Why one Mac owner might go back to Windows

To many Macintosh owners, it is anathema even to suggest that Apple computers are anything but vastly superior to Windows PCs. But that is exactly what one of them is saying--and he's so disenchanted that he might switch back to a Microsoft machine.

Normally, such blasphemous talk might be easily dismissed for its inanity, insanity or both. But the comments have generated particular controversy because Russell Beattie, an experienced software developer who works for Yahoo, has never been known as a booster for Windows. In a list of 33 complaints, he begins with this entry: "Anyone who says that Macs are more stable than Windows are smoking dope. I have two brand new Macs and they regularly go wacky and need reboots."

Beattie has received so much response that some bloggers are running excerpts of the many retorts.

Blog community response:

"The majority of Russell's complaints have primarily to do with his dislike of applications. So Russell, if you prefer Windoze, then by all means, go and do it--switch back. But don't go trying to turn your preferences into computing axioms."
--LameZone

"While I don't plan to switch back, I share a lot of his frustrations...I can't repeat enough times how frustrating the inconsistent interface is to me, or how much it sucks that my nearly $4000 top-of-the-line Mac laptop chokes on portions of Dungeon Seige--a game that's been out for FIVE YEARS--can't run Doom 3 at all."
--ditto

"Russell Beattie pulls the standard old blog trick. Tells the world that he's thinking of switching away from his Mac and back to Windows. That always generates lots of traffic and gets lots of links. Me? I can't buy this kind of publicity."
--Scobleizer

[icarus441]

Russell.... Come on, I've used PC from windows 95 through to XP and lately some Vista then gladly made the switch last year to MAC. The claim "Anyone who says that Macs are more stable than Windows are smoking dope. I have two brand new Macs and they regularly go wacky and need reboots." is a lie. I couldn't even ball park the number of times my PC's have froze/crashed or just plain stopped working. This is due to the build of the Operation system, (DOS), being inferior to the Unix based OS the MAC has been producing for the last few years. You work for yahoo, you have an obvious personal bias toward PC, and your complains are misdirected. You are mad about application variety and that's understandable. But you switched to MAC for a reason so Windows apparently wasn't giving you what you wanted, so I say don't chose... Use the best of both worlds..... MAC with Bootcamp... you can have your fill of a terrible OS(which has run smoother in bootcamp then on any PC) , and play your mass market games(thats for you Ditto) and then switch back to a OS that doesn't need a firewall or virus protection ....... cause its clearly better...

[AntonioZero]

Hmm well Iarcus is certainly an idiot...
I have to year old PC's I have had one freee, zero crashes.Myabe a mac is perfecy for you, you dont know how to run a computer beyond the most basic tasks.. For all PC users put disk defragmant and virus scan in your scheduled tasks. You will never have another problem. And by the way, any apple software ran on a pc Sucks, I-tues for example is the biggest heaping pile ive ever scene. If you consider downloading it you are only wasting memory and time.