• On The Insider: Britney's Bikini-Clad Top 10
March 10, 2008 1:08 PM PDT

A dark side of solar power

by Elsa Wenzel
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 1 comment

The growth of the solar power industry is poisoning land in China, according to the Washington Post.

Polysilicon, which is widely used to make solar panels, is in short supply. In the rush to make it cheaply, a Chinese company reportedly is dumping toxic waste into the ground, killing wildlife and endangering human health.

The newspaper describes green fields in the nation's eastern central Henan Province that have turned snow white from the powdery waste of silicon tetrachloride, four tons of which result from every ton of polysilicon created. Toxic hydrogen chloride gas and acids waft from the waste.

The waste is allegedly coming from Chinese polysilicon maker Luoyang Zhonggui High-Technology, a supplier of rising solar power star Suntech Power, according to the Washington Post.

"In China, polysilicon plants are the new dot-coms," writes Ariana Eunjung Cha, reporting that new factories there are set to produce more than twice the amount of polysilicon as is currently manufactured in the world. Silicon tetrachloride can be recycled. But manufacturers reportedly can make polysilicon about two-thirds more cheaply if they ignore environmental protections.

Henan Province is in the eastern central part of China.

Henan Province is in the eastern central part of China.

(Credit: Google Maps)

U.S. politicians and activists have been pushing for "green-collar jobs" to fill the gap left by the dwindling blue-collar economy.

"Green" drywall maker Serious Materials is pursuing building a U.S. plant. And Suntech Power has expressed interest in building U.S. factories, helping to avoid the high price of shipping solar panels. However, watchdog groups and environmental laws in the United States would likely aim to prevent or punish the kind of dumping Suntech's supplier has been accused of.

Other unanticipated side effects of new "clean" technologies include rising food costs linked to the growing of corn for ethanol as well as the clearing of Indonesian rainforests to grow palm for biofuels. And China's Three Gorges Dam is flooding enormous swaths of land to make possible the world's largest hydropower plant.

Recent posts from Green Tech
A Toyota Prius owner waits for the recall
Ford to debut all-electric Transit Connect van
Hints of a bubble in green-tech IPOs
Toyota adds 2010 Prius to global recall list
Survey: More people looking for help on recycling
Areva buys solar-thermal start-up Ausra
Israeli gas stations to swap Better Place car batteries
Turn your office expense reports into toilet paper
Add a Comment (Log in or register)
by reptimania September 7, 2009 11:42 PM PDT
Great article! Yet there is another aspect to Chinese solar which is very threatening besides dumping, employment, and environmental costs. Yes, Suntech will hurt the industry, job sector, and the already toxic air in China- but it will hurt the US tax payer through involuntary utility costs, and aid an even greater deficit..<br /><br />Remember, the renewable energy market in the US, specifically solar, is a heavily subsidized market for the consumer. In many cases the consumer will receive up to 50% of the total costs covered by rebates, tax incentives, and federal tax credits. Remember that stimulus bill which was passed to stimulate our economy? Well, when it comes to the cost of installing solar on your home, you will have to pay half of that cost in solar panels (half of which is subsidized in some form or another.)<br /><br />This means that for every customer the Chinese manufacturer gains, the US tax payer accounts for half of this profit. It doesn't take an economy professor to know that money borrowed from China to stimulate our economy, while govt. are sneaking "solar" bills through congress in our sleep, which gets redistributed back into China through Solar is only creating an even larger deficit. It's throwing money at a solution, which is really "the problem" to begin with.<br /><br />According to Joseph Fleshman at the Califonia Energy Commission, it is OK for Chinese manufacturers to allow "branches" to open up in the US with different names, product model numbers, logos, and to falsely advertise their product as their "own" brand. He says that as long as a company, such as Centron Solar (www.centronsolar.com) receives a multiple-listee letter from the manufacturer in China they are allowed to "privately label" their product. Of course these 3rd party companies are all from China also.<br /><br />This means that if company X, Y, and Z privately label a specific solar panel from manufacturer A, there is a 4x duplication of the exact same product, all claiming to be their "own" brand. To take this scenario further, if you will, add company Q, P, R and you have a 7x duplication of the same solar panel all claiming to be different. Add 10 more model numbers from manufacturer A, and you you have even greater duplication. Then add 10 more manufacturers to the mix and you can quickly see that there is an exponential relationship in the growth of misrepresentation of Chinese solar products. How should this be accepted by CEC, who sets the greater example for other states when it comes to solar??<br /><br />Demand some answers:<br />Joseph Fleshman<br />California Energy Commission<br />Renewables Call Center<br />Ph. 916-654-4562<br />Fax. 916-653-2543
Reply to this comment
advertisement

Google's social side aims for some Buzz

Facebook and Twitter are the darlings of the social-media world, not Google--which hopes to change that with Buzz, betting it can organize your online social life.

Watching the birth of a gaming start-up

Stewart Butterfield and his friends are back at it with a new company. CNET's Daniel Terdiman was given exclusive, behind-the-scenes access as they built it from scratch.

About Green Tech

Innovation in energy and environmental technologies is long overdue, in business and at home. Green-tech reporter Martin LaMonica and other CNET writers serve up fresh clean-tech news and commentary.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Green Tech topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right