May 17, 2006 7:38 AM PDT
News sites fight to keep spying hearing open
- Related Stories
Verizon sued for alleged NSA cooperationMay 15, 2006
FAQ: NSA's data mining explainedMay 12, 2006
EFF reaches out to D.C. with new officeApril 27, 2006
Yahoo on NSA surveillance: No commentFebruary 15, 2006
Gonzales: NSA may tap 'ordinary' Americans' e-mailFebruary 6, 2006
AT&T sued over NSA spy programJanuary 31, 2006
Editing tips from the NSAJanuary 24, 2006
Bush allies defend NSA surveillanceJanuary 24, 2006
CNET Networks (publisher of News.com), Wired News, and the California First Amendment Coalition are sending a letter (click for PDF) to U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker, saying the hearing should remain open because the "surveillance at the heart of the case presents issues of enormous public interest and importance."
On Tuesday, AT&T's attorneys asked the judge (click here for PDF) to close the hearing "during any discussion of its trade secrets or confidential information."
The Electronic Frontier Foundation, a digital-rights group in San Francisco, filed a class action lawsuit in January, claiming that AT&T illegally cooperated with the Bush administration's secret eavesdropping program. EFF has obtained documents from a former AT&T employee that it believes buttress its case--but which the telecommunications company says contain trade secrets and proprietary business information.
"Given the tremendous amount of public interest in this case, no part of the proceedings should be closed to the public," said Sharon Le Duy, CNET's general counsel. "We believe it's important to defend our First Amendment right to bear witness to these hearings."
CNET, Wired News and the California First Amendment Coalition have retained attorney Roger Myers of Holme, Roberts & Owen. A second set of media organizations, including the San Jose Mercury News, also is planning to send an attorney--Karl Olson of Levy, Ram & Olson--to the hearing, which is set be held in federal district court in San Francisco.
An attorney for AT&T asked the judge for a "brief telephone conference" on Tuesday afternoon to discuss the mechanics of closing the courtroom. The judge denied the request for a conference call, but AT&T could renew its request during Wednesday's hearing.
The Bush administration has tried to halt the lawsuit, saying that permitting the suit to proceed could jeopardize "military and state secrets." Wednesday's hearing will address AT&T's motion requesting the return of its documents and EFF's competing request to make them public.
7 commentsJoin the conversation! Add your comment