November 6, 2008 12:00 PM PST

Obama's search for a CTO

by Stephanie Condon
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 19 comments

By naming some technology executives to his transition team--especially former IAC executive Julius Genachowski--President-elect Barack Obama is signaling that he's likely to follow through with his proposal to appoint a chief technology officer to the White House.

The person in this new position--and possibly a new White House technology office staff--could be given the directive to create new levels of transparency and access to government agencies, or to guide policies that spur innovation and growth. Technology experts within the Beltway warn, however, that a CTO would have to avoid potential pitfalls such as creating new spending for ineffectual projects, running into conflict with other agencies, or simply becoming nothing more than a symbolic office.

Still, creating the position would generally be seen as a positive step.

"The fact that this is difficult is, in some ways, an example of why we might need a CTO," said Alan Davidson, head of Google's Washington office. "There is no one place for unified technology leadership in our executive branch right now."

A tech-friendly transition team
The overall composition of Obama's transition team indicates he may be serious about implementing new uses of technology in the executive branch and directing more cohesive policy making. Genachowski was an adviser to two Federal Communications Commission chairmen during the Clinton administration--Reed Hundt and Bill Kennard--and is the founder of start-up incubator LaunchBox Digital. Genachowski chaired the group that helped shape Obama's Tech and Innovation Plan, in which Obama calls for a CTO.

Genachowski is considered to be a strong contender for the CTO position.

Former IAC executive Julius Genachowski is part of Barack Obama's transition team and may be under consideration to fill the role of CTO.

(Credit: LaunchBoxDigital)

"Julius is an example of the kind of person who has both real-world technology and business experience and would be effective in Washington," Davidson said. "He's a good model of the type of person one might look for as a CTO or as another technology leader within the administration."

The transition team also includes Sonal Shah of Google.org and Donald Gips, vice president of corporate strategy and development for Level 3 Communications. Many Obama advisers come out of the Clinton administration, and Gips, among others, specifically served Vice President Al Gore. Given Gore's emphasis on the development of information technology, those advisers are well poised to integrate technology into the way the government functions and creates policy, some have said.

Gips served as Gore's chief domestic policy adviser in the late 1990s. William Daley, another member of the Obama transition team, served as secretary of commerce from 1997 to 2000 and was chairman of Gore's 2000 presidential campaign.

Obama's transition team is headed by John Podesta, the former Clinton White House chief of staff, considered in Washington to be a competent figure who is comfortable with technology issues in his own right.

The team has already shown its commitment to embracing technology by launching the site Change.gov.

"Because of the impact the Internet had in the election, we're expecting to see the incoming administration embrace a lot of those tools, and that will be important for laying the groundwork once the administration takes office," Davidson said.

Beyond this transition team, Obama may look for advice on technology policy--or for a CTO--from the cadre of technology advisers he maintained during his campaign. Obama's technology advisers, both formal and informal, included government types, academics, and people from the high tech industry.

Former FCC chairs Hundt and Kennard serve as advisers, as do Michael Nelson, the former director of Internet technology and strategy at IBM; Daniel Weitzner, an MIT computer scientist and a policy director for the World Wide Web Consortium; Craigslist Founder Craig Newmark; Google CEO Eric Schmidt; and a number of others.

Will a new cabinet position change anything?
Some inside Washington have said the Obama administration will be a vast improvement from the Bush administration, which has been criticized for neglecting technology as an issue and a tool. President Bush has not completely ignored the issue, however. As part of its cybersecurity efforts encouraged by the administration, the Homeland Security Department is conducting a complete overhaul of government networks to make them more secure. The Office of Management and Budget has also emphasized funding to keep information technology secure and up to date.

The OMB, through the Presidential E-Government Initiatives, has also served the public through sites like Grants.gov, which allows people to more easily find and apply for federal grants, and USAJobs.gov, the federal online recruitment service.

Moreover, the appointment of a CTO in an Obama administration does not ensure any improvements.

"The idea of a chief technology officer is a fine one, but I think it's more complex than that," said Ed Black, president and CEO of the Computer and Communications Industry Association. "It's not enough to make an office--the use and understanding of technology needs to permeate every agency."

Yet someone with the right credentials and reputation could make that happen, Black said.

"It's going to take a person with a liberal background, with skills across the field," he said. "Somebody close to Obama certainly helps."

Looking to industry for help
Speculation has circulated that Obama could consider a well-known executive like Amazon CEO Jeffrey Bezos or Google's Schmidt for the role of CTO; however, at least one Washington insider said it is highly unlikely Schmidt would leave his position at Google for the job.

Some have speculated Google CEO Eric Schmidt may be up for the job of CTO, but others--including Schmidt himself--say that's unlikely.

Davidson noted that Schmidt has said he has no interest in the role. Davidson did not rule out the possibility of another Washington outsider taking the job, though.

"There's a balance that will need to be struck in looking for people who have real world technology experience and can be effective in Washington," he said. "There are people in Washington who fit that role and people outside of Washington who fit that role."

Others such as James Lewis, director and senior fellow in the technology and public policy program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, cautioned against the idea.

"We've seen lots of times where people have brought in gurus from the high-tech community, and they give up after a year because they're frustrated," Lewis said. "Knowing how the government works is important."

Even so, Lewis said, implementing technology policy cannot be left to policy wonks from Washington without industry advice, Lewis said.

"Innovation's the secret sauce of the year, but we need to figure out what exactly that means," he said. "Giving the Commerce Department more money will not do anything for innovation, yet that's one of the things we hear."

Defining the CTO's mission
The executive branch will likely have an onslaught of technology policy proposals to consider, Lewis said, which could range from a national broadband commitment to the establishment of a central office for research and development funds. Some may be good, but others could be a waste of time and money.

"The transition team needs to take a really hard look at the ideas that are going to be put forward because most of them aren't going to work," Lewis said.

Those familiar with the transition process have said it will work "quickly, but not hastily." Before a CTO is chosen, Obama and his team will have to decide how to structure the White House.

The jurisdiction of a CTO could overlap with other agencies or executive positions in areas such as innovation policy, cybersecurity, or intellectual property enforcement. To avoid those overlaps, the Obama team will have to decide, for instance, whether the CTO would focus on goals like making agencies more efficient or take on a broader agenda such as dictating policy.

Innovation policy could intrude on turf covered by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, many noted, and policy covering digital copyright law might conflict with another cabinet position Obama will have to fill--the position of intellectual property enforcement coordinator, which was established by the recently-signed Prioritizing Resources and Organization for Intellectual Property Act

Foreseeing a battle in the copyright world between Hollywood and the tech industry, Black said it would be ideal for the Obama administration to include "somebody who can recognize there is significant collateral damage to other legitimate interests and industries" by some copyright positions taken by the entertainment industry.

"They don't have to be anti-Hollywood, they just have to be not blinded by an extreme position," he said. "I'd actually be very happy if we just had somebody who was very balanced and open."

President-elect Obama may also consider appointing a completely separate cybersecurity chief, as is likely to be recommended by the CSIS Commission on Cybersecurity for the 44th Presidency.

"The commission said (cybersecurity) was a national security issue, and that's kind of out of the orbit of the CTO," said Lewis, who chairs the commission. "There's some overlap, but I think the CTO's role is kind of orthogonal to the cyber mission."

Stephanie Condon is a staff writer for CNET News focused on the intersection of technology and politics. She is based in Washington, D.C. E-mail Stephanie.

Recent posts from Politics and Law
'Don't-be-evil' Google spurns no-evil software
White House appoints cybersecurity chief
U.S. cap and trade looks out of reach in 2010
FTC's new strategy: Kick 'em when they're down
Plurk holding Microsoft's feet to code-copying fire
FTC wants Intel to mend its ways
Biden to unveil $2 billion in broadband grants
FTC pursues Intel on new front: Graphics chips
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (19 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by shadowself November 6, 2008 1:17 PM PST
Someone needs to tell the administration -- and all the computer/networking/digital communications focused observers -- that technology is *NOT* limited to these areas. A CIO is *NOT* a CTO and should not be confused as being the same. A CTO that is 90+% focused on these areas would not be a good thing.
Reply to this comment
by inachu November 6, 2008 1:26 PM PST
Also hiring a CTO who does not know how to use Linux or a mouse should not be hired.
Tired of seeing lower ranks with lots of certifications and the CTO only got the job because he is a drinking buddy.
Reply to this comment
by Mr. Dee November 6, 2008 3:23 PM PST
I would recommend Bill Gates.
Reply to this comment
by November 21, 2008 8:53 AM PST
Yes; open source is very important; and states and cities facing a credit crunch should be looking to open source to save money.It also opens the door for people to learn not just open source but many subjects ect.
by Zaphod_Beeblebrox November 6, 2008 6:22 PM PST
If he's all about change here's a good idea - how about NOT hiring a CTO?
The last thing we need right now is bigger government with yet another useless yet highly paid senior position that mooches off the taxpayers.
Reply to this comment
by sarah_oneill November 6, 2008 10:12 PM PST
The new cabinet position seems like an exciting idea. To have an executive branch that understands tech may actually help net neutrality and free speech, not to mention how tech has to do with every other branch of the government! There's another interesting article <a href="http://www.atelier-us.com/internet-usage/article/technology-in-the-obama-administration">here</a>.
Reply to this comment
by walt41 November 6, 2008 11:06 PM PST
I read this as a hard wiring situation that will be delimiting because this agency can,will and must control the budget. I see this "as just another" struggle over tax payer money, which should not be used in the first place to fund capitalist advances.

If this CTO focus is placed upon improving individual computing possibilities...that alone would be a good thing to have happen over the next four years, which are the first four years and maybe the last for the CTO.
Reply to this comment
by orimta November 6, 2008 11:39 PM PST
2 good friends: Bill Gates as CIO and Warren Buffet as a treasury minister?

my comments at http://www.commentino.com/orim
Reply to this comment
by johnericanderson November 7, 2008 6:16 AM PST
He could hire me as CGO (Chief Game Officer).
Dude, I could totalize the White House for World Of Warcraft! and link the avatars to actual military units.

Watch out for that troll.
Reply to this comment
by celticbrewer November 7, 2008 12:13 PM PST
Mario, Luigi, and Joe the Plumber?
by TheDiplomat78 November 7, 2008 7:18 AM PST
Obama treats technology with respect. His campaign revolved around it, his Webmaster was the co-founder of Facebook, and one of his senior advisors is the the CEO of Google. The last thing he needs are some yokes at the bottom of a news article offering lame suggestions. But I do like the Bill Gates idea.
Reply to this comment
by celticbrewer November 7, 2008 12:12 PM PST
It sounds like a good idea, but to control and grow technology on a national level, you have to regulate it. And that eventually means restricting freedom. Who's going to pay for it? Maybe 2009 will be the year of the internet tax.

The government needs to secure their own network (it sounds like Bush already put that into motion); but otherwise, stay out of the way and let private businesses innovate. -- Oh wait... that's a very capitalist way of thinking and definitely not what this new administration embraces.
Reply to this comment
by November 21, 2008 9:35 AM PST
Halburton ; has it's main office out side the United States making billions on the war and not paying taxes in the United States; that's you Bush policy of take and give back nothing! Why if you feel that capitalism is the way to go would you endorse taxing the internet. The engine of our county is not the wealthy but the working American. We should focus on supporting the average person. We have so over burdened the average worker that there is little left it is time to give back and grow our work force.
by rahein1 November 10, 2008 12:27 PM PST
We need Ray Kurzweil for CTO, not some corporate guy. If anyone knows change it is Kurzweil.

Kurzweil is an accomplished inventor, business man, investor, and futurist. If you read back over his predictions he has a great track record. Just read The Singularity Is Near.

Obama needs someone like Kurzweil, who doesn't just understand tech as it is today. But understands where it will be in 10 years. If we are going to get out of this energy crisis that is the kind of thinking we need.
Reply to this comment
by monchakib November 19, 2008 6:25 AM PST
choose the best search for your information need :

Yahoo, Google, Lycos,Aol Search, Altavista, Hotbot,

All the words, ask, gigablast, Teoma, Exite, The

Exacte Phrase, The Words, Sports Search Engines,

Search AardvarkSport, Any Word, Find a Hockey

Arena, Prov Code, State, Find a Stadium, Snow

Search, Ski Resort, Find a Golf Course, Daypop,

WeblogsNews, WeblogsRSS, Headlines, New York

Times, WebMultimedia, NYC, Events NYC Venues,

Science Search Engines, Scirus, Google cholar, New

Scientist, Biome, Citeseer, Encylopedia Search

Engines, About.com, Wikipedia, Encyclopedia.com,

Encarta, Bartleby, Full Text Entry , World Book,

InfoPlease, All Infoplease, Almanacs, Sports

Biographies,Dictionary, Encyclopedia, Government

Search Engines, FDA, US Department of Education,

EPA, US Gov, Federal, All States, One State, Library of

Congress, Education Search Engines, InfoMine, BUBL,

Internet Public Library, KidsClick, RDN, News Search

Engines, Yahoo Finance, MSN Money, Jayde, Business

By Domain, Adult Content, Fool, Market Watch, Meta

Search Engines, Ixquick Metasearch, Mamma,

Metacrawler, Vivismo, Search, MonsterCrawler, The

Web News, Mp3, Ftp, Kartoo, Zapmeta, DogPile, The

Web ImagesAudio, Auctions News, FTP Discussion,

Multimedia, Meta Eureka, Web Weblogs, News

Software, Directories Human Maintained, Zeal,

Directory members, DMOZ, JoeAnt, Yahoo Directory,

Gimpsy, Web World Index, All Info, Family Friendly,

Search All Words, Search Any Words.

choose all you need here :

http://www.allthebestsearchengines.blogspot.com
Reply to this comment
by November 21, 2008 9:18 AM PST
" In a world without fences who needs gate's" we need freedom in learning, we need to open the net to programs that will help our citizens learn. Any free programs that would encourage learning new subjects would only promote further growth in formal education. Formal education should focus on opening doors to subjects that would enable people to prepare themselves prior to formal education. Formal education should not simply be taken money for service but should be focus giving back to the community . If we have subjects that paralle the subjects being taught will only make it easier for formal education to do their job.
Reply to this comment
by superstevetech January 1, 2009 1:01 PM PST
This cabinet position could either make or break our world leadership in the World. an article I found regarding this subject; http://www.techheck.com/journal/2008/12/28/turning-a-linksys-wrt310n-into-a-wireless-bridge.html
Reply to this comment
by superstevetech January 1, 2009 1:04 PM PST
sorry, here is the correct link: http://www.techheck.com/journal/2008/12/24/the-united-states-cto-of-the-world.html
by alliedtrustdiamond June 13, 2009 11:48 AM PDT
description:
They use methods of repairing your credit you can do yourself if you simply google credit repair templates. Their process is very lengthy and requires months and even years to get a lot of things removed and sometimes the bad marks can come back as some companies are very persistent, especially if you still owe them money.
The only guaranteed method to repair your credit is to pay off the old bills and get your derogatory balances to $0. "Well that isn't very helpful" is probably what you are saying. Since none of us just have cash laying around to do that there are other things you can do that are guaranteed to increase your FICO score practically overnight and start rebuilding your credit.
It's actually very simple. Sign up for Millennium Secured Credit Card and send them $300. Buy $90 worth of groceries on it and make the payments. Keep the balance under $90. Then sign up for www.alliedtrustdiamond.com and get a $10,000 unsecured credit card, buy something and make the payments. Do a google search for USA Shopping Club and sign up with them for $12,500 unsecured credit card buy something and make the payments, Eclub USA and get your $3,500 credit card and finally Horizon Gold and get your $500 credit card.
Once all of these companies report to the credit bureaus you are going to see an immediate increase in your FICO score. Guaranteed. Then you can work on getting the bad marks paid off and removed. It's much easier to get them permanently deleted if you don't owe them any more money.
Reply to this comment
(19 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

15 sites that went kaput in 2009

Web sites launch all the time, but they also shut their doors. We highlight 15 that bit the dust this year.

Top 10 news stories of the decade

Let the debate begin: Was the iPhone more important than iTunes? Was anything bigger than Google finding a great business model? CNET offers its list of the 10 most important stories of the '00s.

About Politics and Law

News at the intersection of technology, politics, and law, ranging from intellectual property to censorship to tech policy.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Politics and Law topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right