• On The Insider: Judge Bans Real Housewives Sex Tape
July 12, 2007 10:03 AM PDT

Sony BMG sues CD vendor over rootkits

by Robert Vamosi

Sony BMG Music Entertainment is suing an antipiracy CD software company claiming that the technology provided was flawed. In November 2005, researcher Mark Russinovich discovered hidden files left behind on computers when certain Sony copy-protected CDs were played. The subsequent consumer complaints and government investigations, says Sony, cost the entertainment company millions of dollars in losses.

Now Sony BMG has filed a complaint against The Amergence Group, formerly SunnComm International, a company that produced the piracy-protection system known as MediaMax CD. According to the Associated Press, Sony BMG is seeking $12 million in damages for unfair business practices and for breaching the terms of its license agreement.

The Amergence Group told the Associated Press it would fight the allegations and suggested that lawsuits against Sony BMG's use of copy-protected software involved Sony's use of other technologies.

As CNET's resident security expert, Robert Vamosi has been interviewed on the BBC, CNN, MSNBC, and other outlets to share his knowledge about the latest online threats and to offer advice on personal and corporate security. Listen to his podcast at securitybites.cnet.com or e-mail Robert with your questions and comments.
Recent posts from News Blog
Neil Young Archives Blu-ray: Rip off?
Acronis revises survey results about backup habits
Acronis miscalculates data on users' bad backup habits
Flickr co-founder presses beta button
Comcast, Sony open retail store
Cox to try coaxing the Internet into submission
Was InfoWorld's CTO of the Year award a year late?
VMWare VI4 renamed to vSphere
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (7 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
Freudian Slap? ... er ... Slip?
by lampietheclown July 12, 2007 11:00 AM PDT
This must be meant as humor.
"Sony BMG Music Entertainment is suing an antiprivacy CD
software company"

Antiprivacy is more correct than anti-piracy, and more
humorous.

To the other extreme, Mr Vamosi wrote;
"SunnComm International, a company that produced the
privacy-protection system known as MediaMax CD."

Privacy-protection?

I'd guess that the only way Sony will win is if they can prove that
they didn't know the software was flawed before putting it onto
millions of CDs.
They knew what it was, They knew what it did. They just didn't
know it was a flaw, until it was pointed out to them by the
California and Texas AGs.


Lampie The Clown
Reply to this comment
Sony is suing because they got caught!
by mike.gw July 12, 2007 11:34 AM PDT
Some nerve. I can hear the execs on the conference call now: "You said this software was UNDETECTABLE, so how come we got caught?"

The CD vendor must have promised BALCO like stealth software! LOL!
Reply to this comment
False accusations
by Arcond July 12, 2007 12:32 PM PDT
I'm actually very good friends with the lead developer that developed the software for SunnComm. The thing is, the rootkit they're suing over was developed and distributed by another company known as First4Internet. But because of the outrage from people hearing the news they never bothered to see if it was one company or all. So any company that Sony used for DRM is now getting sued. My good friend who developed SunnComm's software already had his code reveiwed in court and was exonerated over a year ago.
Reply to this comment
True but still no basis for a suit
by Arcond July 20, 2007 10:26 AM PDT
Yes it is true that the software would install even if you clicked no to the EULA, however it begs the question, why? The answer is because if the end-user clicks no it was still possible to rip the songs off the CD at that point since the DRM software would not be installed. If SunnComm hadn't done what they did then there would be no true DRM and Sony would have every right to sue them for not delivering a viable DRM solution. As it stands, yes the software is installed no matter what, but the MediaMax software was a solid platform which could not be exploited by hackers. Again the actual code in question was reviewed by the Texas Attourney General's office and the code was cleared of charges and the developer exonerated over a year ago when all this first hit the news.
Reply to this comment
(7 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

Can RIM get its mojo back?

The new BlackBerry Tour, carried by Verizon and Sprint, arrives Sunday, even as RIM seems to be losing sales to exclusive devices like the iPhone and Pre.

With Chrome, Google reignites the OS wars

roundup Google Chrome OS, due in 2010, underscores the Web giant's cloud-computing ambitions and opens new competition with Microsoft.
• What Chrome OS has on Windows that Linux doesn't

About News Blog

Recent posts on technology, trends, and more.

Add this feed to your online news reader

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right