• On TechRepublic: 2 humane ways to fire someone
June 13, 2009 11:51 AM PDT

The day after the DTV transition

by Marguerite Reardon
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 45 comments

Americans have survived the transition to digital television without incident.

The sky did not fall and there was no major shortage of digital converter boxes Friday when full-power broadcasters across the nation turned off their analog TV signals and started broadcasting only in digital. Calls to broadcasters and the Federal Communications Commission have been heavy the past few days, but officials say that the volume is within what the agency had expected.

"The digital TV transition is looking more like Y2K than the Bay of Pigs," Commissioner Jonathan Adelstein said during a press conference on Saturday.

While the agency is quick to say that there is still work to be done in helping stragglers get over the air signals, it's clear commissioners were relieved and pleased with how smoothly the transition of some 971 stations to all digital broadcast went throughout the country on Friday.

Officials said Saturday that more than 317,000 consumer calls were made to the FCC on Friday, the highest number of calls the agency has ever had in one day. But the agency was prepared with call centers staffed 24 hours a day with a total of 4,000 live operators to answer questions. Even though call wait times were higher during peak periods, on average consumers had to wait less than five minutes for their call to be answered.

The largest volume of calls came from broadcast markets serving major cities, most notably Chicago, Dallas-Fort Worth, New York, Philadelphia, and Baltimore.

The FCC's Web site also got a lot of activity on Friday with more than 3.1 million page views on the www.dtv,gov site. This is more page views than the site had in all of May.

About 30 percent of the calls to the FCC call centers concerned the operation of digital boxes, the agency said. And most of those calls were resolved were instructed to "re-scan" converter boxes in order to receive the digital channels that had moved to new frequencies. More than 20 percent of the calls handled by live agents dealt with reception issues.

FCC officials said that it was hard to say exactly how many people were not prepared when the switch happened and how many are still without over-the-air broadcast TV. But according to the latest Nielsen survey conducted before the June 12 deadline, less than 3 million households across the nation were unprepared. This figure was at least half of what it had been in February.

Retailers across the country were well-stocked with digital converter boxes for last-minute shoppers, which alleviated any concerns government officials had about equipment shortages. But the agency noted that in some locations antennas were in short supply. The FCC is suggesting that consumers look online if they are unable to get an antenna from a local retailer this weekend.

Even though there was no major catastrophe or mass out-cry from the public over the switch to digital TV, acting FCC Chairman Michael Copps said the agency's work is still not complete. He said that the FCC is continuing its grassroots efforts to ensure consumers, who still aren't getting over the air TV are not left behind. He used a baseball analogy to describe where he feels the agency is right now in the transition.

"We are safe on third right now," he said. "But I'm not going to close the books on the transition or declare a home run until we solve all the consumer problems."

Still, he also pointed out that there are likely far fewer unprepared viewers now than there would have been had broadcasters switched to digital on the original February 17 deadline. Fearing that consumers were not ready for the transition early this year, Congress voted to delay the mandated transition to June 12.

Since then FCC has thrown its efforts into overdrive, working with volunteers from the public and private sector to educate consumers and provide out reach programs to install digital converter boxes for consumers.

Copps expressed his pride for the efforts of his staff and the massive coordination among the different groups working to make the DTV transition smooth.

"We turned this little regulatory agency on the Potomac into a real grass roots organization," he said.

Copps and the other FCC commissioners said that "search and rescue" efforts will continue to find and help individuals who have been left behind in this transition. FCC volunteers along with volunteers from other groups, such as AmeriCorps, are on the ground manning walk-in centers where people still needing help can go to get help. These folks are also going to door-to-door in at-risk communities to make sure that people are able to get over-the-air TV.

Broadcasters will also continue to turn up the power on their transmitters, which could help some consumers receive TV signals that they might not have been able to get previously.

Marguerite Reardon has been a CNET News reporter since 2004, covering cell phone services, broadband, citywide Wi-Fi, the Net neutrality debate, as well as the ongoing consolidation of the phone companies. E-mail Maggie.
advertisement
 
Business supplies and services can get expensive. Get smart spending tips and learn about new cost-saving opportunities for your business
Recent posts from Wireless
Windows Mobile loses nearly a third of market share
Ricky Gervais helps reveal pain of cell phone salesmen
AT&T: Verizon ads are 'blatantly false'
HTC expects rough fourth quarter
Dell unveils Android-based Mini 3 smartphone
Qualcomm readies 3G/4G mobile chipsets
Report: Motorola looks to sell set-top box biz
Powering cell phone towers with wind
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 2 pages (45 Comments)
by jjayguy23 June 13, 2009 12:43 PM PDT
Wow that is really cool. Hopefully a lot of good will come from this.
Reply to this comment
by rdupuy11 June 15, 2009 7:45 AM PDT
just an aside, but I was one of the 'prepared'--I had satellite tv. But I use it to get only off-the-air channels and one russian language channel. I got interested in this digital transition, so I ordered a digital tuner (had a digital monitor already, simply lacked a tuner).

Wow, it really looked good in my area, so I cancelled the satellite tv. After all these years, I'm back to broadcast reception!

The one russian channel I was getting, is replaced now by dozen's of russian channels, because I'm just getting those from the internet at an even lower cost.

Yeah, the combination of Off-the-air digital and the internet, is quite compelling...very pleased here with the digital transition.

I'm not happy with $40 coupons that drove the price of a $25 converter box to $50, so that after taxes are added, the consumer paid about $15 out of pockets instead of $27.50, and the largest part of the program just padded Wal-marts bottom line.

Typical insanity with government programs....but the overall move to digital broadcast, just a great technology.
by RoC1909 June 13, 2009 12:46 PM PDT
I continually have less faith in the intelligence of American citizens every single day. This transition has ONLY been known for the last 7+ years and HEAVILY advertised the last two. What is so F'in hard to realize that if a person's television set is not hooked up to a cable provider, it IS NOT going to be compatible UNTIL the person gets a converter box??? And WHY does TAXPAYER MONEY need to be spent on this FCC "search and rescue" crap? Television is STILL considered a luxury the last time I looked. If the remaining MILLION are STILL having issues.....good riddance!

Thank god I wasn't manning the help desk phones. I would have called just about every caller a moron!
Reply to this comment
by odubtaig June 13, 2009 2:14 PM PDT
Even morons pay taxes and vote.

Just remember, average intelligence is just that, the average.
by ewsachse June 13, 2009 6:03 PM PDT
Silly moron.

The government sold of the frequencies of the old analog TV spectrum and made a huge profit on it. They funded the coupon program with that money.

It did not cost the taxpayers anything.

Think before you post.
by jaguar717 June 13, 2009 6:09 PM PDT
You obviously weren't paying attention to that whole election thing. TV isn't a luxury. You are Entitled (unless you work for a living).

Hi-def TV, Blu-Ray, broadband, two cars, air conditioning, and a new phone with unlimited "texts" are all Entitlements now, whether you get up before noon or not.
by zizzybaloobah June 13, 2009 9:08 PM PDT
@ewsachse: The govt indeed made a huge profit auctioning the analog TV spectrum. 'Huge' is probably an understatement. Nobody should have paid anything at all for a converter box, as well as the new antennas many needed to go with those new boxes. And the government still would have plenty of auction money left over to waste on earmarks and pet projects.

The politicians pulled a fast one on the tax payers (as they usually do).
by rllaw June 13, 2009 9:25 PM PDT
government made a profit...somebody remind me again why the government "owns" wavelengths...
by fletchb June 13, 2009 11:44 PM PDT
The Gov sold off our (public) airwaves to private corporations. They should have to pay us for that lost of public bandwidth.
by gerrrg June 14, 2009 4:12 AM PDT
There is always someone smarter than you.
by ITcomposer June 13, 2009 1:27 PM PDT
Is that in Los Angeles?, or Will all of this make jack benny come back? Hehehe, yea America if you waited till the last second, its your fault, amen to the last comenter, why should i pay to have someone watch tv, why not give me those $40, i could put them to good use, what a waste of tax payer money!
Reply to this comment
by epcraig June 13, 2009 1:29 PM PDT
So rural viewers are OK?
I saw lots of criticism on DKOS among other blogs. Apparently even the best antennas don't help outside most urban areas, best hope you can move into town if you need TV.
Reply to this comment
by julie7789 June 21, 2009 6:21 PM PDT
Rural viewers are not OK. Talk about being screwed. Rural viewers who went dutifully out and bought converter boxes or, even worse, new ($$$) digital TVs have no signals. (OK, I have three signals [I know the box works] a Re-run station which comes in great, a Spanish language station and a shopping channel) I am less than 30 miles from Seattle but there is a "hill" in the way of all of the network signals. This has happened everywhere around the country. All of those annoying commercials never mentioned this as a possibility. The local CBS station ran many tests and went on and on and on about being prepared but NEVER did they say to check the FCC coverage map.

Of course, many commenters may say, "you should have known" to do this. I am well informed, computer literate and did not think to do this. I would like to know how many thousands of people were conned into these purchases and now have converter boxes to donate. Oh that's right, no point in giving them away here. They're unusable.
by bildan2 June 13, 2009 1:46 PM PDT
The change in picture quality didn't seem to change the programming content - same old crap. Tell me, why is digital TV important?
Reply to this comment
by Hunnter2k3 June 13, 2009 3:00 PM PDT
It is to free up the spectrum that analog currently used.
This can be used for much more better things, such as wireless broadband, or specialised broadcasts for things like emergencies or whatever.

They have been auctioning off sections of the spectrum for a couple years if i remember correct.
by Seaspray0 June 14, 2009 6:22 AM PDT
Now if they could only get those commercials to quit playing at 3 times the volume as the program.
by mrsly69 June 13, 2009 2:03 PM PDT
Are we Americans that stupid? Come on, you had 3 years to get ready. Don't give me the excuse that people are confused. They are idiots. Maybe it is time to legalize euthanasia. That is why taxes are so high.... There are just too many dumb people in this country. God help us all. We keep electing dumb people that just want to live off the governement. Time has come for change. Maybe it is a good thing they can't watch tv. Maybe they will read a book or go back to school.
Reply to this comment
by rklrkl June 13, 2009 2:06 PM PDT
Here in the UK, we've been looking on at this with some bemusement. Giving every citizen a $40 voucher - paid for by the US taxpayer - to buy a luxury item (that's right folks, TV is an optional non-essential item in households) had us UK folks scratching our heads, especially when we've had to buy our own digital set-top boxes for the past decade or so (and are now so ubiquitous that they are only around 20 pounds now - yes, less than $35).

In the UK, the analogue switch-off has indeed begun, but at a much slower rate than the "big bang" the US has just had. We're switching it off region by region and won't be completed until 2012 (which you suspect is just in time for the London Olympics!). The biggest disappointment of the UK switch-over isn't the digital aspect, but actually that we're not phasing in HD as the analogue channels are turned off.

Sadly, HD Freeview (HD terrestrial digital) is still in its trial phase and, yep, will require us Brits to throw away all our SD set-top digital boxes and buy a whole load of new ones (or replace the SD IDTV with an HD IDTV equivalent). This is something the UK broadcasters, government and all the retailers have been keeping extremely quiet about. Most of the UK public simply don't know that their shiny new "HD ready" LCD TV isn't such a thing at all - not one LCD TV in the UK has an HD Freeview tuner built in yet (trial phase remember?) and there's going to be a lot of disgruntled people in a few years time when HD Freeview renders their TV's digital tuner (partially) obsolete.
Reply to this comment
by odubtaig June 13, 2009 2:22 PM PDT
It's either that or FreeSat (run through Sky's satellites), which is the only way a lot of people are going to get a clear signal without subscribing to Cable/Satellite. Near Coventry the signal's clean for most of the time (excepting heavy rain and wind) but in Sheffield with its seven hills it can only be described as abominable. I await the promised improvement in signal with the switchover (more bandwidth freed up) with interest and no small amount of skepticism.

Of course, this being britain it'll probably run 3x over budget come five years late and deliver on one tenth of the promises after it turns out the contract was given to some politician's best mate and not the best people for the job.
by MagiMamoru June 13, 2009 3:21 PM PDT
Working retail at a big box store in electronics has been very enlightening. Most of my customers who don't understand whats going are the elderly. Its very rare for someone under the age of 60 have an actual question.

As to the question of luxury. Yes and no. The area I live in no longer has a local radio station and during the spring we face inclement weather. Thunder Storms, and Tornados. The so called weather radios can only go so far. The local news stations are good about covering bad weather in my area, so the TV becomes a very important information tool. The question of of luxury is mote at this point.

I can be woken up by the weather sirens, (recycled air raid sirens from WWII), look at the weather radar on the TV and deicde if I need to head for shelter or go back to bed at 2 o'clock in the morning. The sirens cover 434 square miles. (1,124 sq km for those snots who can't stand the fact that some of use prefer to stick with what we grew up with, and the local population uses. Truth be known I tell the local populace how tall I am in the metric system just to tick them off. 2.03 m.)

Ouch, two levels of phasing in equipment? I feel sorry for my retailing counter parts on the other side of the ocean.
by dfevans-1 June 14, 2009 4:29 PM PDT
Remind us again about UK and the annual tv tax/license you have to buy to watch anything?
by love00001111 June 13, 2009 2:13 PM PDT
well i was prepared but i watch the tv all since all day and i thought the were going beat this to death just like the y2k and bank failures and the bad economy. well maybe in the east cost but defiantly not were i am,

and by the way for the person saying waiting tax payer money as much as i hate the government and I'm moving back home anyway. listen to this, if the coupons were expired and never reused the it doesn't wasted, because like a prepaid product any remaining unused money on the card if its the $40 coupon or any prepaid card the money goes back on the computer system that's why they have expire dates so the money isn't thrown away. the $40 card is exactly the same as a gift card or a prepaid phone card in this case they just gave it to use for free and it was a basically a gift card strictly for the parches of a ATSC tuner box. and this is so stupid it forced me to pay stupid as 9.25% sales tax to buy the dam thing
Reply to this comment
by love00001111 June 13, 2009 2:19 PM PDT
most south east asin countries use usa format ntsc going to atsc, so the southeast asain counties will off in 2011-2012, the olymic is wold wide view and, will efect fans of it there, who know if the will even get a chance to get coupons wehn there time comes, onther resan it so stupid this switch and may only get to get DTV at the best, might not even have HDTV
Reply to this comment
by MagiMamoru June 13, 2009 3:24 PM PDT
Ok, just a bit of fun here. I hope no one loses any sleep. :-)

Has anyone broadcast the schematics to digital tuners so aliens can watch our cast off programing thousand of years from now?
Reply to this comment
by Seaspray0 June 14, 2009 6:26 AM PDT
I hope not. They get a bad enough impression of us from what they've already seen.
by licht1 June 13, 2009 3:24 PM PDT
The DTV transition is no trouble at all if your cables are correctly bipolarized. Go to Screen 47 of the DTV Converter Box On-Screen Installation Guide and use the resident GPS to correctly align your antenna for each channel, allowing for local ionospheric conditions, and ARRRGGGHH!

Technical reference:

http://notionscapital.wordpress.com/2009/06/12/tv-d-day-usa


---
DTV Transition is a snap
Reply to this comment
by Capn Jon June 13, 2009 5:18 PM PDT
Let's be honest here, the public is really getting screwed, especially those of us in the outlying areas. All of a sudden, an antenna that worked fairly well, is now a worthless piece of scrap, and we need to spend a couple of hundred on a new one. Just what programing on national TV is worth that cost? Why isn't the FCC buying and installing those antennas for us? Or better yet, why is the government making rules at all? They can't run the country, and they sure can't run the airwaves!
Reply to this comment
by marcusjames June 13, 2009 6:31 PM PDT
Why do you need a new antenna? Your current one should pick up the DTV (and HD) fine. You just need a converter box if you have an analog TV.
by marcusjames June 13, 2009 6:37 PM PDT
A little more info: http://www.hdtvantennalabs.com/hdtv-antenna-hype.php (note, I don't really know anything about this site -- just came up near the top of a search).
by CommanderLogjam June 13, 2009 7:41 PM PDT
marcusjames,

The UHF signal of DTV is considerably weaker than the old VHF analog signal. If you live in an outlying area it is very likely you will need to have an amplified antenna or maybe even a rooftop antenna where your old analog TV worked fine with a coat hanger and aluminum foil.
by bob1xxxx June 14, 2009 1:53 AM PDT
Honestly you dont need a super expensive antenna I got my folks a 50.00 rat shack roof mounted antenna it works great. You got to follow the instruction and point it correct direction of you tv source. But dont belive the crap you need 400.00 one.
by jerryimax4 June 13, 2009 7:49 PM PDT
Everything went soothly on Friday at 12:30pm during the transition, so I forgot about it and went out to eat. When I came back my favorite stations dissapeared.
I rescanned several times and; nothing happened.
So I spent most of Saturday moving the outside antenna around useing a. compass.
Finally during the 9th inning of the baseball game I missed, I got my signal back.
The solution was moving the antenna, which is 25 feet in the air, 6 inches further to the south. .
Same tower different frequency, 22 miles away. HDTV at 91 percent on all channels. Raleigh, N.C. has them all grouped together. I get 18 local channels now.
It was like trying to shoot at a bird a mile away with a BB gun.
Reply to this comment
by dcmichie June 13, 2009 10:52 PM PDT
"Finally during the 9th inning of the baseball game I missed, I got my signal back. "

Should have got the directv HD Sports package, you'll never miss a game!
by gerrrg June 14, 2009 4:14 AM PDT
Most stations here haven't yet turned off their analog. Weird how that works, eh? I thought they were supposed to turn off their analog signals, but I can see through snow, half a dozen signals coming through.
Reply to this comment
by Hords June 14, 2009 10:29 AM PDT
Same here. Only one local station has made the switch so far. I'm in a smaller city and all the channels are actually from a bigger city, about 30 miles away. I called one of them up and they told me that had no deadline to switch their outlying translators to digital, but they had to switch their main one. Doesn't seem right to me, but that was what the engineer told me. It has been very confusing because they said on the channels that the switch was happening, but then they only switch it in some areas (this was all done back in February, on the original analog to digital cutover date.)
by dennisl59 June 14, 2009 5:37 AM PDT
"The digital TV transition is looking more like Y2K than the Bay of Pigs," Commissioner Jonathan Adelstein said during a press conference on Saturday.

As usual a Washington Flunkie makes a reference to a event beyond the knowledge of the regular citizen. The "Bay of Pigs" was an invasion, sponsored by the US Government, of the island of Cuba in April 1961. It failed because JFK withdrew air support at the last minute. Result?...Castro continues to be the Communist Dictator.

So what the "F" is this IDIOT, MORON and FOOL doing comparing Y2K with the Bay of Pigs? Here's your Federal Government Citizens and the people that work for it. Good Luck Slaves!!! And remember to take your Soma and turn up the Prolofeed.
Reply to this comment
by licht1 June 14, 2009 7:05 AM PDT
The DTV transition is no trouble at all if your cables are correctly bipolarized. Go to Screen 47 of the DTV Converter Box On-Screen Installation Guide and use the resident GPS to correctly align your antenna for each channel (allowing for local ionospheric conditions) and ARRRGGGHH!

Technical reference:

http://notionscapital.wordpress.com/2009/06/12/tv-d-day-usa/
Reply to this comment
by dennisl59 June 14, 2009 9:55 AM PDT
I also recommend that all users dip their cables into grain alcohol but only the yellow ones, for god's sake, don't dip the blue ones. Then toss your TV into the Trash for recycling in China. And use your "hand crank" radio to watch TV
by taxiguy250 June 14, 2009 12:04 PM PDT
I wonder how many of the people who can't figure this out have a cell phone? Or is a phone with no wires just too confusing ("But how does it work? It must be Magic")?
How many hitch up Old Bessie to the sulky to go into town because they don't like the looks of that ********** Carriage?

Wake up people, the world is passing you by. The only thing that is constant is change. Get used to it.
Reply to this comment
by taxiguy250 June 14, 2009 12:05 PM PDT
I wonder how many of the people who can't figure this out have a cell phone? Or is a phone with no wires just too confusing ("But how does it work? It must be Magic")?
How many hitch up Old Bessie to the sulky to go into town because they don't like the looks of that Horseless Carriage?

Wake up people, the world is passing you by. The only thing that is constant is change. Get used to it.
Reply to this comment
by dennisl59 June 14, 2009 5:42 PM PDT
Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.
Arthur C. Clarke
by weegg June 15, 2009 6:31 AM PDT
Oh wonderful the joys of DTV. I now get Thai, Korean, Chinese, Armenian, Spanish channels. So much for increased channels....sigh
Reply to this comment
by BtmnHatesRbn June 15, 2009 6:56 AM PDT
Here's what happened in the Las Vegas area:

My step-father bought an HDTV with a new "digital" antenna. It only gets, after the "switch", the analog signal from KVVU Ch. 5, and nothing else. He also bought two converter boxes...well, using the two coupons, he just took 'em more or less, as it cost him nothing afterwards. Both are different brands. The generic, bought-at-a-grocery-store brand he's using on a 31-year-old Fisher TV works just fine, and picks up all of the channels except KTNV's digital output. The one upstairs picks up nothing. He even went ahead and bought an expensive "digital" antenna for it and still nothing. The box was fine before the switch. This box is made by Memorex. I live outside of Las Vegas, in the middle of the desert. The hell if I know if I get any channels. I have cable!
Reply to this comment
Showing 1 of 2 pages (45 Comments)
advertisement

A CNET Conversation with Eric Schmidt

CNET's Tom Krazit and Molly Wood sit down with Google CEO Eric Schmidt to discuss the future of Android, the Chrome OS, the problem of real-time search indexing, and more.

Verizon tests sending RIAA copyright notices

The No. 2 phone company, known for its reluctance to intervene in antipiracy cases, strikes an agreement to forward copyright notices on behalf of the music industry.

About Wireless

Check out the latest wireless news on CNET News, featuring the latest news on cell phones, mobile gear, VOIP, and internet access via broadband and wireless connections.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Wireless topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right