shipped
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 2 pages (53 Comments)
by ywkhgqo July 13, 2009 7:53 AM PDT
Rick, this deal is ridiculous:
http://www.americantv.com/itemDetail.do?itemCd=042500315&linkBack=L2l0ZW1MaXN0LmRvP2NhdENkPTUwNDE=

$50 blu ray player.
Reply to this comment
by olatte July 14, 2009 11:04 AM PDT
too bad the movies only look as good as the TV you are watching them on. Hidden cost of a bluray player is the 1080p TV you have to have to watch it. And most people, if they spend that kind of money on a TV are willing to buy a much better bluray player for better playback.
by ScrambledD July 13, 2009 8:00 AM PDT
Already unavailable, I'm afraid.
Reply to this comment
by QueSeraSera July 13, 2009 8:04 AM PDT
Any format on a disc, including Blu-ray, is doomed. Don't waste your money.
The net is the future for digital contents because you can store and transfer to any player.
Most people are aware that tapes, disc, ...etc. are no longer necessary.
Reply to this comment
by ancl87 July 13, 2009 8:18 AM PDT
The net is only the future if bandwidth caps are outlawed. I still buy CDs and will continue to do so until a new lossless format is put on the market.
by ywkhgqo July 13, 2009 8:22 AM PDT
I'm so tired of hearing this. As of right now, bandwidth limits and possible bandwidth caps make 1080p content over the internet at least 5-10 years off.
by bionicjim July 13, 2009 11:47 AM PDT
Digital Downloads are still dependent on ISP. I have FIOS internet at home and, though I pay $40/mo for it, they cap dload speeds unless I pay twice that amount. I purchased a game, GRID, for the PC yesterday at 2PM and when I went to bed, it was still not done downloading (this ships on a single DVD). When purchasing HD movies on my Xbox 360, I have to do it the night before, because it usually takes them about 2 hours before they are "ready to start" meaning they have buffered enough that you won't catch-up. I can play SD versions of movies fairly quickly, it's the HD ones that take forever.
by Shaun822 July 13, 2009 1:57 PM PDT
I just feel like piling on to what others have said. Lets assume the average BRD for games and movies is 15 ish GB, the standard DVD maxes out so thats like 8.5 last I checked, a normal web surfer uses between 5 and 10 a month, and MMO's can eat up around the same amount with steady play. (all of this assumes digital distribution) You buy 2 PS3 , 2 360 , 3 or 4 downloaded HD movies, 3 or 4 standard def movies and you are now at between 140 and 150 of your bandwidth cap of 250 if you are with comcast, I don't know what Fios and ATT and WB set their caps at. That doesn't even begin to discuss the issues of download speeds for files that large. ISPs are going to be the reason Blu Ray succeeds or fails if they actually upgrade the infrastructure and make digital distribution available on a wide scale.
by mderby05 July 14, 2009 4:26 AM PDT
... hypothetically, if someone has a 50 title true-HD movie collection, that is one and a quarter terabytes of info. Bandwidth caps aside, that is a bummer for someone who has to go get an external hdd storage device to store, especially if it goes belly up down the road. Physical media is here to stay, unless we start selling flash drives with the movies preloaded, and a typical 32 gb flash drive is still upwords of $50 usd.
by TheGoBetween July 13, 2009 8:15 AM PDT
Two things turn me off to Blu-Ray:

1. Price. Of both the player and discs. It doesn't help that I'm having problems with a Magnavox LCD right now, so the prospect of a bargain basement Blu-Ray player from said company doesn't exactly thrill me.

2. I'm not a huge videophile, much like I imagine the large majority of the home movie audience is. For me the difference in quality between proper aspect ratio DVD and the (optimized) Blu-Ray in-store sample is minuscule compared to the quality gulf between DVD and VHS. I personally don't see enough of a benefit to upgrade like I did previously.
Reply to this comment
by chrkeller July 14, 2009 6:40 AM PDT
The problem is in-store blu-ray setups are on HDTVs that are not calibrated. On a nice HDTV blu-ray is a significant improvement, having said that the key is "on a nice HDTV." None of this Vizio, Sharp, Magnavox Proscan BS. I am talking about Panasonic, Pioneer and Samsung top shelf plasma sets. That is the real problem, to get the most of blu-ray one needs a nice HDTV, and most people are not videophiles such as yourself. The difference is there, it just costs a lot and quite honestly takes a good amount of knowledge to properly calibrate and use the right settings. VHS to DVD was a jump without having to buy a new TV, the same cannot be said about blu-ray. Personally I love my home theater, but realize most aren't going to drop 5k like I did. But for the record the difference is there. The picture quality is leaps better and so is the audio (assuming you have the right equipment.)
by Nychocolips July 13, 2009 8:44 AM PDT
I bit the bullet on a Samsung BDP-1500 recommended by Rick some months ago (still happy with it). I also managed to clean up on some Blu-Rays on out of business sales. After that, I am cautiously buying DVDs based on sales and prices that survive the scrutiny of a calculator.

I am reluctant to buy anything at Wal-Mart. A little effort has helped me avoid them for some time now. I am also not looking to by DVDs that don't have firmware upgrade paths. This is not because of the Blu-Ray LIve feature. This is because firmware updates can resolve incompatibility issues with DVDs. Sometime a Blu-Ray is released that just won't play right with your player. If this Magnavox can do DVD or Flash-Drive updates, then it's worth consideration (minus the Walmart).

My opinon.

Cheers
Reply to this comment
by wusupjohn July 13, 2009 11:19 AM PDT
It's available at my walmart. I just wish I wouldn't have picked it up when it was still $128.
Reply to this comment
by rickbroida July 13, 2009 11:29 AM PDT
And where is your Walmart? Crucial bit of info, there... :)
by wusupjohn July 14, 2009 9:31 AM PDT
Ames, Iowa
by ewelch July 13, 2009 1:06 PM PDT
The problem with really cheap Blu-ray players at this point is the lack of features, and upgradability. Spend an extra $100 or so and you'll get a player that works for years.

Everybody whines about the magic $99 price like the good old days of DVD. Unfortunately, because of inflation, the logic is off. It's more like $199 is equivalent of what you paid back then.

Prices for discs are coming down, plus you can get all the Blu-ray discs you wan through Netflix for bit of a fee.

As for the claim that Blu-ray and other optical media are defunct? Only that poster's thinking is defunct. Have you actually watched a movie downloaded from NetFlix on a TiVO HD? Not only is the proportions distorted, during large parts of the day the bandwidth of most people's ISPs is so compromised that they end up having the single dumbed down to i480 or worse.
Reply to this comment
by Weeji July 14, 2009 8:18 AM PDT
I second this. I started up an HD movie on Netflix, and Netflix "readjusted the quality to prevent further interruptions" about 3 or 4 times after that, dropping it definitely below 480 (probably ended up around 360 or so). Also, even though my bandwidth is capped at 250GB per month with Comcast, I've heard that nearly every other ISP caps much much lower.
by biggben July 13, 2009 1:22 PM PDT
Here in Baltimore, it is $98. I noticed it over the weekend at Walmart.
Reply to this comment
by macksumum July 13, 2009 2:06 PM PDT
walmart has mastered the art of fooling people into coming into their stores,they just sell something cheap in a small number of their stores and when that information gets out people will go out of their way to get in on the sale by going to their local walmart only to find out that most walmarts don't even offer the sale but if you are already there then why not just buy something.the one thing a lot of people fail to understand is that most people don't even care about high definition,sounds crazy but it's true.blu ray,HD download,HD online streaming,no matter how good or bad it looks most people don't even care.just walk into a bestbuy on a busy day and watch the number of people who are really paying that much attention to the blu ray movies playing on display.most people would just look and then walk away without even looking back.
Reply to this comment
by Pavliga July 13, 2009 2:52 PM PDT
I have to admit, I can't really tell the difference between most live-action Blu-ray movies on my PS3 and an upscaled DVD. Both display about the same on my 1080p Toshiba LCD. Animation is another story, though. Animation is just amazing in Blu-ray. The sharp lines and crystal clear text look gorgeous.
by blusky08 July 13, 2009 11:20 PM PDT
l can distinguish a slight difference IF the transfer has been done properly. But (IMO)
Blu-ray is a lot of hype designed by a consortium for gaining yet more royalties, control and repurchasing of media.
by Pavliga July 13, 2009 2:41 PM PDT
Haven't checked my local, Pinole, CA, Wal-Mart yet. But what's up with all the hate for that chain? Folks I know are grateful to finally have an affordable retailer in the area.

They don't have a lot of high-end stuff, but they've consistently got the best prices on the low-end and mid-range items. We in the unwashed masses mostly buy that stuff anyway.

Wal-Mart may not have the best pay and benefits in the world, but what retailer is better? The local "mom and pop" shops everyone romanticizes so much have lower pay and no benefits for their employees, and offer no career path. You could work at Ma & Pa's General Store for 20 years, but if you're not Ma and you're not Pa, and you're not one of their kids, exactly what future do you have there?

Wal-Mart has great prices and gives workers better opportunities than they'd have otherwise. Small business owners may suffer when a Wal-Mart comes to town, but many more people (workers and consumers) benefit substantially.
Reply to this comment
by fmanus July 13, 2009 2:58 PM PDT
Went to WalMart on Ramsey St in Fayetteville NC and they had plenty.
Reply to this comment
by genebean66 July 13, 2009 3:35 PM PDT
I got back from El Cajon, CA Wal-Mart They have plenty in stock! I noticed it had the same model I bought before at Father's day sale NB500MGX They do not have Magnavox NB530MGX That supposed to be on sale! Just Magnavox NB500MGX! The Model maybe Cheaper but I don't care about the fancy shmancy features! I rather pop the disc in player and watch movies Thats all!
Reply to this comment
by vonscoot81 July 13, 2009 4:02 PM PDT
Not all stores will be getting the $98 model. Only stores that are "traited" for competition with Best Buy will receive the additional quantities and the price drop. Basically, if there isn't a Best Buy near your Walmart, you likely won't see this player/price in the store.
Reply to this comment
by rickbroida July 13, 2009 4:03 PM PDT
Ahhhh...that would explain. The nearest Best Buy to my Walmart is probably 7-8 miles away.
by 1kingsfan July 13, 2009 4:43 PM PDT
I already have a PS3 and a Samsung stand alone that I won in a contest at work. Honestly the PS3 blows the samsung out of the water. The speeds on some of the blu-ray discs are ridiculously slow to upload. In fact, it can take up to 2 minutes on my samsung to load a movie. My PS3? Instantly. To be fair and stay on topic though, everyone I talk to talks about price. I haven't heard one person say "meh, not worth it. looks like enhanced dvd" what I DO hear is "too expensive. . .$30 movies? are u kidding me?" My collection of blu-ray is small simply because I REFUSE to pay full retail - I wait til they go on sale or purchase online to save money.
Reply to this comment
by Maruuk July 13, 2009 4:47 PM PDT
What's all this bushwa about 1080p downloads being 10 years away??? I download 1080p movies all the time from Directv VOD. I've only got about 2.5Mz download speed max but you just start it in the morning and you got it by viewing time that night. No mailing, no driving twice to Blockbuster, no fuss no muss, no Blu-Ray player!
Reply to this comment
by ywkhgqo July 13, 2009 6:20 PM PDT
see its the downloading all day part buddy. What if you decide you don't want to watch the movie you're starting to download. We're not talking about if its possible to download 1080p stuff we're talking about if its actually feasible.
Waiting a day for something to download isn't a feasible alternative to a disk.
by DavidSDawson July 13, 2009 6:05 PM PDT
I saw these Blu-Ray players at that price at the WalMart's in North County San Diego about two weeks ago.
Reply to this comment
by JAH_RDH2009 July 13, 2009 6:35 PM PDT
I'm in Humble Texas and my Wal-mart has a full shipment of the players. I bought one today and it played the Dark Knight flawlessly and the load speed is only seconds longer than a DVD. I am thoroughly impressed with the player. Will update with info about the longevity...
Reply to this comment
by ryan2485 July 13, 2009 6:58 PM PDT
I saw a few at the Walmart in Eagan, MN today. I'm not too sure on the quality of the Magnavox Blu-Ray players. It's hard to beat the price though. I'm sure other brands will be soon to follow suit.
Reply to this comment
by jumpkutz July 13, 2009 7:35 PM PDT
Not in my Walmart on the way home today in Louisville, KY.
Reply to this comment
by jumpkutz July 13, 2009 7:38 PM PDT
Didn't find any in my east Louisville, KY Walmart on the way home from work this evening. We do have a Best Buy in the area.
Reply to this comment
Showing 1 of 2 pages (53 Comments)
advertisement

The browser battles go on and on

roundup From Firefox to IE and from Chrome to Opera and Safari, there's no sitting still for browser makers looking to keep their products fresh and competitive.

3G wireless still holds promise

The next generation of 4G wireless may get all the headlines, but advanced 3G technology will likely dominate services for the next few years.

advertisement

About The Cheapskate

The best things in tech are cheap. "The Cheapskate" scours the Web for great deals on PCs, phones, gadgets, and all the other tech stuff that makes life worth living. Send your own cheapskate tips to thecheapskate@gmail.com. Rick is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure. Deals found on The Cheapskate are subject to availability, expiration, and other terms determined by sellers.

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Cheapskate topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right