• On GameSpot: So-called 'Halo killer' gets 23 to life
December 12, 2008 4:00 AM PST

SETI's large-scale telescope scans the skies

by Daniel Terdiman
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 14 comments
SETI

In a tiny California town town within sight of Mount Shasta and Mount Lassen is the Hat Creek Radio Observatory, home to the Allen Telescope Array--the only large-scale telescope fully at the disposal of the SETI project.
Click on the image for a related photo gallery.

(Credit: Daniel Terdiman/CNET News)

HAT CREEK, CALIF.--From the perspective of an extraterrestrial, I wonder if there would be much difference between a human and a deer.

You might think that's an odd question, but on Wednesday, as I stood in an open plain here, at around 5,000 feet, with Mount Shasta visible far off to the north, a stunning blue sky, I watched a deer poking around at the base of what on its own would be an odd piece of astronomy equipment.

In fact, though, the 20-foot-diameter antenna the deer was investigating was just one of 42 identical units that make up the Allen Telescope Array, currently the world's first large-scale telescope meant for the full-time use of the Search for Extra-Terrestrial Intelligence (SETI) project.

Click for gallery

The ATA, as it's called, opened in late 2007 with these first 42 antennas. Designed to work in pairs, the antennas are intended to work together to mimic the stellar investigatory capacity of far larger single dishes. And the ATA is hardly finished. In fact, it is planned to eventually be made up of 350 of these antennas.

And while the famous Arecibo uber-antenna in Puerto Rico, with its 73,000 square meter size, has seven times the collecting area of the full ATA, the telescope here--the array in its entirety is a telescope--will be able to look at 2,500 times as much sky as Aricebo.

For my visit, resident astronomer Rick Forster took me around, explaining the history of the facility, as well as how it is used today.

Originally, the Hat Creek Radio Observatory--the official name of this facility--was a joint effort by UC Berkeley, the University of Illinois at Urbana, and the University of Maryland, called BIMA. It had ten 20-foot-diameter antennas that operated in concert to create a millimeter-wave radio interferometer.

A deer investigates the ground around one of the 42 antennas in the Allen Telescope Array.

(Credit: Daniel Terdiman/CNET News)

But eventually, that project moved on, and now, Hat Creek is the home to the ATA, and for the same reason that BIMA was here: it is one of the few places in North America that provides astronomers hoping to scan the skies with little-to-no terrestrial radio interference.

That's because the facility is bounded by the Cascades on one side and a fault scarp to the east.

Of course, for the folks who live here, that means no cell phone service, and they're pretty much out of luck for listening to the radio or watching broadcast TV.

But since what these scientists want is to do serious astronomy, it's fair to say that's a trade they're willing to make.

To be sure, however, their hope for radio silence is dashed by the ever-present broadcast satellites that scream overhead. And those mean that there are a series of frequencies that simply aren't available for scanning.

The Allen Telescope Array has been funded so far mainly by Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen, and it's hoped he will be the benefactor for the future, as well.

Forster said that the original 42 antennas cost around $25 million to put up, and that while no additional funding has yet been acquired, they are in negotiations for the money to expand the array to about 128 antennas.

You may be familiar with other large-scale radio observatories. Perhaps the most famous is the Very Large Array, in New Mexico, which comprises 27 giant dishes.

Like ATA, SETI makes use of the Very Large Array. But the chief difference is that the SETI folks only get to use VLA once in a while. At ATA, however, they are always on. And that means, the SETI folks think, that their goal of tracking down E.T. is now getting a serious jump start.

The full array of 350 antennas, as imagined by Isaac Gary. The ATA needs more funding in order to reach the goal of 350 antennas, and it is likely to be several years before reaching that goal.

(Credit: Isaac Gary)

Forster explained that at the full 350 antenna capacity, the SETI project will have the ability to "see" transmissions from something as large as Aricebo from as much as 1,000 light years away, meaning that if there are aliens within that distance and they have their own SETI projects going on that are broadcasting signals like we are, there's a much better chance we'll meet up eventually, now that a tool like the ATA is available.

Of course, the array here is also available simultaneously for other astronomy, but thanks to Allen's interest in finding extraterrestrials, SETI is the bread-winner here.

"Without SETI, it would never have happened," Forster said of the ATA's creation. "Since BIMA left, this luckily came along. So, yeah, it's hugely important for the existence of the observatory.

When the funding comes in for more antennas, Forster explained, the facility has a team of two techs that can put them together at a rate of about two a week. They cost about $150,000 each, a number that is cheap in the business. And they're provided by a guy in Idaho Falls, Idaho, who specializes in making large-scale satellite dishes.

Radio waves that come screaming in from outer space are captured by a receiver called an ultra-wide band log periodic feed. Forster said that electrons in the radio waves bounce off the main reflector, then bounce again off the sub-reflector and arrive at the focus of the receiver, a spot about 80 percent or so along its jagged length.

The receiver of one of the antennas in the Allen Telescope Array. Electrons in radio waves from outer space bounce off the antennas' main reflector, then again on their sub-reflector, before being captured on the focus of the receiver.

(Credit: Daniel Terdiman/CNET News)

Then, through a multi-step process, those radio waves are transmitted to the scientists' computers nearby for analysis.

Ultimately, said Forster, the entire array is about doing exactly this job.

"The whole telescope is just to get that reflective surface...pointing in the right direction."

And while many large-scale telescopes require complexities for analyzing and collecting data, the ATA is quite simple, and thus, elegant, Forster said.

Eventually, the full 350-antenna array will cover about 90 acres, and be much denser than it is today, at 42 antennas.

Until then, the search for E.T. will have to make do with what is available here. But once Allen, or other benefactors come through with the money, we may just discover once and for all that we are not alone.

Daniel Terdiman is a staff writer at CNET News covering games, Net culture, and everything in between. E-mail Daniel.
Recent posts from Geek Gestalt
Nintendo primed for holiday console dominance
A wild ride on NASA's massive flight simulator
Millions using social media on Xbox Live
Alternate-reality games flourish at the grassroots
IBM: Computing rivaling human brain may be ready by 2019
Video game sales fall off a ledge in October
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 said to break sales records
Report: Microsoft's Project Natal pricing details
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (14 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by hassan_bin_sober December 12, 2008 7:10 AM PST
The aliens are already here! ...Just look at Wall Street.
Reply to this comment
by Alphaman63 December 12, 2008 7:23 AM PST
A couple things. First, the second photo in the gallery is of a yacht? While it looks like it has an antenna, I don't think it really is one from the ATA...

Second, the last photo is quite a "Where's Waldo?" :) I found two stakes, but had to zoom in on the image to find the third!

Were they in a scheduled downtime so you could bring your digital camera on-site, or did you have to use film?

As always, good article, Dan. Thanks for the insight!
Reply to this comment
by pbackus December 12, 2008 12:15 PM PST
The second photo in the gallery is indeed an ATA antenna. It shows the main 6.1 meter reflector and the back of the subreflector.

We try to schedule engineering time or maintenance during visits by the media.

Peter Backus
SETI Institute
by sriharsha2851988 December 12, 2008 10:13 AM PST
i am very happy to see such a great news about
SETI'S telescope
Reply to this comment
by Wick_1973 December 12, 2008 11:35 AM PST
I doubt that Rick Forster said "electrons in the radio waves bounce off the main reflector." There are no electrons in radio waves - they're comprised of photons. Said photons striking a surface may knock electrons off to be collected but there are none in the original waves.
Reply to this comment
by pbackus December 12, 2008 12:24 PM PST
The VLA is not used by the SETI Institute, even occasionally. In its history, the VLA was used for one brief SETI project: a 16 hour search for evidence of the famous "Wow Signal".

Peter Backus
SETI Institute
Reply to this comment
by Kevinkreb December 15, 2008 1:11 AM PST
Science really opened our eyes by developing new things.
Reply to this comment
by setipioneer December 16, 2008 8:13 AM PST
Nice pictures--which only underscore that this project is all potential and not a viable scientific tool. Originally conceived 15 years ago by Frank Drake, this array was intended to be very cheap--under $10Million--and a dedicated SETI telescope. Instead is has bloated into a $30M plus project --so far--has not demonstrated any new science or spinoff-technology, and been compromised by claims that astronomical research makes for intended use. If and when it does get 'funding' it will already be OBU (obscelete before use). At a time when people are on the verge of a major depression in the homeland, do we have to be deluded that we are still 'dreaming' for other worlds--using flashlights rather than searchlights (to use an analogy)? If there was a viable array, the answer would be yes. As it stands, this project is an anachromism; wa-a-y overpriced, and in bad taste in bad times.
Reply to this comment
by maniac42 December 26, 2008 5:29 PM PST
There were naysayers like you who protested the moon shots in the 1960s and 1970s, which eventually led to a sharp curtailment of funding and the near-death of the U.S. space program. Yet, the poor, indigent, lazy and inebriated are still with us, despite hundreds of billions of dollars poured into programs such as The Great Society. I think the money would have been better spent on the space program -- at least we'd have the technology spinoffs to show for it and they would have benefited mankind immensely compared to the monies that were peed away to "fight poverty".
by prometheon123 January 4, 2009 6:02 AM PST
I completely agree with seitpioneer. SETI is a complete waste of money. The project itself is based on Drake's equation of N=N*fp ne fl fi fc fL None of the terms in this sophisticated looking equation can be known. Since none of these expressions can be known the equation itself is meaningless. SETI is a religion and a study without a subject. The money spent on SETI could have provided clean drinking water in any number of countries.
by setipioneer December 29, 2008 8:58 AM PST
Well, nice try, but I see no reason to insult me: especially since your facts and comparisons are so --way-- off the mark. The issue isn't 'seti'. The issue is' doing seti'. This clouded eyepiece of an array isn't doing it; has cost tens of millions of dollars to date, and has no path to completion.

I don't believe money should be spent on useless social panacea. OTOH, wasting money on something that doesn't work (accept it: it does NOt work as a viable SETI telescope )--and to use your analogy --has had NO spinoffs, is a huge boondoggle. Appreciate your provision of actual facts (you won't be able to) to show me this educated opinion is not correct.

But keep the personal dissing out of it. Thanks.
Reply to this comment
by oldtroll57 January 3, 2009 3:24 PM PST
There are some out there who feel that we should not spend a single cent, to find out what we are, or why we are here.
I for one do not think, that in this vast universe, we are all there is. Therefor I support the effort to see if there is anything, or anyone else out there, weather it is privately or government funded. Myself I would like to know
Reply to this comment
by sanenazok January 4, 2009 8:18 AM PST
I don't think anyone objects to privately funded searches for aliens or bigfoot or the bogeyman. People are free to spending their own money on whatever legal things they want. In theory I don't want government funds spent on this, but in reality I prefer them spending money on SETI than the usual waste that goes on at universities.
by setipioneer January 9, 2009 7:31 AM PST
Spending money on SETI is fine. This array, on the otherhand, is NOT a functional research instrument and is NOT being used to do SETI. It probably never will. The point is that this particular project has not, and will not lived up to its claims, and has been a huge financial boondoggle. Please read my comments: there is nothing that I said that in any way could be construed as representing that SETI is a waste of time. This PROJECT is a waste of MONEY. See the difference:-)?
Reply to this comment
(14 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

S.F. hacker space: Heaven for the DIY set?

The Noisebridge hacker space offers sewing and Mandarin classes, soldering workshops, Internet-controlled front door access, and a server room with no door.
• Photos: Circuits, code, community

The browser battles go on and on

roundup From Firefox to IE and from Chrome to Opera and Safari, there's no sitting still for browser makers looking to keep their products fresh and competitive.

About Geek Gestalt

Daniel Terdiman, uniquely positioned to take you into the middle of another side of technology, chronicles his explorations of the "fun beat," from cultural phenomena such as Burning Man to cutting-edge aircraft to game conventions.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Geek Gestalt topics

advertisement
advertisement
Click Here

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right