July 17, 2007 9:57 AM PDT

Is U.S. broadband access truly lagging?

An ever-popular lament among U.S. politicians and regulators in recent years is that the nation is falling behind its foreign counterparts in delivering widespread broadband access to its citizens.

For instance, the latest oft-quoted statistics compiled by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) ranked the United States 15th out of 30 as of last December, with 19.6 broadband subscribers per 100 inhabitants and more than 58 million total subscribers.

But a new paper (PDF) by a Washington think tank challenges the assertion that the United States is doing so poorly.

Unlike the OECD and the International Telecommunication Union, which rely on raw numbers of per capita broadband subscribers to derive their rankings, the Phoenix Center for Advanced Legal and Economic Public Policy Studies is proposing a new method that assigns a numerical score--they call it the "Broadband Performance Index"--to the relationship between broadband penetration and factors like broadband subscription prices and a population's income, education levels, age and density.

By that measure, "we find that the United States generally meets expectations in its conversion of its national endowments into broadband subscriptions," concluded co-authors Lawrence Spiwak, George Ford and Thomas Koutsky. The Phoenix Center bills itself as a non-partisan organization that "seeks to demonstrate that consumer welfare is best maximized by promoting free markets, competition, and individual freedom and liberty."

The group said it's not enough to look at broadband subscription rates in a vacuum. That's because "broadband adoption is not a race--broadband is instead a service purchased by households and businesses, and it is reasonable to expect that households and businesses in different societies with different conditions will make different purchasing decisions," the paper's authors argue.

By that logic, the report concluded that countries like Turkey and Portugal, which fall behind the United States in the OECD rankings, are actually making better use of what it calls "national endowments." Countries like Denmark and Norway, which top the United States on the OECD charts, are "underperforming" considering their demographic and economic realities, and nations such as Japan and Korea hailed as broadband "miracles" are really pretty average, the report said.

Their calculations determined age and income are the two most significant factors influencing broadband subscription levels. Overall, Finland, Iceland and Portugal were the best at "transforming their nation's endowments into broadband subscriptions," while New Zealand, the Czech Republic, the Slovak Republic, Luxembourg, Ireland and Greece were the worst, the report said.

The findings aren't meant to suggest that broadband penetration in the United States need not be improved, the group wrote, but to suggest that "the typical rhetoric surrounding broadband rankings can be misleading and misguided."

Recent posts from News Blog
Sprint HTC Touch Diamond outed early
Woman to virtual ex: 'I won't be ignored!'
Swiss secret sauce to power green choppers
iLink to deliver answers to military online communities
Vonage names new CEO
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 15 comments
Make it available and I'll do it!
by morningowl July 17, 2007 11:03 AM PDT
Regardless of how remote your town is, if the service is available one town over, it should be available in your town too!

After working a contract job for a broadband provider, I found one thing that disturbs me. All they want is money and return on investment. They do not care that a whole town is not on their broadband availability list. There is no social responsibility at all. If it doesn't pay, the public cannot play. Well you can play, but sell your house and move if you want broadband!

I'll just stay disconnected.
Reply to this comment View all 2 replies
Urbanization & climate
by InklingBooks July 17, 2007 1:54 PM PDT
To add a sane comment to what mostly seems to be childish
ranting, note that the researchers should have also taken into
account urbanization. Densely populated, the Netherlands is
more easily wired for broadband and a less densely populated,
rural and small town US. In much of the US, houses can be 1/2
mile or more apart.

There's also the social factor. Given their long & dark winters, I'd
expect Icelanders to be more inclined to get broadband than
someone in Florida, where even the winter doesn't force you
indoors.
Reply to this comment
Broadband Access Truly Lagging
by Paninteas July 17, 2007 3:39 PM PDT
In a simple term, Yes!
When I Lived in Van Nuys California our area was one of the last to get Cable Broadband, we were one of the first to get DSL. 128K up 384k down 5 years have past. DSL hasn't improved since we happen to be at the end of the line. In the Middle of a 50 year old tract of WW2 Homes. Cable has improved they upgraded.
I now live in a small farming "village" not town in central Illinois. No broadband except satalite,
(expensive slow) or cell phone (expensive slow).
while towns a little larger than ours have had 5-10 generations of improvement. The school children in nigeria either have or soon will have better broadband access than we do here. Cable is still analog in this area. No broadband. Do it ourselves? $1600 a month for a 1.5 kps connection. 12 Miles away 1.5 kps connection 29.95. something is wrong same telephone company same cable company. The fiber runs through town to the school but no way for the locals to access it. AT&T will allow us access when they get around to it. I happen to live at the end of the line again.
Reply to this comment
Again, blame the corporate game
by tanis143 July 17, 2007 10:01 PM PDT
Ok, STOP YOUR WHINING! Living in a more populated area has its advantages, one of them is broadband. You have wal-mart, we have malls and super wal-marts. You have 28.8 dialup, we have broadband. Its that simple.

You can not expect to force the cable and phone companies to shell out all the money for fiber for a town that only has 10,000 ppl when they can get 30 times that amount from a population of 400k to 600k.

Basically those that complain that rural area's do not have broadband are better off complaining that they do not have a Parks 5th Avenue store instead.
Reply to this comment View reply
Finall some Logic
by Entouchable July 18, 2007 5:41 PM PDT
It's nice to see an unbiased study come out that does its best to include as many factors as possible rather than laying down a general blanket statement across all areas regardless of how illogical it is. This Phoenix group even seems to have some good goals to get behind, I love it.

With that said, regardless of how "on track" we are, as stated before, we should AT LEAST have top rated high speed access (50-100mbps)in our biggest metroplitan areas, where it's easy to feed the major populated areas with sufficient fiber. We arn't even seeing this.

And all of this from companies that were supposedly given hundreds of millions, if not billions of dollars to upgrade the nation's Internet infrastructure.
Reply to this comment
look at the numbers
by m00nj0ck July 20, 2007 1:03 PM PDT
check out some of the numbers here. notice that in most countries your average rate (if you take average speed and multiply times cost per MB) is between $20-$30 dollars. Also, the countries that are doing the best, with the highest speeds/lowest costs, are smaller, densely populated countries. Another fact to take into consideration is that while only 51% of the us is using broadband, that is over 80% of internet users. Lastly, in many countries the expansion of broadband availability/speed has been driven/regulated by thier governments, and until we get that kind of support, we'll continue on our current path of high mediocrity.
Reply to this comment View reply
Powered by Jive Software
advertisement

Latest tech news headlines

About News Blog

Recent posts on technology, trends, and more.

Add this feed to your online news reader

News Blog topics

Featured blogs

advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right
  • News - Business Tech

    Chrome's JavaScript challenge to Silverlight

    The advent of Google's Chrome browser, software pros say, should spur a big speedup for JavaScript, which would raise its standing against Microsoft's Silverlight technology.

  • Gallery

    Photos: Top 10 reviews of the week

    Here are CNET Reviews' 10 favorite items from the past week, including the TiVo HD XL, Sony Cyber-shot DSC-H50, and the Dish Network's newest digital TV converter box.

  • News - Apple

    Apple watchers spot 'iPod Nano' pix, iTunes hints

    The rumor mill has long been predicting a longer, leaner new version of the iPod Nano, and now it's conjuring up some pictures.

  • Coop's Corner

    Chris Shipley 1, Internet lynch mob 0

    Demo's impresario goes public with a tart and smartly written riposte to the shoot-from-the-lip crowd.

  • Video

    Katie Couric reflects on first Webcast

    The political conventions are over and so are CBS Evening News anchor Katie Couric's first series of Webcasts. CNET's Kara Tsuboi sat down with Couric on the final night of the Republican National Convention to discuss what she liked about Webcasting, some of her most memorable guests, and whether TV news will still be around by the next round of conventions.

  • News - Digital Media

    Google-focused satellite enters orbit

    The search titan has exclusive rights among online mapping sites to images from the new GeoEye-1 satellite, which launched Saturday.

  • Video

    YouTube plays party politics

    During the presidential campaigning four years ago, YouTube didn't even exist. Now it's a tool candidates must master to get their message across. CNET's Kara Tsuboi stops by the YouTube upload booths at the Democratic and Republican conventions to find out why Google's video site has such a big presence in Denver and St. Paul, Minn.

  • News - Gaming and Culture

    Are Demo and TechCrunch50 fragmenting their audiences?

    With both events scheduled to start Monday, many press, as well as venture capitalists and others are having to choose which one to attend.

  • News - Cutting Edge

    Execs predict next Google-like tech

    On eve of company's 10-year anniversary, researchers and business pundits speculate about what technologies might someday have as much impact as Google.

  • Gallery

    Images: The art of 'Spore' prototypes

    Will Wright and his Maxis team worked on dozens of prototypes to test the elements of their soon-to-be-released evolution game. Here's a sampling.

  • Webware

    At the TechCrunch50, an unfair advantage?

    Inside baseball: How Webware and other blogs can compete with TechCrunch in covering the TechCrunch50 event.

  • Green Tech

    Duke Energy to invest in mini solar power plants

    Can hundreds of rooftop solar panels collectively operate like a central power plant? Duke Energy launches $100 million distributed solar program to find out.