• On CHOW: Sexy vampire party
July 24, 2008 10:14 AM PDT

Mossberg pans MobileMe amid service outages

by Tom Krazit

Apple's MobileMe cloud service is off to a rocky start, alienating even Walt Mossberg.

(Credit: Susan Dove/CNET News)

As if Apple wasn't having enough problems with its launch of MobileMe, its usually reliable friend Walt Mossberg has recommended that people stay far away from the service.

Mossberg's review on All Things Digital doesn't even take into account the service outages that have many former .Mac users up in arms over their inability to access e-mail. In his view, "it's a great idea, but, as of now, MobileMe has too many flaws to keep its promises."

MobileMe does more than just give you e-mail: it's designed to let you access your contacts, calendars, and bookmarks from any computer connected to the Internet. One flaw that bothered Mossberg was the fact that while changes made to one of those applications on an iPhone sync instantly, changes made on the Dell PCs and Macs he used in his testing synced in 15-minute intervals. Apple has acknowledged that issue and says it's working on a fix.

But the main issue seems to be that MobileMe is sluggish and buggy, according to Mossberg. Web pages load very slowly, synchronization with Microsoft's Outlook e-mail software seems problematic, and manual refreshes were required to make changes appear inside calendar appointment.

The MobileMe mail problems don't seem to have been fixed, although Apple is still claiming that only 1 percent of all MobileMe users are affected. While that's indeed a pressing problem, Mossberg's experience is enough to make you wonder if Apple's a bit over its head trying to run a cloud computing service.

As an aside, an informal poll of the CNET staff could not turn up the last Apple product that Mossberg flat-out panned. The closest we came was the original Motorola Rokr phone, which to be fair, nobody liked.

Tom Krazit writes about the ever-expanding world of Internet search, including Google, Yahoo, online advertising, and portals, as well as the evolution of mobile computing. He has written about traditional PC companies, chip manufacturers, and mobile computers, spending the last three years covering Apple. E-mail Tom.
Recent posts from Apple
Apple said to be working on 'world-mode' iPhone
Smartphone market unfazed by recession
Steve Jobs, Fortune's CEO of the decade
Apple, RIM grab market share from Nokia
Parallels 5 boasts huge speed improvement
Apple reaches 100,000 apps, 2 billion downloads
Hacker breaks into jailbroken iPhones, asks for $7
China Unicom: 5,000 iPhones sold in first weekend
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 2 pages (34 Comments)
by joetesta70 July 24, 2008 10:38 AM PDT
It's something when Apple's biggest shill even panns the product. MobileMe is stupid name too.
Reply to this comment
by Thomas, David July 24, 2008 12:19 PM PDT
A. Mossberg is not a shill, he is always honest
B. No Apple fan likes bad Apple products, and are just as vocal as those (such as yourself) who have no reason to be.
by open-mind July 24, 2008 4:44 PM PDT
The fact that he panned the product indicates that he's not a shill. A shill would make excuses and spin a positive story.
by wratbatblue July 24, 2008 10:49 AM PDT
Somebody tell Mossberg to take up the cause of the 3G reception problems, too. That's something else affecting lots and lots of people, and something else that seems to be a direct Apple problem, as well.
Reply to this comment
by anilsudh July 24, 2008 11:03 AM PDT
Could very well be an AT&T problem. Besides 3G coverage where I live and work is fantastic. I rarely have to go to WiFi for anything these days.
by alexacker July 25, 2008 6:41 AM PDT
LISTEN UP EVERYONE (typing in all caps on purpose):

The 3G problem is not AT&Ts fault?it is Apple's (this coming from a fanboy). I have an AT&T 3G card for my MacBook pro and THE RECEPTION IS FAST AND FLAWLESS EVERYDAY I'VE USED IT.

There's something wrong with the 3G iPhones! My 1st gen iPhone works perfectly.
by Macanada July 24, 2008 10:50 AM PDT
Yeah, a rocky start, but for me.. even with a few bumps in the road, MobileMe is still a better product than .Mac - what I've been paying for for the last 3 years. I for one welcome the changes and so far I find everything working well for me.
Reply to this comment
by Thomas, David July 24, 2008 12:20 PM PDT
*cough*

Give me .mac back!
by anilsudh July 24, 2008 10:50 AM PDT
Apple should have kept this product in Beta and allowed users to play with it for a couple of months before announcing the cut over.

I am not a heavy user of MobileMe and other than the occasional issues, it has worked fine for me. Not had any major issues with emails, contacts, calendar and pics. Everything seems to sync up fine.
Reply to this comment
by nouser July 24, 2008 11:05 AM PDT
As much as I'd like to rip the service, it has worked well for me. I must be the lucky 1%. My calendar and contact sync just fine. My email has always worked. I've never lost an email and it seems quite speedy.

Not sure what to make of all the complaints. Guess I'm waiting for the brick to fall but so far I'm a happy camper.
Reply to this comment
by Thomas, David July 24, 2008 12:33 PM PDT
The service should not work for only some people, a partial success is a complete failure. That is the measuring stick for a service.
by AppleSuxLeo July 24, 2008 12:05 PM PDT
If more than one person was dumb enough to use it...it would have been named MobileUs.
Reply to this comment
by Thomas, David July 24, 2008 12:35 PM PDT
*rolls eyes*

Bring in the clowns
by edgedesign July 24, 2008 2:45 PM PDT
AppleSuxLeo rarely has anything intelligent to say... just do a search.

Apple certainly had problems the first few days rolling out this new service, but it seems to be working fine for many people since. I functions and synchs fine here.
by troyallen July 25, 2008 9:41 AM PDT
Spam
by jimoase July 24, 2008 1:41 PM PDT
Unfortunately Apple rolled out their Me Generation product line at the same time they rolled out a single non-functional email server. This one non-functional server services 1% of Apple's Me Generation email. We can assume the Me Generation email product as rolled out was functioning because, according to Apple, 99% of their customer have had full service for the last 6 days.

Considering that 99% of Apple's customer's are using a functioning Me Generation email product then what has been going on for the last 6 days is kind of a surprise for a company which developed the elegant backup scheme Time Capsule. Had Apple had the industry's traditional backup system or a redundant system their customer may have had email for the last 6 days.
Reply to this comment
by artistjoh July 24, 2008 2:40 PM PDT
Dot Mac was always expensive for what it was but at least it had cool features like iCards which was the main reason I subscribed. Now without warning features like iCards and HomePage were discontinued in the transition to MobileME. To add insult to injury Apple promoted MobileME as being "everything we loved about dot Mac plus more." You cannot remove large chunks of services and then claim the new service is "Everything" we loved. It is plain dishonest.

Then the service is less reliable than dot Mac. On top of that the name is so narcissistic, and childish. There are loads of unhappy dot Mac users who dislike more than just the email outages.
Reply to this comment
by edgedesign July 24, 2008 2:41 PM PDT
AppleSuxLeo rarely has anything intelligent to say... just do a search.

There were certainly some problems getting this new service up and running, but I have not experienced any problems since. It all works and synchs fine from here.
Reply to this comment
by usna84_dotmac July 24, 2008 3:08 PM PDT
As a dotMac user, the 1% seems to be hitting me more than it should. I would really hate to have to redirect my email to gmail or yahoo (or god forbid my ISP account) because Apple was a little too quick on their release.
Reply to this comment
by Thomas, David July 24, 2008 3:47 PM PDT
As much as I love Apple, and that's quite a bit, they need to be blasted over this. Not with irrational comments, but serious, focused questions. You can't measure the disappointment I, and others, have experienced after relying on a reliable product for so many years.

What happened to the .Mac servers?
Why can't us "1%ers" roll back to those servers?
Why won't you tell us what is really going on?
Why haven't you provided forwarding address, and outgoing email operation services?
What went out of scope on your disaster recovery plan?

Simple silence is doing nothing but a world of hurt to your customers, and yourselves, even if they love you afterwards. A complete disaster is understandable but the problem is you aren't even letting us know that.

If you think by not providing information, and alternatives will keep you from losing mobileMe customers, you've got it wrong, only the opposite reaction will occur. Sure we will still be Apple customers, but something was laid and won't be touched by a yard stick if this isn't handled properly.

I've said my piece.
Reply to this comment
by galleyhannon July 24, 2008 6:37 PM PDT
I read Mossberg's piece on MobileMe and thought is was really dumb. I never liked his technology reviews. It sounded to me like he was trying to do something strange with Apple Mail and syncing didn't like it. Oh, and Microsoft products weren't working too well with it. That's a shame, but BFD.

I have been using .Mac for five years and it has definitely been worth the money. MobileMe hasn't changed anything about that and it actually added several useful features. It also sounds like there are more improvements on the way, so yay for that.

The only thing that can be criticized is the fact that there are MobileMe users that have been without email service for the past week. That's downright inexcusable and something completely unexpected from Apple. Here's hoping there is a happy resolution in the near future, though the situation doesn't sound very good right now.
Reply to this comment
by sroussey July 24, 2008 9:01 PM PDT
Oh my God, I read this, and then went to check my email, and half my email is GONE!!!

:(
Reply to this comment
by jedijeff1962 July 25, 2008 4:26 AM PDT
the mobileME name is way over the top and embarrassing to use for a professional. to loose iCards is significant and a major loss. very poorly thought out i wonder if apple can try to make this thing right again?
Reply to this comment
by iPhotographer July 25, 2008 5:50 AM PDT
What is the point of MobileMe? $100 a year for 40GB of storage (I could get an external driver for far less), email and a photo gallery, the latter two you can get for free with gMail and Photobucket.
If you need ActiveSync like functions, you would have Microsoft Exchange. Otherwise, who is buying this?
Reply to this comment
by troyallen July 25, 2008 9:43 AM PDT
People who want the Apple package. If you are not interested, but bother commenting?
by Thomas, David July 25, 2008 9:52 AM PDT
Seriously, your comment was unwarranted, and quite frankly, unwanted
by FS1982! July 25, 2008 8:09 AM PDT
I'm doing the free trial on MobileMe. I haven't had very many issues. I have noticed the website does run slow especially on Windows computers (which MobileMe does advise you at startup). With the 15 minute refresh I have not experience that. Right when I put an event into my calendar on Mobile me my phone refreshes. Honestly I don't know what everyone is complaining about. Even with the 2.0 download I got it mid-day the first day it came out with no problems. I think the most applicable quote in the Mac situation "You either die or live long enough to see yourself become the villian."
Reply to this comment
by jcasteli July 25, 2008 9:19 AM PDT
I have been a loyal Apple customer for 5 years and couldn't me more disappointed than I am today with MobileMe. This application has crippled the Apple user community and is far less useful than expected. It is not fully integrated and not a replacement for any Blackberry. Calendars are not integrated with email, and you cannot send invites out via the Calendar application. It's just terrible. And two weeks into the launch and our email is still not consistently available. 1% may not be able to access email, but how many experienced smaller bugs, slow speeds, sync failure, emails missing, calendars disappearing and contacts unavailable through email for two weeks?
Reply to this comment
by troyallen July 25, 2008 9:40 AM PDT
I have no issues with mobileme. sluggish, but Everything works as advertised. I only dislike the interface. Looks ugly
Reply to this comment
by texasags July 25, 2008 10:23 AM PDT
I haven't had any trouble with MobileMe and neither have three other people I have talked to. I know many have had trouble, but that doesn't mean it's everyone.
Reply to this comment
by AppleSuxLeo July 27, 2008 2:56 AM PDT
MobileMe should have been released on April Fools Day. When Walt Goatbeard pans it...you KNOW it really is a failure.
Reply to this comment
Showing 1 of 2 pages (34 Comments)
advertisement

FAQ: Buying the right Windows 7 upgrade

Readers still have lots of questions on just which version of the software they need to buy in order to upgrade their PC. CNET News tries to offer some answers.

N.Y. lawsuit details Intel's 'largesse' toward Dell

Attorney General Andrew Cuomo's federal antitrust case filed Wednesday alleges a longstanding symbiotic relationship between Intel and Dell.

About Apple

At the start of the 21st century, there's no tech outfit more influential than Apple. CNET News' Erica Ogg and other reporters will attempt to make sense of the rumors, hype, products, and people that will shape the future of the company. But Apple's not the only game in town, as the established cell phone companies and others strike back against the iPhone. E-mail Erica at erica.ogg@cnet.com.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Apple topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right