• On TechRepublic: Five super-secret features in Windows 7
February 28, 2008 5:43 AM PST

'Virtual' fence along U.S.-Mexico border delayed

by Anne Broache
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 16 comments

The Bush administration's plan to outfit the U.S.-Mexico border with a "virtual" fence consisting of sensors, cameras, and drone aircraft is running into technical snags.

Federal officials told a congressional committee on Wednesday that the first phase of the project--consisting of about 100 miles near Yuma and Tuscon, Ariz., and El Paso, Texas--won't likely be completed until 2011, about three years later than expected, according to The Washington Post. The task is being overseen by the Department of Homeland Security and has been contracted out to Boeing.

The Bush administration is working on adding a 'virtual' fence--consisting of sensors, drones, and cameras--in an effort to supplement physical fences like this one along the U.S.-Mexico border.

(Credit: U.S. Department of Homeland Security)

For years, the Bush administration has been heralding the concept of a "high-tech" fence as a sophisticated, 21st-century way to help border patrol agents nab foreigners trying to sneak into the country--and supplement physical fences, which are also in the works. In 2006, it estimated that it would cost $7.6 billion to secure the entire 2,000-mile southern border. Critics, including Democrats in Congress, charge the effort has been wasteful and poorly executed so far, and civil libertarians have raised questions about privacy.

The decision to postpone completion of the first phase came after government auditors discovered numerous flaws in a 28-mile pilot of the border fence in Arizona. Known as "Project 28," the $20.6 million effort was supposed to have been operational last summer, but software integration issues stymied a timely launch.

In the past, other glitches--including lags in radar information displaying in command centers and newly deployed radars being activated by rain or other environmental factors--have made the system unusable, according to Government Accountability Office investigators. However, the GAO did note in its testimony Wednesday to Congress (PDF) that border security agents they interviewed say the current project provides "greater technological capabilities" than what they're accustomed to working with.

Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff said last week that the department had "accepted" the pilot, which he said means the agency will take elements of the prototype and apply them to other parts of its virtual fence plan. He also said the department plans to double the number of unmanned aerial vehicles policing the border. In a blog entry on Tuesday, Chertoff denied any allegations that the overall border security plan is facing setbacks or, as The Wall Street Journal called it in a weekend article, "mothballing."

"I've seen this system work with my own eyes, and I've talked with the Border Patrol Agents who are using it," Chertoff wrote. "They assure me that it adds value."

Recent posts from News Blog
Nvidia puts NForce chipset development on hold
Opera 10 browser is here
Neil Young Archives Blu-ray: Rip off?
Acronis revises survey results about backup habits
Acronis miscalculates data on users' bad backup habits
Flickr co-founder presses beta button
Comcast, Sony open retail store
Cox to try coaxing the Internet into submission
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (16 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
Time is critical we could put this fence up in 12 months
by Manhattan2 February 28, 2008 7:38 AM PST
We are working on systems that Mr. Chertoff should look into. The solution is simple. Any delay is a planned delay? see securityimages.com for a sample of what will be. This issue and that of our energy crisis need to be looked at in the form of a Manhattan Project. Thus, check out Manhattan2.com the answers are out there.
Reply to this comment
Worlds Top Superpower can't make a friggin fence?
by russkeller February 28, 2008 8:20 AM PST
You have got to be kidding me. Just use Barb wire and land mines.
Reply to this comment
Simple solution
by SeizeCTRL February 28, 2008 8:37 AM PST
put up a bunch of predator drones with machine guns and missiles, provide a free control program disguised as a game and let players pick off anyone stupid enough to cross over illegally.
Reply to this comment
Illegal Imigration
by azephyr February 28, 2008 9:17 AM PST
A 'fence' could easily be financed if we stopped this colossal fraud by NASA and their "Investigation of Space."

In the meantime, some EIGHT YEARS, the Democratic 'run' Legislators and Pres. Bush are purposefully allowing, and even enabling, multi millions of people to enter and stay in this country ILLEGALLY. CURRENT law allows deportation of all Thirty Million of them! What are we waiting for.....bankrupcy of the nation?

Illegals, FELONS BY DEFINITION INDER CURRENT LAW, are desroying every facet of our economy and society.

Wake-Up America!!!!!! Stop this invasion and occupation.
Reply to this comment
You propose THAT as our solution?
by jrm125 February 28, 2008 12:31 PM PST
Wow...crazy much. With all our wasted spending you propose cutting NASA to finance a fence to keep out illegals?

What's the matter with you? NASA is one of the few government funded projects that we can actually be proud of (most of the time). How about cutting military spending, or giving those Washington representatives a pay cut? After all, it's a government for the people, by the people, right?
Mexico, Canada....Canada, Mexico
by overroger February 28, 2008 10:07 AM PST
Shrub: you call it Dick, heads it's Cananda, tails it's Mexico.
Dick: here, use my special coin.
Reply to this comment
Why not hire illegals to build it?
by LuvThatCO2 February 28, 2008 11:07 AM PST
Appearently they're the only ones in this country who can get anything done.
Reply to this comment
Another Tortilla Curtain
by muttman February 28, 2008 11:49 AM PST
I live in El Paso. None of these big shots have ever come to the border to look and study the situation here. If the do come they fly over the border in a customs helicopter for about 10 minuets, and then have some Mexican food. There is no way that any FENCE of any kind that can keep people out of our country. It's been tried and it just won't work. Enforcement of the laws on the books will work. I feel sorry for our Border Patrol who busts their butts and is now being shot at from the other side of the border. They are putting their lives on the line every day to capture ilegales. Only to see them given amnesty a few years later. They are not able to do their true job of keeping smugglers and terrorists from our country
Reply to this comment
Virtual Fence
by ConservativeNotRepublican February 28, 2008 11:51 AM PST
Contractor could not deliver goods for cost agreed.
Recapture tax payer's money build a double fence with space between for border guards/vehicles first.

Then come back with virtual fence along with that. I bet there are "TONS" of American Contractors that are not favored by the Government that could do an awesome job building a physical fence in less than a year for total completion for a fraction of the cost originally thought.

Put Americans to work!

For Tunnels found being dug.

Plant poisionous bugs, spiders, and snakes then back fill the holes.

For every tunnel discovered by an American Citizen a bounty of $5,000.00 should be paid within two weeks (tax free).

Any American caught participating in smuggling of illegal immigrants should be declared NON American and not protected by our laws and should be deported with the illegal immigrant.

Companies that are found to be employing illegal immigrants should be fined so heavily the first time that if doubled the second time they are out of business.

Take care of Starving Americans before giving illegal immigrants anything.. period.
Reply to this comment
wow, some thought
by Dalkorian February 28, 2008 12:35 PM PST
ConservativeNotRepublican offered this thought:

"Any American caught participating in smuggling of illegal
immigrants should be declared NON American and not protected
by our laws and should be deported with the illegal immigrant.

Companies that are found to be employing illegal immigrants
should be fined so heavily the first time that if doubled the
second time they are out of business."

That would actually do something. This "border fence" idea is
just another distraction from fuhrer bush's total incompetence
combined with yet another plan to fleece as much $$$ out of
this country as possible. We're being raped by the White House
and yet people are falling into line, blaming all our problems on
illegal aliens. News flash people, this isn't a new problem and no
terrorist has ever made it into this country from our southern
border. Fact: the 9/11 terrorists got into this country legally
(and overstayed their visas). They didn't slip across either
border. Notice that means even if we had locked down both
borders years prior to 9/11 it would have still happened.

9/11 happened because fuhrer bushit allowed it to happen. He
knew about it well in advance and did nothing to prevent it
because it got the country all riled up and allowed him to start
an illegal war with Iraq for his oil buddies to profit from. You've
been scammed people.

Want to protect this country from terrorists? Impeach, imprison
and torture to death the entire bushit regime including all his
appointees and reverse all laws passed during it's reign. Press
the reset button and start over. Everything fuhrer bushit has
done over the last 8 years has put the U.S. in more peril than
we've been in at any time throughout our glorious history.

The most unpatriotic act I can think of today is to support fuhrer
bushit in any way. He needs to be executed for crimes against
humanity and our Constitution.
Three more years standing post on the border
by apacherat February 28, 2008 4:50 PM PST
The virtual fence won't be completed until 2011 !!!
Another three years I have to stand post on the border with the Minutemen doing the job our government refuses to do.

We all will be speaking Spanish by the time they complete the fence.
Reply to this comment
Virtual taxes
by wtortorici February 28, 2008 10:06 PM PST
When you file you tax return, pay the IRS with virtual money.

This latest attempt of the ICE is loaded with Bush's pork for the faithful. 3 Years guarantees that Boeing will still be getting fed money even after Bush.

The "Virtual Fence" will make the money spent on the "Big Dig" look like a little ditch.
Reply to this comment
Hmmmm, "Lags" in Radar data...
by ndustire February 29, 2008 12:22 AM PST
As a comm engineer that tells me some genius decided to do this with insufficient transmission bandwidth. That means the camera video and radar and sensor data will all try and rush thru too small a data pipe. I read comments about cameras having half the range they expected, probably in sand storms or rain too...While this project can be done, they are not going to like the costs of getting that bandwidth. Problems with microwave overshoot, not enough frequencies, electrical power, cooling , etc are going to give them heartburn. Probably just like the middle east, they want full motion video in color, with wifi maps to the patrolmen. It is going to give new meaning to taxation to do this.
Probably would be cheaper to give the illegal mexicans work permits, then hire them to guard the border and keep anyone not mexican out.
Reply to this comment
NASA US/MEXICO border satellite
by JamesKlich March 11, 2008 6:08 PM PDT
If you want to watch the border 24 hours a day why not use a US MEXICO border satelite. One or two satellites working 24 hours a day could send down the information in real time to border control agents. In areas where there may be a border fence we need to consider how this will affect endangered animals such as the Jaguar. I would try to involve the World Wildlife Fund.
Reply to this comment
Doomed
by borderstories April 8, 2008 9:47 PM PDT
If only foolishness provided security...

http://www.borderstories.org
Reply to this comment
by Violin_writer August 24, 2008 6:02 PM PDT
It is so simple to assume that this illegal imigrants are the cause to all of Americas problems. There perhaps more desperate global issues than a few Mexicans hoping the fence. Much of Mexico's problem is their corruption within their government... not only tdon't you have immigrants from many other third world south American countries comming through the Mexican border

The key in eliminating the threat of illegal immigrants is to make the INS more effecient.... not wasting hundreds upon hundreds of dollars on a fence that just gives the illegals a workout..
Reply to this comment
(16 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

Inside the Apple, er, Microsoft Store

Although Redmond's foray into retail bears a big resemblance to Apple's approach, Microsoft has added some distinctive features to draw casual PC buyers and techies alike.

Big marketing budget drives Moto Droid sales

Verizon and Motorola are spending big bucks--$100 million--on marketing the new smartphone, and it looks like it will pay off with 1 million devices sold by year's end.

About News Blog

Recent posts on technology, trends, and more.

Add this feed to your online news reader

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right