• On CHOW: Why are shopping carts so hard to steer?
October 14, 2007 5:11 PM PDT

OpenOffice's apparent mission creep

by Matt Asay
  • Font size
  • Print
  • Post a comment

Apparently, OpenOffice 3.0 is intent on picking a fight with Microsoft Outlook. Bonne chance, mes amis. I don't mean to imply that it can't be done, but am rather suggesting that this is not the right way to go about it. Zimbra, sure. Or Mozilla's Thunderbird (standalone), sure. But bundled into OpenOffice? I'm not seeing it.

This arises from a presentation delivered earlier this year at the OpenOffice conference:

One thing that really caught my attention was (a) reference to including a Personal Information Manager (PIM) (in OpenOffice). More specifically the presentation mentions bundling Thunderbird with their Office Suite, and refers to it as an "Outlook replacement."

Bundling a runner-up PIM/e-mail suite with a runner-up Office replacement? Not likely. Disruption is the way to go, and the combination is not disruptive.

Zimbra changes the game sufficiently, and is innovative in its own right, such that I can see people being patient with it to overlook some of its weaknesses relative to Outlook to give it a shot. (My own company is currently looking to do just that, and not even remotely out of religious open-source reasons.)

Thunderbird is the same, if it can generate enough of a community around it. If Mozilla can achieve the same plug-in community around Thunderbird that it has around Firefox, then it would be a winner, even if corporate IT took eons to adopt it (which it will).

But marrying Thunderbird to OpenOffice is a losing strategy, because OpenOffice has yet to prove that it knows how to grow a viable community around it. OpenOffice would need to be substantially rewritten and have its community procedures significantly overhauled before it could be a strong Trojan Horse for other open-source projects to flourish. Today, OpenOffice is quite good and something I actually recommend to neighbors and family members. It works.

But not because of any vibrant community around it, and that is the major thing holding it back. Until it groks community, OpenOffice is a losing competitor to Microsoft Office, and burdening itself with yet another Microsoft turf war would only exacerbate the problem, not ameliorate it.

So, cute idea. But I'd rather fix OpenOffice first before anyone kicks mission creep into overdrive with it.

Via Slashdot.

Matt Asay brings a decade of in-the-trenches open-source business and legal experience to The Open Road, with an emphasis on emerging open-source business strategies and opportunities. Matt is vice president of business development at Alfresco, a company that develops open-source software for content management. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure. You can follow Matt on Twitter @mjasay.
Recent posts from The Open Road
Zimbra buy to raise VMware's cloud ante
Can open source be consumer friendly?
An application war is brewing in the cloud
2010 the year of cloud-computing...M&A
Canonical shines its Ubuntu light on consumers
Open source became big business in 2009
Will we see an open-source IPO in 2010?
Could Apache keep Google's regulators at bay?
The real issue with OpenOffice
by j_a_s_p_e_r October 14, 2007 6:10 PM PDT
I've been using openoffice for many many years now. Its usable for my basic needs, but the bugs and limitations often drive me up the wall. I don't see Thunderbird's inclusion as a big issue. Its a mature enough product, unlike the rest of openoffice. Unfortunately I have to concede that a mail client will just be a distractor to solving these really serious core problems :

1. Wizards don't work very well. They have too few options and rarely yield results even close to the desired document. (Just try getting any decent results with the OpenOffice Base Report Wizard).

2. Bugs. The software is riddled with bugs. Not the Access Violation kind, but the logical error kind. (Try selecting a large number of data fields in a tabular data merge to OpenOffice Calc)

3. Visual functionality gets neglected. Often dialogs are poorly translated, fields are off forms. There are even dialogs where useless restrictions are preventing taking the actions needed (ridiculous limit on the number of fields in a datamerge to Calc)

4. Help is just plain awful. It often just states the laughable obvious. This is probably the most embarrasing part of the software

I work for a small software company and I know what 2 or 3 good programmers can do. Why is OpenOffice still so junky? I don't get it. A few good permanent dedicated programmers is all it needs
Reply to this comment
Jasper - IBM just added 35 full-time devs
by tristanbob October 14, 2007 8:51 PM PDT
Yeah, I don't know why open office is still lacking in a lot of areas.

In addition to the existing developers, IBM just hired 35 to work on it. I hope they can do things right and make it an AWESOME office tool. Only time will tell.

Tristan
Reply to this comment
It is the most often called for feature
by Conficio October 18, 2007 12:28 PM PDT
Matt,
I think you are right on many points but miss two essential ones.
A. OpenOffice.org has a significant community and a very large user base, just not in the US. Have a look at the dedicated community of people that translate and internationalize the product into over 170 languages of the world. Some of these even have the backing and financing of their local government. Not withstanding, there are some voices that this community could be improved further and that its governance could be improved as well.
B. An E-Mail/Calendar integration is the number one asked for feature enhancement. The user community does clearly want it and I guess if done right, it will clearly help the numbers that use OpenOffice.org. With "done right" I mean not just a bundling, but a real adaptation/integration, with unified user interface etc. Why in the world would that not fly?
Reply to this comment
advertisement

Five New Year's resolutions for Google

Stakes are high as Google attempts to maintain one of the Internet's greatest cash machines while pushing into new and risky markets.
• Android event set for Jan. 5

For eBay sellers, a holiday hamster hangover

The gift frenzy over Zhu Zhu Pets leaves some power sellers feeling like they've just run a marathon--but the steep price tags lead to some impressive profits.

About The Open Road

Matt Asay brings a decade of in-the-trenches open-source business and legal experience to the Open Road, with an emphasis on emerging open-source business strategies and opportunities. Matt is general manager of the Americas division and vice president of business development at Alfresco, a company that develops open-source software for content management. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure.

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Open Road topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right