• On BNET: Dumb (but funny) career moves
April 11, 2008 11:33 AM PDT

TiVo patent win against EchoStar upheld

by Erica Ogg
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 8 comments

Updated at 11:45 a.m. PDT with Dish Network's statement.

Another court has upheld TiVo's patent suit against EchoStar Communications.

A U.S. Appeals Court on Friday denied EchoStar's appeal on an earlier court ruling that said the company's Dish Network digital video recorders violated a patent held by TiVo. The ruling was first reported by Thomas Hawk's Digital Connection blog.

Friday's appellate court decision comes two years after TiVo's initial victory, in which a court found that EchoStar's DVRs (digital video recorders) "willfully infringed" on TiVo's patented TimeWarp technology. EchoStar appealed the ruling, which awarded $73.9 million in damages to TiVo. It was also upheld by an appeals court in January.

Alviso, Calif.-based TiVo first sued EchoStar in 2004 for selling its Dish Network DVR, which, like TiVo's DVR, allows TV watchers to record one channel and watch another simultaneously.

"We are extremely pleased that the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit today denied EchoStar's petition for a rehearing en banc, upholding the court's unanimous ruling in our favor on January 31, 2008, in EchoStar's appeal of the district court judgment of patent infringement, full award of damages and an order for the injunction to be reinstated," TiVo said in a statement.

EchoStar said it was "disappointed" by the court's decision not to rehear its appeal. "The decision, however, will have no effect on our current or future customers because EchoStar's engineers have developed and deployed 'next-generation' DVR software to our customers' DVRs," the company said in a statement. EchoStar said the updated software has been delivered to its customers and that none of the DVRs currently infringe on TiVo's patent, and promised that customers will see no interruption in service as a result of the ruling.

EchoStar, which has since changed its name to Dish Network, said it plans to appeal the ruling to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Erica Ogg is a CNET News reporter who covers Apple, HP, Dell, and other PC makers, as well as the consumer electronics industry. She's also one of the hosts of CNET News' Daily Podcast. In her non-work life, she's a history geek, a loyal Dodgers fan, and a mac-and-cheese connoisseur. E-mail Erica.
Recent posts from News Blog
Nvidia puts NForce chipset development on hold
Opera 10 browser is here
Neil Young Archives Blu-ray: Rip off?
Acronis revises survey results about backup habits
Acronis miscalculates data on users' bad backup habits
Flickr co-founder presses beta button
Comcast, Sony open retail store
Cox to try coaxing the Internet into submission
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (8 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
Dish DVRs rock...sorry Tivo, but enjoy the money!
by shanewalker April 11, 2008 12:38 PM PDT
As a happy customer of Dish for a few years now, I have to say
that this resolution neither surprises me nor changes my
positive feelings about the company and their products. Look at
the reviews, both professional and user, and you'll see I'm not
alone in saying, Dish knows how to build a quality DVR. The
622/722 series beats anything out there in the HD DVR sphere,
and that's as cutting edge as it gets. So, I say enjoy this victory
Tivo--it's your victory as others become more relevant in
actually moving time-shifting into the future.

I say this knowing full well that Tivo was a key innovator in the
space and continues to maintain loyal fans of its user
experience. But let's face it, they have long since become less a
manufacturer of 'stuff' in the here-and-now and more a
litigating machine making profits from past successes. Sortof
sad.

And with Echostar's purchase a while back of Sling Media, they
show they 'get it'. Beyond time-shifting, the future is also about
place-shifting.

Chin up Charlie (and gang), and keep the good stuff coming!

Oh, and about those national HD channels we've been waiting
for...;)
Reply to this comment
I don't get it...
by drfrost April 11, 2008 12:51 PM PDT
Are you saying it's ok for a company to infringe on a patent as long as they make a better end product?
View all 3 replies
Sorry Charlie...
by honorable1 April 11, 2008 3:21 PM PDT
Completely bogus decision. This 'technology' is easily implemented independently with a TV/Video card and a PC. You can record a cable channel simultaneous to watching another channel. The only thing unique here is the 'removal' of advertising, which is nothing more than capturing the identifing code for the ad in the Tv signal. The US patent system is going to H311 and companies like tivo, and an inept USPTO, are driving it to ruin. Call your congress(person)man and tell them to vote against "patent reform".
Reply to this comment
(8 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

Five New Year's resolutions for Google

Stakes are high as Google attempts to maintain one of the Internet's greatest cash machines while pushing into new and risky markets.
• Android event set for Jan. 5

For eBay sellers, a holiday hamster hangover

The gift frenzy over Zhu Zhu Pets leaves some power sellers feeling like they've just run a marathon--but the steep price tags lead to some impressive profits.

About News Blog

Recent posts on technology, trends, and more.

Add this feed to your online news reader

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right