July 25, 2008 5:01 PM PDT

Don't be greedy for hard disk space

Are there things you can never have too much of? Sure. Money and closet space come to mind off the top of my head. What about hard disk space? You can, indeed, have too much hard disk space.

(Credit: Western Digital)

I know this seems ridiculous, but for Defensive Computing, large capacity hard disks are riskier than lower capacity ones. The reason is simple, cramming more bits in the same physical space means crowding them closer together. This is asking for trouble.

This came up on an old Security Now! podcast by Steve Gibson. Gibson is famous for security, but his day job is hard disks and he is an expert on the subject. He makes his living selling SpinRite, a hard disk diagnostic and repair program.

As he put it "Drives have gotten so dense that drives are now depending upon the error correction code, ECC, just to read good sectors, not even bad sectors."

SpinRite owners see this all the time. I recently ran a SpinRite diagnostic on a hard disk that generated over 3 million correctable errors.

When Gibson goes shopping for hard disks he asks for the smallest capacity available. This posting was prompted by the fact that I had just done the same thing a few days ago.

See a summary of all my Defensive Computing postings.

Recent posts from Defensive Computing
Why can't Firefox print as well as Internet Explorer?
Summarizing the Nvidia problems with laptop chips overheating
In a pinch, GoDaddy and Typepad let a customer down
The market share of Firefox vs. Internet Explorer
Netflix computer problems continue
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 6 comments (Page 1 of 1)
by Howard_V_Agnew July 26, 2008 12:38 AM PDT
I just done read this article and just done thought maybe, instead of shopping for a hard drive, you shoud done have studied grammar!
Reply to this comment View reply
by jgfuller July 28, 2008 1:49 PM PDT
What maximum size would you recommend, for a laptop and a desktop?
Reply to this comment View reply
by jgfuller July 28, 2008 1:49 PM PDT
What maximum size would you recommend, for a laptop and a desktop?
Reply to this comment
by alegr July 30, 2008 10:04 AM PDT
That's pure steer manure. These days, if you ask for smaller capacity drive, which is less than 1 year old, you'll get pretty much the same recording density, but just less platters or even just a single head. That means SG doesn't know what he's doing. If you want a drive that doesn't rely on Reed-Solomone and PRML, good luck. Go buy an old 1 GB drive on eBay. Whatever you get in stores is using those technologies.

Steve Gibson is actually more like an expert in selling his BS-powered software, than in anything else.
Reply to this comment
Powered by Jive Software
advertisement
  • About Defensive Computing

  • Michael Horowitz is an independent computer consultant and the author of several classes on Defensive Computing. He views Defensive Computing as taking steps, when things are running well, to avoid or minimize the inevitable problems down the road. It's about educating yourself to the level where you can make your own intelligent decisions about keeping your computers and data happy and healthy. If you depend on computers, yet are on your own, without an IT department or nearby nerd, this blog's for you. His personal web site is michaelhorowitz.com.

    He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET.

    Disclosure.

Add this feed to your online news reader
Google
Yahoo
MSN

Latest tech news headlines

Featured blogs

Beyond Binary by Ina Fried

Coop's Corner by Charles Cooper

Defense in Depth by Robert Vamosi

Geek Gestalt by Daniel Terdiman

Green Tech

One More Thing by Tom Krazit

Outside the Lines by Dan Farber

The Iconoclast by Declan McCullagh

The Social by Caroline McCarthy

Underexposed by Stephen Shankland

advertisement
On GameSpot: Our first look at the new Wolfenstein!
Advanced
search
Advanced
search
Visit other CBS Interactive sites