Report: China Mobile wants a slow iPhone

China Mobile might be asking Apple to ship a version of the iPhone 3G without the 3G--and without the Wi-Fi, too.

(Credit: Apple)

China Mobile might be asking Apple for a modified version of the iPhone to ensure its customers stay within its network.

Apple and China Mobile have been flirting for some time over the prospect of bringing the iPhone to China. Now the South China Morning Post is reporting (via Cellular-News) that China Mobile wants Apple to ship an iPhone in China with the Wi-Fi and 3G chips disabled. Why take out the fast networking chips that make the iPhone shine, you may ask?

Competition. China Mobile plans to build out a 3G network based on a homegrown Chinese standard for third-generation networks that is not compatible with the widely used W-CDMA standard that is also expected to be used by China Mobile competitor China Telecom.

The thinking, according to the report, is that China Mobile doesn't want its customers buying an iPhone 3G compatible with the W-CDMA standard before it can complete its own 3G network. Otherwise, those customers may decide to unlock the iPhone and use it on China Telecom's network rather than staying tied to the China Mobile network. Unlocked iPhones are rampant in China; over 400,000 were estimated to be in use earlier in the year, and few think that number has gotten smaller.

If all Apple has to do is knock out the 3G and Wi-Fi chips it might not be too difficult to ship the modified handset, since it wouldn't be like developing something completely different. But given how closely the iPhone is associated with Apple, the move would create the potential for Chinese iPhone users stuck on a slow data network to blame the iPhone for their poor experience.

China would be a big prize for Apple, but it might not be worth the cost of shipping a crippled iPhone.

[umbrae]

Why not? Apple cripples everything else...

[bonesbautista]

Um, doesn't China have about eleventeen different illegal knockoff models floating around already?

[swrobel]

So why don't they partner with China Telecom instead...?

[eBob1]

That's exactly what I was thinking.

[Alpha225]

China Mobile has the most users and the network is more sophisticated.

[benjaminstraight]

Of course

[actuallyknown]

Since iPhones are actually made in China, wouldn't there be near-zero shipping costs?

Does anyone think Apple would ship a stripped version of their iconic iPhone that is clearly out of the mainstream of currently accepted standards.

Does this article make sense to anyone?

[Synthmeister]

This is crap. All it will do is pump up the black market for iPhones in China. Especially now that you can buy iPhones everywhere in Asia now, including Hong Kong where they are selling unlocked iPHones! I wouldn't even want an iPhone without WiFi! That's one of the major reasons it is so frickin' great!

What else are they going to do, sell iPod touches without a multi-touch screen? (Or WiFi?) Sell iPod nanos without the click wheel? Sell iMacs without Safari, iLife, Mail and AddressBook and iTunes?

This rumor makes NO sense. I'll believe it when I see it. iPhones are too easily had and the black market would just go wild.

[xxczxd]

Proposal to increase the component so that the iphone become a dual-mode handsets.

[victor_sf]

"Otherwise, those customers may decide to unlock the iPhone and use it on China Telecom's network rather than staying tied to the China Mobile network."

So what?? How lame are business people gotten these days?

[qihui369]

please lock it for the selfish operator, but not a cripple iPhone because it does nothing good for both Apple and that operator for the prospect of future growth. china is a vast market so think before making such a paramount decision