• On GameFAQs: Is it OK to lay my Wii down on its side?
April 10, 2009 2:26 PM PDT

AT&T increases bounty on fiber vandals to $250K

by Marguerite Reardon

AT&T has increased its reward to $250,000 for information that will help law enforcement arrest and convict vandals who cut the company's fiber-optic cables in San Jose, Calif., on Thursday, the company said in its Twitter feed.

On Thursday, AT&T said it would offer a $100,000 reward for anyone who has information that could lead to the arrest or conviction of anyone involved in cutting the fiber.

Thousands of wireless, Internet, and landline phone customers were without service beginning at about 1:30 a.m. PDT on Thursday after vandals had cut four fiber-optic cables owned by AT&T. A cable in San Carlos, Calif., owned by Sprint Nextel, had also been severed about two later. But Sprint spokeswoman Crystal Davis said the company was able to reroute most of that traffic onto another fiber link and for the most part, service was not disrupted.

Wireless customers from almost every carrier were also without service, because AT&T's network is used to connect cell towers back to these carriers' respective national networks. Officials also said that residents in the San Jose/Santa Clara region were without emergency 911 service for much of the day.

AT&T said early Friday morning that service had been restored to all of its customers.

San Jose Police Sgt. Ronnie Lopez said that the fiber cut appeared to be deliberate and the police department is treating it as a felony act of vandalism. The FBI has also been briefed on the case, although Lopez said that for now local officials are handling the investigation.

Anyone with information or tips is being asked to call 408-947-STOP.

Marguerite Reardon has been a CNET News reporter since 2004, covering cell phone services, broadband, citywide Wi-Fi, the Net neutrality debate, as well as the ongoing consolidation of the phone companies. E-mail Maggie.
advertisement
 
Business supplies and services can get expensive. Get smart spending tips and learn about new cost-saving opportunities for your business
Recent posts from Wireless
New Verizon ad calls iPhone 'misfit toy'
Apple said to be working on 'world-mode' iPhone
Is Verizon's new early-termination fee anti-consumer?
Sesame Street, Droid get Google's love
Slow start for the Motorola Droid?
Smartphone market unfazed by recession
eBay's Skype sale gets go-ahead with settlement
GetJar: The unknown app store leader
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (37 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by scott_currier April 10, 2009 3:16 PM PDT
I hope that they catch the people who did this. The other question that needs to be asked is why there wasn't enough redundancy to keep this from turning into a serious problem?
Reply to this comment
by chuchucuhi April 10, 2009 3:49 PM PDT
oh just cuz...well it depends on who laid the fiber in the first place, the cost of the enviromental impact study to lay new fiber, finding enough employees who know what they are doing, etc. etc. Redundancy is great but its expensive and when you have an oligopoly you don't have to worry as much about someone canablizing your customers.
by tln256 April 10, 2009 6:25 PM PDT
I think there was redundancy. From what I've read, it sounds like the perps cut both sides of a diverse fiber ring. Sounds like someone knew what they were doing.
by viper396 April 11, 2009 12:14 AM PDT
@scott_currier, there were four cables. How much redundancy is necessary?

I think it safe to assume that whomever did it had insider knowledge in order to know exactly what and where to cut to kill the entire system.
by bobanavrin April 12, 2009 8:46 AM PDT
I don't think many people on this page understand diversity. Diversity is two or more completely different cable routes .If service was cut on a diverse ring it looks like an inside job. They would have to know the route the fibers take to know what manholes to enter.
by Maccess April 13, 2009 6:34 AM PDT
Redundancy needn't be yet another fiber optic cable. It can be wireless, it can be a route through another telco. that's the problem when each telco isn't really interested in building the internet. Instead, each is building their own private network connected to the internet backbone. This wouldn't have happened if the interconnections are at the city block level using multiple technologies: Cable, Fiber Optic, wireless, etc.
by Bevenson May 29, 2009 4:52 PM PDT
Given the obvious "insider" knowledge required to pull off a multi-cut, multi-locatoin attack, it is clear that the intruders here were very well versed in what the cables were (they were not mistakenly looking for cooper to steal), and what impact the cuts would have on the whole communicatins network. I underatand that there is/was a concurent labor disput with the communicatons workers union and management. It is pretty clear that these guys decided to make a bold statement. It obviously when way too far..

Interestingly, I am in the intrusion deteciton business and there are mature electronic means currently available to detect the initial intrusions into the cable vaults and to detect the (pre-event) distrubances of the fiber even over very long distances. Future Fibre Technologies a well respected global player in the outdoor security business manufactures Secure Link www.fft-usa.com which uses just a few of the existing dark fibers in the communications bundle to "self-protect" the entire cable and the pipes or conduits along the path even over runs of 50 miles with out any field electronics or power required. Any attempt to disturb the cable (well before any cut has even taken place) is reported over the fiber itself to a central monitoring point where precise location data down to about 50 feet) is displayed along with exact GPS cooridinates. Company personnel or law enforcement can then respond in time to esily stop the event. This kind of ultra-expensive prank, an innocent accident by an unknowing contractor or even actual terrorist activities can be easily and cost effectively detected and monitored well before any damage or disruption of service occurs. Fuuny that so much emphasis is being placed on cybersecurity when a simple pair of wire cuttters and access to a man hole can bring the whole system down. Europe and even South America have recognized these huge gaps in the protection of public networks and these regions have already begun to address these threats (including oil, gas and water pipelines) even ahead of us.
by The_happy_switcher April 10, 2009 3:47 PM PDT
This will rank right up there in effectiveness with these other famous bounties/search for perpetrators:
1. OJ will look for 'real' killers.
2. Microsoft offers bounty for catching virus writers.

Good luck with that, AT&T, really.
Reply to this comment
by Perry_Clease April 10, 2009 3:58 PM PDT
$250,000 could be enough to rat someone out.
by viper396 April 11, 2009 12:29 AM PDT
@AppleRocks1963 you never actually check your facts do you? While not 100% effective history has proven that bounties are one of the most common ways to catch criminals. More people have been caught by bounties then not.

..and are you even capable of posting without bringing up Microsoft somehow? Still pathetically stuck on your anti-Microsoft vendetta aren't you?
by Lerianis3 April 11, 2009 10:55 PM PDT
Well, viper396 is right, but he misses a salient point: the addition of a 'bountry' or reward also increases the chance of someone turning in someone who is........ innocent.
by AlexKasper April 10, 2009 3:51 PM PDT
First place to look: Union bosses. The AT&T union contracts for the people who fix this stuff expired on Sunday.
Reply to this comment
by Thumper01060 April 10, 2009 4:42 PM PDT
That's disgusting. Union bosses had nothing to do with this. It of course is possible that there is a nut amongst the 110,000 cwa employees that are now being asked to give back in every area of the contract to a company that made $13 billion last year. It's also possible that there's a nut amongst the company management.
CWA workers take great pride in their work and the network they have built and protect. They would noy do this. Where would it get them?
It is probably just vandalism. Contrary to the company's statement, It is very easy to get into a manhole. Any road worker can get in with a crowbar and a shovel and in most cases can pry up the cover with just a shovel. Manhole hooks are abundantly available. Don't use your anti-union sentiment to belittle hard woirking people and accuse them of crimes.
by tln256 April 10, 2009 6:28 PM PDT
ok thumper, how doid they know to go to 4 different locations to cut both sides of a diverse ring? I manage 17 legacy BellSouth employees and yes, about half of them take pride in their work.
by Lerianis3 April 11, 2009 10:57 PM PDT
Thumper01060, I don't think that this was 'random vandalism' considering that ONLY AT&T's lines were cut. If it was vandalism, they would have cut ever single line down in the manhole, and not in FOUR manholes.
I hate to say it, but this does sounds like the Unions or someone else who is 'in the know' and helped to install these lines are the one who did this.
by Bevenson May 29, 2009 5:08 PM PDT
You are spot on. Any investigation has to point directly to the labor dispute. Access to and knowlege of the cable vaults and specific cable locations, access to the special tools needed to lift these covers, it all sounds very "insider".to me.

Funny, Future Fibre Technologies www.fft-usa.com (and a couple of others) make a laser-based device that attachs to one end of the fiber run and can locate any (even minor) disturbances and provide GPS latitude and longitude to responders as an early warning The same technology protects pipelines and fences at some of the worlds most secure facilities. It's time the telcoms woke up to this threat. These kind of catostrophic distruptions perpetrated so easily won't be acceptable by the public should they occur with any regularity. Having any civil infratructure down for any length of time is so third world, the public will not tolerate it I'm sure.
by mrdparada April 10, 2009 4:09 PM PDT
WHY DOES AT&T HAVE SO MUCH MONEY FOR BOUNTY HUNTING, BUT IS TRYING TO SHIFT HUGE HEALTHCARE COST TO THERE EMPLOYEES? THEY WANT TO CUT AT&T EMPLOYEES PAY, BUT HAS ALL THIS MONEY TO BOUNTY HUNT. IT DOESNT MAKE SENSE!!
Reply to this comment
by Maelstorm April 10, 2009 4:24 PM PDT
First of all, you need to learn how to operate your caps-lock key. Second, the answer to your question, can be summed up in two words: Corporate Greed. The rich get richer and the poor get screwed.
by Jurassic974 April 10, 2009 4:24 PM PDT
They want to cut?? How about they already DID cut their pay. Already being told don't expect any type of raise this year. But still the company shows billions of dollars in profit every quarter. But what is one to do right? If you aren't happy you can just quit and be unemployed like thousands of others.
Reply to this comment
by Lerianis3 April 11, 2009 10:58 PM PDT
Personally, I think that it is time for some worker's rights laws. The right to a raise every year, the right to medical insurance, and (most importantly) the right to not be fired without cause!
by thelemurking April 13, 2009 6:26 AM PDT
I'm in agreement with Leriannis3. On top of that, there needs to be a universal law on insurance. Of the 3 hospitals close by, my insurance only covers costs at 1. So if I were in an accident that was closer to the other 2, I'm sort of screwed. It's not like I will be like I CAN'T GO HERE, TAKE ME TO THE MEDICAL CENTER DOWN TOWN THAT'S 20 MINUTES FURTHER AWAY. Recently my girlfriend's insurance dropped coverage on her therapist without telling her and then she was hit with a huge bill and forced to go out seeking another therapist that would accept her insurance.

Health-care should be health-care and any legitimate insurance company should cover it's part regardless of where you go.
by blafouille April 10, 2009 5:13 PM PDT
With all the screw up bills from this company it will be hard to find them and lucky if he does not happen again....
Reply to this comment
by katoosh April 10, 2009 5:25 PM PDT
I ditched ATT for Magic Jack. Best thing I ever did. I am now on vacation in South Africa. Brought my Magic Jack along. I have been making phone calls all day long to America for free as I have a high speed connection down here in South Africa. Phone rings here when someone calls me. What better could you ask for. It costs $20.00 per year
Reply to this comment
by BGXterra April 10, 2009 6:53 PM PDT
Yes MagicJack is great. i sent one overseas to my family for virtually free international calls
by CA1900 April 12, 2009 7:41 PM PDT
If the entire data network is cut off, your Magic Jack dies right along with your internet service. (I use a VOIP provider [PhonePower] as well, but understand that every solution still depends on a network to support it.)
by dennisl59 April 10, 2009 6:46 PM PDT
The people who did this are already back in Communist China having tea and laughing their ***** off.
Reply to this comment
by renopanther April 11, 2009 2:39 AM PDT
This focus on 'terrorism' or 'cyber-vandalism' is actually quite silly and a new invention. In reality, MOST crimes are about money. This was a surgical strike that disabled 911/EMS, cell phones, internet i.e. this was a COMMUNICATIONS blackout. Something Big went down. Somebody was operating under the cover of electronic darkness. We don't have the full story here. And given banks's tendencies to cover stuff up, we might never get the full story, unless someone slips up or some third party sells out for cash. I think the caper was revealed and the true victims are using AT&T reward money as a way of trying to flush out the criminals.
Reply to this comment
by rc2250 April 11, 2009 7:48 AM PDT
You would think someome has an issue with AT&T for some reaason. Gosh, I can not imagine how that could happen. I mean they give free wire taps and help monitor private communication, so what more could anyone ask....

I wonder if AT&T has anymore fiber optic cables buried underground...
Maybe they should up the reward before it gets really expensive, or perhaps they should figure out how they pisssssed somebody off and stop doing that.
Reply to this comment
by chuck_whealton April 11, 2009 9:47 AM PDT
I heard somebody say that the criminals who did this may have "insider knowledge".

They may very well have. I wouldn't be the least bit shocked to find it's somebody that AT&T laid off. How ironic, no money to pay people but it's OK to shell out $250k of stockholder funds to do something that law enforcement is aready paid to do.
Reply to this comment
by Eholler April 11, 2009 10:16 AM PDT
Insider knowledge is almost a given, or at least really good surveillance. To gut all for major cables (we aren't talking one fiber per cable here) of a metropolitan ring, nice job. I think the union and other crime explanations are probably equally possible unfortunately. As for the union demands/claims. Well there are plenty of AT&T managers who make 25k to 50k range that already pay much higher health care costs and have had their pay frozen twice in the past 5 years while health care benefits got worse. I'm talking everything from administrative assistants, to accountants, to engineers who can splice fiber and terminate cable, and lets not forget most of the IP network guys and outsource guys. Remember them when you are calling managers at AT&T "Evil Fat Cat Overlords Who Only Want To Screw the Working Folks." you're actually talking mostly about people who make the same as the Union guys, but pay more of their benefits. The Evil Overlords are like 10 guys. Won't most of the 13 billion go to shareholders, and back into things like UVerse and Mobile so AT&T can survive the lose of the core business anyway?
Reply to this comment
by Lerianis3 April 11, 2009 11:01 PM PDT
No, most of the 13 billion would NOT go to shareholders or into those other businesses. I've seen this ******** argument before, and that is exactly what it is: ********.
The fact is that most of the dollars do go to shareholders..... but only the people who own MILLIONS of dollars worth of shares, and therefore will get a disproportionate amount of this money, which should be required to be put back into hiring more workers, increasing the services of AT&T, etc.
As I have said before: 99% of the money given to people as money from owning stock N E V E R gets back into the economy at large.
by dennisl59 April 12, 2009 8:11 AM PDT
And this is Day Number What?...And Still Nothing after the Reward was Upped?. I still contend that the people who did this are back in China, drinking tea and laughing, laughing, laughing.
Reply to this comment
by thelemurking April 13, 2009 6:35 AM PDT
Maybe someone didn't like AT&T working as the RIAA's little police dog...
Reply to this comment
by QASIMARA April 13, 2009 10:54 AM PDT
We lco me to the ho tel California. Let the Halo Wars commence.
Reply to this comment
by hassan_bin_sober April 13, 2009 10:55 AM PDT
Couldn't think of a more deserving victim than AT&T. Eat S-H-I-T & die!
Reply to this comment
by jeremyjohnson72 April 14, 2009 11:30 AM PDT
ATT Report Card

F- = Customer Service. Horrendous Call Center in Bangalore India or Manila. Employees are Barely Audible. They can?t under stand what you?re trying to tell them and just use a script, They cant articulate a solution for your problem and talk like they have a mouth full of marbles.
F-= Network Redundancy. They should have Dual-ring sonet redundancy. Cable cuts happen all the time, THE OTHER RING SHOULD BE ROUTED AND BARRIED AT A DIFFERENT LOCATION. They should be able to reroute critical government services, but were unable to do so.
F-= Privacy of customer information. Call centers in other countries, some 3rd work countries who pirate 90% of intellectual property and media property have your personal Information.
F-= DSL Service, Just wait until you on hold with a call center then given a script or promise for credit for an outage, Simple fact that when SBC bought ATT then they bought Bell South, they have to many call centers that DO NOT COMMUNICATE WITH EACH OTHER.

B-ATT Wireless Cell. They have the best phones available from, I-Phone to Samsung Texture bad thing you have to buy a 2 year contract. The roll over minuets is great also however they do expire.

D+= ATT Land Lines. They rip people off with to many bogus charges my Grand Parents were paying 80 per month for the last 30 years, I had there land line ported to there cell phone to save them money. Then ATT calls with the sales pitch, they should of done that 10 years ago.
B+ ATT U-Verse. It is not true Fiber to the house, it is fiber to the pole then copper to the house. Simple fact that Cable going to your house has more More capacity for bandwith for YOUR house then Cat5. There DVR is great and can record up to 4 channels at once Vs. Cables 2 channels However who watches so much TV.
B+ Price or Value of service. The only problem with ATT they try to lock you into a contract like they do with there Wireless, DSL, U-Vers or Dish network.
Reply to this comment
by Thumper01060 April 14, 2009 11:39 AM PDT
Those who think that you have to have insider knowledge to do this much damage are speculating without a thorough knowledge of the facts. Who said this was on a ring? Much of AT&T's facilities are not on rings at all. Also there were several other cuts that didn't do this kind of damage. You can't have it both ways. They knew what to cut here but not elsewhere? The fact is that any cut anywhere may cause a huge outage because it's almost impossible to know the routing of a particular service on a cable. Also, this cut involved several other companies. Very often diversity comes by having part odf a service through one company and part through others but it is not always possible to have completely diverse facilities where they just don't exist. Another thing is that rings can only self heal if nothing else in the network is down at the same time that has taken part of the ring for restoration. AT&T used to dispatch on all troubles but now to save money they only dispatch on priority one outages. If a protection line is down there is no dispatch after hours. Don't believe AT&T when they say their stuff is all diverse. I know of one local ring that goes through 14 towns and several different companie's facilities to complete it's diversity. Some is buried some is arial cable company facilities. There are troubles on this ring all of the time but better facilities jsut don't exist.
As I said in a post somewhere earlier. I've worked for AT&T for 42 years and have never met a union employee who would not turn in a fellow worker for vandalism. The person who did it is obviously disturbed wheter they are union or not but CWA oes not condone vandalism.
Reply to this comment
(37 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

FAQ: Buying the right Windows 7 upgrade

Readers still have lots of questions on just which version of the software they need to buy in order to upgrade their PC. CNET News tries to offer some answers.

N.Y. lawsuit details Intel's 'largesse' toward Dell

Attorney General Andrew Cuomo's federal antitrust case filed Wednesday alleges a longstanding symbiotic relationship between Intel and Dell.

About Wireless

Check out the latest wireless news on CNET News, featuring the latest news on cell phones, mobile gear, VOIP, and internet access via broadband and wireless connections.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Wireless topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right