• On BNET: Is the Mac finally ready for the office?
January 11, 2008 1:10 PM PST

Big surprise: Scrabble manufacturer targets 'Scrabulous' online game

by Caroline McCarthy

That noise you just heard was the sound of several hundred thousand procrastination-happy Facebook users gasping in panic.

Josh Quittner at Fortune reports that Hasbro, manufacturer of the timeless board game Scrabble, is trying to shut down Scrabulous, an unauthorized electronic version of Scrabble that has gained a rabid following on Facebook. The reasons are obvious: licensing. Scrabulous profits from advertising revenue. Hasbro, citing infringement, wants to see it scrapped.

There's no online version of Scrabble, but as Quittner notes, electronic rights to the game belong to video game manufacturer Electronic Arts. One of Scrabulous' creators confirmed to Quittner that Hasbro has contacted Facebook about removing the application.

Scrabulous was started in 2006 as a standalone site operated by a pair of 20-something Calcutta, India-based brothers, Jayant and Rajat Agarwalla, but the game exploded when they created a Facebook application that currently boasts 2.3 million active users and soon became the workplace productivity drain du jour. It's currently the ninth most popular application on the site. If Hasbro decides to take legal action against Scrabulous--which seems rather likely--it'll make a whole lot of cubicle monkeys very, very sad.

But Hasbro cares about its intellectual property, not about the desires of bored office workers. And, sadly, Scrabulous really does mirror Scrabble letter-for-letter: the "Rules of Scrabulous" section of Scrabulous' FAQ even redirects to the Wikipedia page for Scrabble. As Quittner wrote in his article, all good things must come to an end.

(Full disclosure: I have four active Scrabulous games in progress on Facebook.)

Caroline McCarthy, a CNET News staff writer, is a downtown Manhattanite happily addicted to social-media tools and restaurant blogs. Her pre-CNET resume includes interning at an IT security firm and brewing cappuccinos. E-mail Caroline.
Recent posts from The Social
Rickrolling iPhone worm is never gonna give you up
Going rogue? Palin bans gadgets, reporters from speech
Facebook: We're going after scammy ads, too
Offerpal Media mess gets stickier
After onstage spat, Offerpal replaces CEO
Beatles catalog comes to USB
MySpace changes terms of use to combat app scams
Twitter translates into Spanish
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (13 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
Think win-win!
by arutam January 11, 2008 3:47 PM PST
You'd think they could come up with a way to license it to FaceBook for a portion of the revenue, or simply buy the application from the developers. That way everyone would be happy. Including me, since it is about the only app I use on FaceBook.
Reply to this comment
When will big corporations learn to use the web?
by Lagoyu January 12, 2008 12:44 AM PST
I have played a number of 'official' versions of Scrabble on my computer, pda and phone over the years, both online and offline. Most have been poorly implemented and lacked any significant user base. Scrabulous is by far and away the best implementation and its Facebook version has made it phenomenally popular with players of all different levels.
Hasbro almost certainly has a good case for copyright infringement, but for the sake of good customer relations with all the millions of Scrabulous users who probably are currently Hasbro customers for the physical Scrabble game and other games, it would make so much sense for them to make the Scrabulous developers an offer they can't refuse and keep them on as well paid employees - of EA if necessary. This will be best for Hasbro's bottom line since they will retain the advertising revenue from the huge user base and the enormous customer base for future offerings these great developers they could come up with based on Hasbro's game catalog.
Shutting down Scrabulous will create a big backlash against Hasbro - I for one will probably boycott buying from them in future. I will certainly not be interested in payin
Reply to this comment
2.3 million
by Gwhat January 12, 2008 10:28 PM PST
2.3 million active users can't be wrong
Reply to this comment
Hasbro should purchase Scrabulous
by thewi2kbug January 17, 2008 11:42 AM PST
rather than slapping a class-action on these two talented gentlemen that created Scrabulous, they should buy the rights of Scrabulous, give these guys two good paying jobs and rebrand Scrabulous as Scrabble.... turn this into a perfect business investment
Reply to this comment
Hey now
by D.A.W. January 21, 2008 8:45 PM PST
stop making sense. There's no room for good sense in IP law.
Global expansion shouldn't be a scary proposition
by Chris Axtens January 23, 2008 10:47 AM PST
If there is such a large audience of potential Scrabble players on the sub-continent
as well as highly skilled I.T. supervisors
willing to help with Scrabble e-business investment expansion
then
what was mentioned by "thewi2kbug" as far as
employment opportunities are concerned
is
QUITE JUST and worth positive consideration.

Unless the people behind the initiation of the
class-action so happen to have more inclination
to giving jobs to non-ethnic origined persons
and those whom are only located in their
USA domain.
They already own the rights
by sportsfan206 January 26, 2008 3:04 PM PST
That is the point of the lawsuit. Scrabulous is a blatant rip of of Scrabble, why should Hasbro shell out one cent for something they created?
Scrabulous deserves a small bit of leverage,as do current match players
by Chris Axtens January 23, 2008 10:35 AM PST
One of those 4 matches on display in the FaceBook
site
is one between me,my eldest brother,
a newspaper journalist,and a tourism industry
university lecturer.

It is only there BECAUSE
my general access to the other Scrabulous matches
not established on FaceBook
has been denied and thus rendered unreachable along "website restructuring" grounds.

The Scrabulous organisation has been around longer
than my participation with the group.

My introduction to Scrabulous was as a birthday gift
to me on July 1,2007 from my
West Australian based eldest brother Bruce Axtens.
Himself a Scrabble fanatic
and
an employee at Strapper Technologies in Perth
West Australia.

I have since played more than 100 2-way matches against him,
my schoolteacher cousin from Sydney,
two of my politics journalism associates,
and
been involved in 3-way and 4-way contests
involving people from eastern Australia
of whom I would never ever get
to meet up with for hardback boardgame matchplay
opportunities.

Just a simple takeover of the group and
maintaining existing unfinished matches
should be considered
RATHER THAN
condemning hundreds of Scrabble players
to endure substantial heartburn that their
catalogue of previous match results have been
buried and destroyed in a hail
of power plays from big time entrepreneurs and
business operatives
targetting
sub-continent based entreprenurial minnows.

As to why the main complainant is screaming
blue murder over copyright issues NOW
when this situation has been going on
for more than a decade
and
not just by Scrabulous either
IS BEYOND MY COMPREHENSION!

As to whether it is worth the effort spending
money on litigation procedures when the
stockmarkets around the world are in freefall
and with it sales of Scrabble boardgames
dropping with it on affordability grounds

is up to them to decide!

Yours sincerely,

Christopher Axtens
(D.O.B. 1/7/1969)
Scrabble player since 1976

Assistant Secretary,
Lismore Workers Cricket Club

Assistant Secretary
Lismore Branch, New South Wales Division
Australian Labor Party
Reply to this comment
Hasbro, get a life!
by Simurgh30 February 14, 2008 7:16 AM PST
I agree: Hasbro should buy this marvellous and beautifully crafted on-line game, and make it a truly international version (that is, appropriate for web use) by also creating an electronic International English dictionary which truly complies with Scrabble's rules (the two which Scrabulous uses dont' which is annoying), and includes British, US, Asian English vocabulary, including definitions. One fun aspect of the game is learning new words!
Reply to this comment
I fully agree
by redwall_hp February 18, 2008 2:51 PM PST
I couldn't agree more. Hasbro needs to stop being idiots. They should buy Scrabulous, pay for server costs, and keep the scrabulous guys on as workers. Even better, they should do what Google did with YouTube and let the founders keep running the service themselves, but integrate the service into the parent company.
Reply to this comment
get real
by LapCat March 4, 2008 8:58 PM PST
What is it about FaceBook users? This is like the ...10th article I've glanced at this month that highlights their naiveté; their absolute delusion of entitlement. From whining about their potential employers easily discovering their drunken stupidity (and it's inevitable consequences)to this; blatant & illegal copyright infringement. Is anyone in the REAL world actually surprised by Hasbro's actions; after Microsoft's anti-piracy efforts, or the RIAA. Wake up and smell the $. And "this" is the internet generation :snicker:
Reply to this comment
typical corporation...
by speedy21 April 2, 2008 3:12 AM PDT
why don't they learn. if they shut down scrabulous people will just flock to other sites like ISC or quadplex.com they should either license or buy it outright
Reply to this comment
by coni68 September 26, 2008 5:36 PM PDT
years ago I bought the scrabble disc to play online with other people who also had bought the disc. This site is no longer available. Does anyone know of another place to play scrabble. I loved scrabulous, and hope something is resolved so we can continue to play the game and make many on line friends.
Reply to this comment
(13 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement
Click Here

After 5 years, Firefox faces new challenges

Mozilla helped reshape the Web since releasing Firefox 1.0 five years ago. Now it's got a reawakened Microsoft and Google Chrome to reckon with.

There's a map for that: GPS or smartphone?

Almost every handset comes with mapping software these days, but standalone GPS devices are becoming more affordable than ever.

About The Social

CNET News' Caroline McCarthy is a downtown Manhattanite who believes that, despite popular opinion, the Web can actually help your social life. She's happily addicted to fun social-media tools from Twitter to Yelp to Facebook, sends an inordinate number of text messages, and has a tendency to waste time at the office reading restaurant blogs. Here, she explores all facets of the Web's gregarious side, as well as the unique tech culture in her home city of New York. (Don't call it Silicon Alley.)

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Social topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right