SLCC '07: Chicago is the metaverse's metropolis

Some of Millennium Park's interesting architecture; the glowing structures are actually video-equipped displays that spray water at people frolicking in the nearby reflecting pool. No joke.

(Credit: Caroline McCarthy/CNET Networks)

CHICAGO, Ill.--This might just be the perfect city for a Second Life convention. At least this out-of-towner thinks so.

When you think about it, a good number of Chicago's urban planning quirks have quite a bit in common with the aesthetics of some of Second Life's more popular "sims." It's because parts of the city are so planned--as though they were created with a few well-thought-out mouse clicks that could easily be tweaked and improved. The business and shopping districts are peppered with bright displays of greenery and flowers, the streets and gardens in the Michigan Avenue vicinity are impeccably manicured, and skyscrapers extend literally to the banks of the local bodies of water. (Anyone who's seen New York's still-industrial waterfront will understand why this is a novelty to me.)

Plus, the city of Frank Lloyd Wright has all those eye-catching feats of modern and post-modern design--just walk into Millennium Park--that could make any jaded New Yorker say, "Holy (expletive), they actually built that? It got off the drawing board? Red tape and bureaucratic cronyism didn't halt it at stage one?"

The Second Life Community Convention kicked off Friday night with a number of art- and music-focused panels, but a good number of the attendees won't be in town until tomorrow morning--the recent spat of inconvenient weather phenomena in the Midwest crippled more than a few travel plans. Nevertheless, a small crowd of metaverse enthusiasts turned out at the Chicago Hilton on Friday evening to listen to live performances from musicians whom they'd previously known only as avatars, as well as to hear about the phenomenon of Second Life machinima--films created using the virtual world as a platform. (For those who are unfamiliar, machinima has made its way squarely into pop culture: there was a South Park episode that was about 60 percent World of Warcraft machinima, and Coca-Cola's heavily YouTubed Super Bowl ad was essentially Grand Theft Auto machinima.)

I'd never been to any kind of in-the-flesh Second Life gathering before, so taking note of the attendees was interesting. People had come from as far as New York (like me), Boston, San Francisco, Australia, Japan--there were plenty of foreign languages and accents. The crowd was largely a mix of geeks and art-school types, but the geeks were much more on the mainstream end of dorkdom than I'd have expected. There were a few unnatural hair colors, a wacky hat or two, and about a half dozen people who'd chosen to wear sunglasses indoors, but otherwise it was quite an average (albeit loquacious) bunch. A few were even flat-out business casual in dress pants and button-down shirts.

The average age was somewhere in the early- to mid-thirties, but interestingly skewed a bit older for females (i.e. the twentysomethings were primarily male). And Macs appeared to be the computer of choice, both at the SLCC events and at an offshoot art-and-music reception at Columbia College down the street (where machinima called "Zombie Horde" and music from the Avatar Orchestra Metaverse were showcased).

It was difficult to tell whether attendees, whose name tags displayed likenesses of their avatars, were introducing themselves by "meatspace" names or Second Life names. The latter seemed to prevail.

Judging by chitchat, nonprofit uses for Second Life are going to be a hot topic. One person at the machinima screening told me that he wouldn't be surprised if we saw discussion of the dissonance between residents who see Second Life marketing efforts as a cool and creative turn for corporate America and those who think it's just tacky advertising and product placement.

At one machinima screening, the host gave a rundown of the genre's definition for newbies, explaining that machinima is a form of filmmaking in which a video game is used as an artistic platform. "But Second Life isn't a game," he added quickly.

"It's a thingie!" several audience members shouted out.

[Len Bullard]

Second Life is Dieing

Second Life is dieing, Caroline. No innovation, a backlash that won't quit, radio stations years after other online worlds pioneered them, in other words, it has become a joke because in reality (the real kind), there is nothing to do there to keep people entertained. The corporations know they can privately host businesses and now it is a matter of determining which standards will make a browser worth downloading. It isn't going to be Second Life.

Social Life isn't what this is about because there aren't enough mutual self-interests to sustain it. Hype won't do it either. Content is expensive and the risk of building for a proprietary system is too great. LL made some serious mistakes and at least one fatal one. The trend to watch now is where the emerging class of 3D artists (not game artists, that is a very different breed) will go next with their skills.

[ethana2]

If you want a virtual world that works,

It needs to be open sourced from day one, not as an afterthought. Pathetic last ditch attempts simply don't cut it.

...and people need to be able to host their own servers. There are, after all, more than one planet in this universe.

[play7]

The ship is sinking

Really dont know what to say. The game is a mess, people are unhappy. Nobody pays for anything anymore the hackers are running around without a care in the world. Its a second life where the hell is now open and where people are insult and cause hate all they want.