• On TechRepublic: Windows 7: Slower to boot than Vista?
November 12, 2007 8:37 AM PST

Oracle: Just say no to operating systems

by Gordon Haff
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 2 comments

[Update: Corrected name of rPath CEO Billy Marshall.]

There's a nasty little war afoot over the future of the operating system.

In one corner you have the operating system vendors.

They're building in virtualization, for example. This increases the depth of their software stack. The OS vendors present virtualization as a natural addition to existing operating system functions and a means to integrate an increasingly-common software capability.

That's fair enough. But it's also about control, especially in a world where owning the hypervisor gives you an advantage when up-selling to management layers and other value-add software in which there's real money to be made (as opposed to the raw hypervisor, which is becoming increasingly commoditized).

As we saw last week in the case of Red Hat, OS vendors are on the lookout to circumvent attempts to make their operating systems (and their brands) irrelevant. In Red Hat's case, it was to quash the efforts of software appliance makers to effectively make the OS just a supporting feature of the application.

In another corner, you have the application vendors and their fellow travelers.

Software as a service (SaaS) is one aspect of this war. Taken to its logical extreme, it may change the role of systems companies as well as operating system vendors. However, we don't need to look that far into possible futures to see the application vendor front in this war.

Take the appliance makers that Red Hat was taking on last week. Rpath CEO Billy Marshall writes: "Fortunately for all of us, 'certification' will be a thing of the past when applications companies distribute their applications as virtual appliances." It's not hard to see why Red Hat doesn't exactly cotton to this way of thinking. After all, certification is a very large part of what Red Hat sells. And the number of applications certified to run on Red Hat comprises a huge barrier to any other Linux vendor delivering its own flavor of "Enterprise Linux."

Oracle's Unbreakable Linux is a different take from a different angle, but the end result is the same. Its concept is based on the idea that, when you buy an application from Oracle, you also get some bits that let the application sit on top of the hardware and perform necessary tasks like talking to disk. Oracle has been subsuming operating system functions like memory and storage management for years; subsuming the whole operating system was just the next logical step.

So is its latest move, coming out with its own hypervisor based on technology from the widely-used Xen Project. (Xen is also the basis for the hypervisor in Novell and Red Hat Linux--as well as OS-independent products from XenSource/Citrix and Virtual Iron.)

Just as Oracle wants to minimize the role of the OS, so too does it want to minimize the role of the hypervisor (which, as I noted, itself threatens to reduce the role of the OS--got all that?). From the vantage of Redwood Shores, VMware is getting altogether too much attention. The easiest way to minimize the impact of the virtualization players? Offer Oracle's own hypervisor.

The biggest challenge that I see facing Oracle here is similar to that facing Unbreakable Linux and software appliances in general. There's an implicit assumption that people will be willing to have one virtualization for their boxes that run Oracle and another virtualization for everything else--that the maker of the hypervisor bits doesn't matter.

So far, there's scant evidence that people are willing to be quite so blase about their server virtualization. Furthermore, brand preferences aside, it remains early days for standards that handle the control and movement of virtual machines across virtual infrastructures sourced from different vendors. It's perhaps more thinkable that Oracle database and application servers might be kept independent from a general virtual infrastructure than would be the case with other, often less business-critical, applications. But, at least today, its still counter the overall trend of IT shops looking at server virtualization in strategic rather than machine-by-machine tactical ways.

As a result, I don't see this announcement having a broad near-term impact (as, indeed, Unbreakable Linux did not either, once the original raft of press stories and industry discussion died down). Rather, I see this as Oracle determined to keep making its statement, time and time again, that, someday, the operating system won't matter. That's Larry's story, and he's sticking with it.

Gordon Haff is a principal IT adviser at Illuminata and has more than 20 years of IT industry experience. He writes about what's happening with enterprise servers and data centers, "Yotta-scale" computing, and related software and device trends as part of the CNET Blog Network. Disclosure.
Recent posts from The Pervasive Data Center
VMware elevates its desktop virtualization view
Intel's James Reinders on parallelism - Part 2
Intel's James Reinders on parallelism: Part 1
Red Hat debuts virtualization management
3Leaf's modern take on NUMA
Cloud computing's dual identity
Technology takes time
I/O virtualization's competing forms
Add a Comment (Log in or register)
by SkillzCheck January 4, 2008 11:47 PM PST
$140.00 Per Student (8 Session Clinic)

We deliver top level soccer training and instruction with the objective of guiding players to attain their maximum potential in the game of soccer. We place an emphasis on skill and tactical development and the maximization of game enjoyment through a training process that emphasizes fair play, respect and enjoyment of the game. Our programs are presented through a dynamic and creative soccer training model. We encourage players to use their imagination and creativity while playing. Skillz Check Soccer Academy coaches conduct an innovative skills program which provides an opportunity for total involvement for each player. At Skillz Check Soccer Academy we focus on allowing players to express their individuality while giving them concise feedback on how they can improve their game play.

Skillz Check Soccer Academy LLC is a newly incorporated LLC, emerging from under the umbrella of Brazilian Touch Soccer. We begin our second year with a solid foundation of experience, and are expanding with newly added coaches, partners, and educational focus. All of the trainers at Skillz Check Soccer Academy LLC are seasoned professionals with years of domestic and international playing and training experience.

What we offer
Skillz Check Soccer Academy, first and foremost, brings a new training environment for all the players. They will learn:
- small-sided games and drills;
- a unique approach to happiness in play;
- World-class 1v1 moves;
- most importantly ? a different way to see the game;

Besides providing exceptional soccer trainers and well thought out educational sessions, Skillz Check Soccer Academy will increase your player's foundational fitness.

Built into each training session is core stability training.
We also provide fitness training geared for soccer and suitable for the level of each individual athlete.

In each training session we cover all relevant fitness areas: strength, flexibility, agility, aerobic and anaerobic endurance, and speed.
And of course Skillz Check Soccer Academy provides outstanding soccer development, from a core of international developed players and trainers.

Let Skillz Check Soccer Academy help develop the core stability, over-all fitness, and technical soccer skills of your player.

Address:
P.O. Box #7004
Nashua, NH 03060
United States

Phone:
(319) 228-2528

Fax:
(515) 581-0620

Mobile:
(603) 996-1294

E-mail:
info@skillzcheck.com

Website:
http://skillzcheck.com


Copyright 2007-2008 | Check Skillz Soccer Academy LLC | All Rights Reserved
Reply to this comment
by Devlin_McGregor January 25, 2008 10:55 AM PST
http://www.onlinerewardcenter.com/xg_reg.htm is a shame filled scam. Do not fall fore the "2 Free iPod Nano" lure! You will catch a batch of 50 or more spam emails per day, at least 2 telemarketers calling both home and cell, junk faxes, and non-stop garbage snail male.
Reply to this comment
advertisement

As alternative energy grows, NIMBY greens

With more renewable energy projects trying to come online, the country grapples with the balance between local land use and a national push for clean energy.

Google to remake programming with Go

A Unix co-creator is among those behind a language Google hopes will speed computers and programming. Today, Go becomes open-source software.

advertisement

About The Pervasive Data Center

This blog takes a deep (and often skeptical) look at trends big and small in the world of enterprise servers, data centers, and "Yotta-scale" computing. This means also taking into account the myriad of software, networks, and devices that are driving change in (or being driven by) these back-end systems. Stories posted to this blog may also appear on Illuminata's site.

Gordon Haff is a principal IT adviser for Illuminata of Nashua, N.H. Before becoming an IT industry analyst, Gordon held a variety of product-marketing positions at Data General, spanning more than a decade. He's programmed for DOS, Windows, and Linux; builds his own PCs; and holds engineering degrees from MIT and Dartmouth, with an MBA from Cornell. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure.

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Pervasive Data Center topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right