• On TV.com: Sexy summer bodies photo gallery
May 21, 2008 7:00 AM PDT

Microsoft's new tack: Bribery as a business model

by Charles Cooper

So the news is leaking out fast: Microsoft plans to lure users by dangling cash rebates to people who buy stuff using the company's search. Will it work? At this point, I suppose it can't hurt--though no doubt Microsoft is leaving itself open to being ridiculed as a Delancey Street hondler.

Arnold Zafra over at Search Engine Journal wrote that he "cringed" when he heard about the news. Ouch.

A couple of thoughts:

This isn't the first time that Microsoft has tried something like this. As CNET News.com's Ina Fried noted Wednesday:

It has run a number of programs including its Live Search Club that offer rewards for those that use its search. The Live Search Club effort briefly boosted Microsoft's search market share last year, but the gains have proved short lived. Microsoft has been losing ground since then and has returned to a single digit share of the market.

But truth be told, it's not the worst idea. What's the harm in giving it a shot? In a recession--or whatever you want to call the current economic malaise in the United States--consumers are open to bribes (oh, I forgot: rebates). So why not see if this strikes the people's fancy? But this is only a holding action. The reason more people use Google's search is the user experience. It works better, so they keep returning. Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer knows this. That's why he still thinks making a move for some of Yahoo's assets makes sense. He's anxious about staying pat with Microsoft's current search hand and wants to fix things, either through developing technology internally or buying it on the open market.

No way this is the final word.

Charles Cooper has covered technology and business for more than 25 years. Before joining CNET News, he worked at the Associated Press, Computer & Software News, Computer Shopper, PC Week, and ZDNet. E-mail Charlie.
Recent posts from Coop's Corner
It's Coop's -30- column: Adios, sorta
To catch a (cyber) thief: It's not easy
I'm officially dropping out of the Twitter gab fest
Telcos said testing plan to offer PCs to businesses
The world is flat. So what's our problem?
First GM, now Silicon Graphics. Lessons learned?
LotusLive Engage: IBM's cloud gets social
LongJump to foster private clouds for corporate IT
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (11 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by ancre007 May 21, 2008 9:40 AM PDT
Aren't reporters supposed to be objective? I think this is a stupid move by MSFT, but calling it 'bribery' shows more about the reporter's biases than the actual merits/de-merits of the program. My Discover card gives me cash back. I have not heard anyone call that bribery. Please try to be honest if you want to be a credible journalist. Or go do something else.
Reply to this comment
by gary85739 May 21, 2008 9:42 AM PDT
Business has used the "bribery" method since time began!

Ever hear of "lobbyist"?
Reply to this comment
by grindsmygears May 21, 2008 9:50 AM PDT
Before people start posting comments about what I wrote, I want to set the record straight, I AM NOT A MICROSOFT SUPPORTER and DON'T LOVE/HATE GOOGLE EITHER.

Where was this author when Google started peddling its Google Checkout service. Buy using Google checkout and get $10 off the sub-total. Isn't this the same. I hate when reporters (if you can call him that) are biased about what they write and definitely out of context.
Reply to this comment
by jessiethe3rd May 21, 2008 9:53 AM PDT
HONESTLY...
If you are not the leader and you want to become the leader why not incent people to use your service back giving the money back that they make from the search!? You can laugh at them if you want but I'll be laughing right to the bank with the money I make back while the rest of people are busy ridiculing them.
Reply to this comment
by grindsmygears May 21, 2008 9:57 AM PDT
An example of a more objective and unbiased article on this topic that CNET needs to learn from.

http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/05/21/microsoft-searching-for-users-with-rebates/index.html?hp
Reply to this comment
by mmichaels May 21, 2008 10:09 AM PDT
Well, I suppose if "Arnold Zafra" doesn't like it, it must be trash. That guy's bigger than Bill Gates isn't he?
Reply to this comment
by eadeguzman May 21, 2008 10:26 AM PDT
I hope that News.com would reserve these kinds of articles under an Opinions and Editorials section -- so that it's clear that it's not news but more of a a commentary.

More like a personal blog to me than a regular news article.
Reply to this comment
by sal-magnone May 21, 2008 10:33 AM PDT
This isn't new. Previous search engines have tried this. Remember that one that had a 'prize' every day (a couple of $K)?

In a cinsumer space expect consumer hokeyness (is that a word?).
Reply to this comment
by wolivere May 21, 2008 10:42 AM PDT
Is this one of those news articles that are ment to not have meat? And just draw eyes?

Lets see rebates on cars? Cash back on Mortages car loans? Coupons at grocery stores? Cash back incentives at Best Buy?

Google Yahoo have used similar systems?

Heck is not googles entire existence based upon advertising click model funding? Pass through ???

Sort of at awe with this article... wait I'm not in awe at all. I think the only reason I come to this site now and then is to see this kind of crap to remind me what good news is all about.

This site is more like a tabloid then a news site now... all eye catching headlines with no meat or substance with a ton of FUD and SPIN to please corporate sponsor'...
Reply to this comment
by eadeguzman May 21, 2008 11:57 AM PDT
Thanks for removing this "article" from the main page. "Bribery" is a very strong word that could possibly expose News.com to a lawsuit for slander.
Reply to this comment
by PerrySTT May 21, 2008 4:32 PM PDT
Good to see that the comments suggest a more thoughtful view of "business chess" than does the vacuous article by "Coop" (who should go sit and the corner and think a bit more about this). Five things to consider (some already pointed out) if you think mockery makes sense here:

1) Google just pockets all of the money it gets from advertisers -- isn't that worse than Microsoft sharing some of it with customers who are generating the value in the first place?
2) Reward models are proven/successful in credit cards, airlines, and dozens of other realms...why not in search, where $10B+ of advertising dollars float around
3) The value to advertisers of a program like this is probably even greater than the value to consumers, since they only pay for purchases, rather than clicks (e.g. sidestepping fraud, etc.) and this is a major step toward robust CPA models
4) Pretty powerful business move: if buyers flock to Live, is Google left with lower value informational and "upper funnel" searches only? Isn't 80% of the search advertising value in 20% of searches that are commercial in nature
5) Competitively brilliant: could Google really follow? What would happen to its market cap if it had to give away 50% of the value of each search to customers??? This is a classic attacker strategy: create a variable cost burden for the market leader

Not clear this will work, but I applaud Microsoft for trying something out of the box while its teams struggle to catch up with the superior search experience currently on Google.
Reply to this comment
(11 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

Making sense of Windows 7 upgrades

faq The basics and the fine print on Microsoft's options for those eyeing the next operating system from Redmond.
• Full Windows 7 coverage

Road Trip 2009: Big Sky Country

CNET News reporter Daniel Terdiman takes his car full of gadgets to the Rockies and the Great Plains in search of tech, science, nature, and more.
• America's Fortress: Cheyenne Mountain

About Coop's Corner

Charles Cooper has covered technology and business for more than 25 years. A graduate of Queens College and Columbia University, Cooper received the Excellence in Journalism award from the Northern California branch of the Society for Professional Journalists for column writing.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Coop's Corner topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right