Red Hat opens Network...now how about a community?

Red Hat has been talking about open sourcing its Network for well over a year. Today, it finally did it.

However, code by itself is only moderately interesting. What we need now is a thriving community around "Project Spacewalk," as Red Hat calls the Network project.

Why? Well, because in some ways the commercial open-source community increasingly fragments as it matures financially. What is the first thing that MySQL and JBoss did to add value to their support subscriptions? Build networks. What, presumably, will be the first things that other open-source companies do? Build networks.

What is the result? A swamp of incompatible service-delivery networks.

Now consider the power for Red Hat if its Spacewalk actually served as a gathering point - an integration point - for the commercial open-source community? Powerful.

We haven't bumped into the problem yet because the open-source industry is still in its infancy, and there have been few mergers and acquisitions. But as Sun, Red Hat, IBM, and others acquire commercial open-source vendors, it would be nice if they could focus on the value of the companies they acquire, and not on integrating incompatible network products.

So, here's a significant opportunity for Red Hat with Spacewalk: Foster a community around it that includes a wide range of commercial open-source companies. Convince the world to build on the Red Hat standard.

Yes, Red Hat has traditionally been a difficult partner. But that has changed, and can change further. The benefits?

1. Red Hat establishes itself as the center of the open-source ecosystem;
2. The open-source industry consolidates around a service-delivery network standard, thereby increasing integration between commercial open-source projects and value to customers;
3. Red Hat scores points with its commercial open-source peers by providing a shortcut to develop products that many of them will otherwise want/need to develop from scratch;
4. Red Hat will see its RHN code improved by a wider range of companies with diverse interests and experience, which will make it better suited to a Red Hat future that includes things like databases, applications, etc., which might well make integration of other products easier for Red Hat to digest as it grows beyond the operating system.

This is an awesome opportunity for Red Hat. Will it take up the mantle of leadership?

[mbbickel]

Red Hat already put out a really nice infrastructure in combination with Hyperic - http://www.rhq-project.org/. This was the basis of the JBoss Network, and is a more services oriented approach with a very nice agent architecture that let's any component gain management capability. We are using this for our upcoming release of Ringside Networks Social Application Server. In essence we are opening up the social services for management and understanding. This kind of proves the open model.

Bob Bickel
(Note, I am on the board at Hyperic and was a former JBoss employee and own stock in Red Hat and am a founder of Ringside Networks)

[jojomcleod]

And does that have a thriving community around it?

[mbbickel]

Between the JBoss Networ, Hyperic and RHQ, there is a very thriving set of users and controbutors. Arguably better than anything else out there, with the possible exception of the lower end and Nagios. Bob Bickel

[jojomcleod]

Really? Where is this community? I googled around and did not find much.

It looks like Spacewalk already has a pretty impressive community. There are many blog posts about it and it seems several active mailing lists.